View Poll Results: How accurate?
Not at all!
7
38.89%
Can be used, but not very accurate.
7
38.89%
Somewhat useful
3
16.67%
Definately 100% useful
1
5.56%
Voters: 18. You may not vote on this poll
Narrowband A/F gauge?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Upstate NY
Posts: 559
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Narrowband A/F gauge?
This has been discussed in random places, but I thought I would start a new thread to get all the collective thoughts. Is a narrowband (stock) O2 sensor to an aftermarket A/F gauge worth looking at? Is it at all accurate?
#2
Queer
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Formerly in the Ass end of the pacific.
Posts: 742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have a GReddy one that, while not used for tuning, can be very helpful. In the event my engine goes lean I will immediately notice it on my gauge and will then have the chance to let up. For the most part it just sits in the rich area when on boost and may twitch towards stoich so in my case, as a piece of equipment that can keep me informed of diaster, I like it. It is also great for tuning while crusing. I tuned it on a trip I took down the highway and ended up getting about 23mpg for the highway
#3
Fok mi
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Sioux Falls, SD
Posts: 892
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Cosmo Donk
I have a GReddy one that, while not used for tuning, can be very helpful. In the event my engine goes lean I will immediately notice it on my gauge and will then have the chance to let up. For the most part it just sits in the rich area when on boost and may twitch towards stoich so in my case, as a piece of equipment that can keep me informed of diaster, I like it. It is also great for tuning while crusing. I tuned it on a trip I took down the highway and ended up getting about 23mpg for the highway
I have a GReddy one that, while not used for tuning, can be very helpful. In the event my engine goes lean I will immediately notice it on my gauge and will then have the chance to let up. For the most part it just sits in the rich area when on boost and may twitch towards stoich so in my case, as a piece of equipment that can keep me informed of diaster, I like it. It is also great for tuning while crusing. I tuned it on a trip I took down the highway and ended up getting about 23mpg for the highway
#4
Queer
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Formerly in the Ass end of the pacific.
Posts: 742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Oh, straight up single wire, yah, worthless. It is designed to do what it does, closed loop operation
And yes, the GReddy is 4 wire so it is heated, but most people will still say it is worthless But as I said, I use it as an emergency meter
And yes, the GReddy is 4 wire so it is heated, but most people will still say it is worthless But as I said, I use it as an emergency meter
#5
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by Digi7ech
The Narrow bands will only work durig WOT since the O2 sensor only funstions at those points.
The Narrow bands will only work durig WOT since the O2 sensor only funstions at those points.
Originally posted by bl|nk
If you're talking about the Autometer disco light of an a/f meter .. it's worthless.
If you're talking about the Autometer disco light of an a/f meter .. it's worthless.
i've heard of the fact the wiring they use which is very thing can pick up interference.
Read Cosmo Donk's first post, so far he's the only one who knows what he's talking about. A/F gauges are a useful monitoring tool if you understand exactly what you're seeing and know how O2 sensors work. Most here don't seem to...
Trending Topics
#10
Zoom Zoom Boooom
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Freakmont, CA
Posts: 987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Cosmo Donk
Oh, straight up single wire, yah, worthless. It is designed to do what it does, closed loop operation
And yes, the GReddy is 4 wire so it is heated, but most people will still say it is worthless But as I said, I use it as an emergency meter
Oh, straight up single wire, yah, worthless. It is designed to do what it does, closed loop operation
And yes, the GReddy is 4 wire so it is heated, but most people will still say it is worthless But as I said, I use it as an emergency meter
- Dana "if it's from Japan triple the $$$"
#11
trying to build a racecar
The real problem is the range in which the stock sensor is accurate. They are really only good around 14.7:1 So using them for tuning isn't really going to get you very far. You could use it to tell you if you are going (dangerously) lean, but that's about it.
You really need a WB for tuning.
Good luck
You really need a WB for tuning.
