DaleClark

iTrader: (55)

Saw this in a video the other day -


It's a 19mm socket that is much thicker and heavier. When you use an impact gun with it has more of an effect due to the extra mass. Going to get one at some point, would be interested if it helps removing the front 19mm pulley bolt.

Dale

cr-rex

iTrader: (114)

that boi thicc

GoodfellaFD3S

iTrader: (213)

Seems to me it would most definitely help...... along with the hottest torch you can find

DaleClark

iTrader: (55)

Yeah my normal method is torch it then put a 6' cheater pipe on it and a flywheel lock to hold the engine still. Works but it's interesting.

It's always funny to me that people get more worked up over the flywheel nut than the front pulley bolt. Hands down that pulley bolt is WAY harder to remove.

Dale

IRPerformance

iTrader: (41)

I use this with a Milwaukee 1/2 M18 impact I have yet to come across a front bolt or flywheel that it would not remove. At nearly 1/3 the price the Lisle might be worth a shot for the hobbyist.

Ceylon

iTrader: (3)

Interesting thread, think I might invest in one of these. I recently had to remove my front bolt and ended up with a 6ft bar to break it loose as my gun wouldn't touch it!

Zepticon

iTrader: (1)

But the listing says its for Honda.

DaleClark

iTrader: (55)

19mm is 19mm

Honda crank pulley bolts are also famous for being a pain to remove. You have to remove them to do a timing belt. I've done that job twice on our previous Honda Odyssey's and it is a challenge to get that bolt off.

Regardless I don't see any reason why that wouldn't fit.

Dale

Pete_89T2

iTrader: (4)

^True for the RX7/13B applications, though in other applications where the bolt is more deeply recessed into a smaller diameter pulley/hub opening, the larger outside diameter of the socket might not fit. Just eyeballing those two sockets, it looks like both might give me problems if I tried to use them on my kid's '03 Protege5 hub bolt - also a timing belt job step.

TeamRX8

iTrader: (2)

I was going to suggest just welding some mass to the outer end of a lower cost impact socket … no different than cutting a slot in a standard impact socket for removing a neutral/reverse sensor switch.
.

DaleClark

iTrader: (55)

So I got one of these for Christmas and had my first opportunity to use it.

No dice.

This was on a Mazda-build RX-8 engine. Heated up the bolt, hit it with the impact gun and this socket, no movement. Breaker bar with 4' of cheater pipe and that was good to go, though.

I have a decent air impact gun. Hell, it did the flywheel nut no sweat.

I think this may help with a real He-Man impact gun but don't expect a miracle cure. Breaker bar and cheater pipe never let me down.

Dale

DaveW

I saw that when you 1st posted it. Being a nerdy engineer type, I wondered if it would help or hinder nut/bolt removal. Depending on the impact wrench, socket, and nut characteristics it could be either way. The impact wrench uses a heavy internal flywheel-like device triggered by intermittent air pressure torque. To do this it accelerates the "flywheel" which then rotationally hammers on the wrench square drive.

If you remember your physics courses, the greater the ratio of the impacting mass vs the impacted mass, the faster the impacted mass will move. This happens both inside the wrench, then from the square drive to the socket, and finally from the socket to the nut. So the effectiveness of impact on the nut depends on the relative rotational inertia of all 3 masses.

That's why I had my doubts on a heavy socket's effectiveness.

TeamRX8

iTrader: (2)

actual reality and real science are always getting in the way, guess it makes sense for certain people wanting to ban it …

.

nashman69g

iTrader: (3)

DaleClark

iTrader: (55)

Interesting! I haven't watched that channel in a while, going to need to catch up on it . Thanks for posting that!

That socket looks to be interesting for sure.

Dale

nashman69g

iTrader: (3)

interesting thing was when you made this post, I immediately thought of this video that I watched a week or so before your post. So, I figured you saw this and decided to order in and make the post…but I guess not.

BlkBrd464

The Milwaukee M18 impact was one of the best investments I've made....