Good luck
#12
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by Digi7ech
SO when does the stock O2 run then?
SO when does the stock O2 run then?
#15
Fok mi
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Sioux Falls, SD
Posts: 892
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"First, about the stock O2 sensor: As others have said, it is designed to zero in on the 14.7:1 A/F ratio the catalytics like to see. Second, it has a total range of 0-1 volts. What others have not said is that a huge percentage of that range is dedicated to A/F ratios near that 14.7:1 ideal.
To be specific, about the 70% of the O2 sensor's output range (about .14v to .8v) corresponds to an a/f ratio range of roughly 14.5:1 to 15:1. Thus, you have only about 30% of the O2 sensor's range remaining to describe anything richer or leaner than that. Looking only at the richer end of the spectrum, and limiting that to the A/F range of 10:1 to 13:1 (where all performance tuning takes place), you only have a paltry one tenth of one volt to work with.
Now, smart people can make gauges sensitive enough to accurately read within a tenth of a volt, but there is another problem. The central 70% of an O2 sensor's range is very stable over the normal range of exhaust temperatures. The outer 30% of the range (including the rich end) is not. This is especially bad news for owners of rotary cars. Taking a lead from the software of my Electromotive system, I would guess that A/F meters are made assuming exhaust temps in the 550-600C range. Rotaries routinely operate in the 800s under boost. Finally, it has been my experience that manufacturers of O2 sensors don't care much about accuracy in the "performance range." Cars are not referring to O2 sensor output when the pedal is to the metal anyway, so there is no reason for manufacturers to pay a lot of attention to it. Some O2 sensors simply give up producing voltages in the range where you need them. "
"These have been around for a long time. They typically divide the entire O2 sensor range into 1/10 volt increments. The 8th LED will come on at .8 volts. I have one unofficial chart claiming that this corresponds to an a/f ratio of 13.2:1. I have another graph (Electromotive again) that shows .8 volts corresponding to more like 13.8:1. Going to the 9th LED, the first source says it is 12.7:1, while the second source says it is more typically 13.1:1. It is rare that any actual A/F information is printed on these gauges. Most just tell you where 14.7 is, then give rough guidance of which direction is lean, and which is rich. My old K&S meter shows an arrow pointing toward 12.8, but seems to be placed in a purposefully vague position.
Is there any use at all for a 10-LED A/F meter? Sure. Lots of engines (even 3rd gen engines) have died because of a failure (clogged fuel filter, for instance) that put the engine in a lean condition. Also, these little gauges will cycle when the engine management system is in closed loop mode (using the O2 sensor to find 14.7:1). Even when tuning something as sensitive as an aftermarket engine management system, one of these little gizmos can be handy for seeing momentary problems such as a badly adjusted acceleration enrichment, or what is happening when you are trying to tune around optimal cruise conditions at 14.7:1. "
To be specific, about the 70% of the O2 sensor's output range (about .14v to .8v) corresponds to an a/f ratio range of roughly 14.5:1 to 15:1. Thus, you have only about 30% of the O2 sensor's range remaining to describe anything richer or leaner than that. Looking only at the richer end of the spectrum, and limiting that to the A/F range of 10:1 to 13:1 (where all performance tuning takes place), you only have a paltry one tenth of one volt to work with.
Now, smart people can make gauges sensitive enough to accurately read within a tenth of a volt, but there is another problem. The central 70% of an O2 sensor's range is very stable over the normal range of exhaust temperatures. The outer 30% of the range (including the rich end) is not. This is especially bad news for owners of rotary cars. Taking a lead from the software of my Electromotive system, I would guess that A/F meters are made assuming exhaust temps in the 550-600C range. Rotaries routinely operate in the 800s under boost. Finally, it has been my experience that manufacturers of O2 sensors don't care much about accuracy in the "performance range." Cars are not referring to O2 sensor output when the pedal is to the metal anyway, so there is no reason for manufacturers to pay a lot of attention to it. Some O2 sensors simply give up producing voltages in the range where you need them. "
"These have been around for a long time. They typically divide the entire O2 sensor range into 1/10 volt increments. The 8th LED will come on at .8 volts. I have one unofficial chart claiming that this corresponds to an a/f ratio of 13.2:1. I have another graph (Electromotive again) that shows .8 volts corresponding to more like 13.8:1. Going to the 9th LED, the first source says it is 12.7:1, while the second source says it is more typically 13.1:1. It is rare that any actual A/F information is printed on these gauges. Most just tell you where 14.7 is, then give rough guidance of which direction is lean, and which is rich. My old K&S meter shows an arrow pointing toward 12.8, but seems to be placed in a purposefully vague position.
Is there any use at all for a 10-LED A/F meter? Sure. Lots of engines (even 3rd gen engines) have died because of a failure (clogged fuel filter, for instance) that put the engine in a lean condition. Also, these little gauges will cycle when the engine management system is in closed loop mode (using the O2 sensor to find 14.7:1). Even when tuning something as sensitive as an aftermarket engine management system, one of these little gizmos can be handy for seeing momentary problems such as a badly adjusted acceleration enrichment, or what is happening when you are trying to tune around optimal cruise conditions at 14.7:1. "
#17
Fok mi
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Sioux Falls, SD
Posts: 892
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by NZConvertible
In installed correctly, wrong.
In installed correctly, wrong.
it has 3 wires. a red (12v+), black (ground), and purple (tie in with o2 sensor.
Most people will pull this from the large white wire coming out of the ECU. (can't think of the pin off hand since I pulled my autometer a/f gauge out over a year ago).
The wiring from the autometer gauge is a bit on the small size which could possibly get interference from any larger 12v wire. Hense why you don't run your RCA's for a stereo on the same side as you run your 12v power to the amp. So unless you clip the wire, run shielded to the the splice in with the o2 sensor it would be possible to get interference from surrounding wires. The only way I can think of improper installation is not using the correct lead for the o2 sensor or bad connections.
For a vague tuning sure.. but for anything above that I don't see how people would trust their motor to a single wire sensor that has variables that could seriously affect it's readings (temp, condition, carbon buildup).
#18
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by bl|nk
How would you install it incorrectly?
How would you install it incorrectly?
Most people will pull this from the large white wire coming out of the ECU.
For a vague tuning sure.. but for anything above that I don't see how people would trust their motor to a single wire sensor that has variables that could seriously affect it's readings (temp, condition, carbon buildup).
#19
Rotorhead
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
Posts: 9,136
Likes: 0
Received 39 Likes
on
33 Posts
Originally posted by NZConvertible
This is the bit I find frustrating. You're not supposed to use it for tuning in the first place! That's not what it should be used for. As I keep saying, it is a useful monitoring tool, not a tuning tool. If you know what to look for, it can immediately show if the engine's not running properly.
This is the bit I find frustrating. You're not supposed to use it for tuning in the first place! That's not what it should be used for. As I keep saying, it is a useful monitoring tool, not a tuning tool. If you know what to look for, it can immediately show if the engine's not running properly.
Originally posted by Travis R
You really need a WB for tuning.
You really need a WB for tuning.
#20
Fok mi
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Sioux Falls, SD
Posts: 892
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I agree with what the scuderiaciriani site says about the autometer a/f gauge for being good for warning signs of something failing. Other than that I just have known it as an annoyance in my interior of lights going back and forth. on the scuderiaciriani site it was discussed about how it can be modified to make it more useable.
A wideband gives you an easier way of targeting a projected a/f ratio with more accuracy.
A wideband gives you an easier way of targeting a projected a/f ratio with more accuracy.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
The1Sun
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
7
09-18-15 07:13 PM
kryan9
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
2
09-15-15 10:11 PM
t-von
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
9
09-10-15 01:56 PM
The1Sun
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
0
09-07-15 10:21 PM