NRS Rotorsports ceramic seal test results
#277
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
NRS 3mm 2 pc Ceramic Power Seals are ready
Well the 3mm 2 pc seals are complete, let the testing begin!
Gaby will have the base dyno figures next week on the 3mm 1 pc seals and once completed we will install the 3mm 2 pc seals for a direct comparison.
The 2mm 2 pc seals will be about another week for completion as I have some detailing to finish as well as QC on them. Pete from Rice Racing will begin the "street" portion of the testing very shortly after receiving them.
I will be in contact with Issy from Select Maz soon to arrange the 2 pc seals for the "road race" portion of the testing.
Below are pics of the 3mm 2 pc seals
Gaby will have the base dyno figures next week on the 3mm 1 pc seals and once completed we will install the 3mm 2 pc seals for a direct comparison.
The 2mm 2 pc seals will be about another week for completion as I have some detailing to finish as well as QC on them. Pete from Rice Racing will begin the "street" portion of the testing very shortly after receiving them.
I will be in contact with Issy from Select Maz soon to arrange the 2 pc seals for the "road race" portion of the testing.
Below are pics of the 3mm 2 pc seals
#278
Rotary Reborn!
iTrader: (3)
I'm just curious. Why are there different shades of colours in that batch?
Also I've heard of someone else up your way (Alberta) has also made ceramic seals. Is this true? Or are you the only one.
Thanks,
Ian
I've seen a motor pulled apart that had ceramic seals after almost a full race season. These seals did not have a mark on them and appeared to be extremely friendly to the housings. i have no idea where these seals came from but they were the same colour of yours.
Also I've heard of someone else up your way (Alberta) has also made ceramic seals. Is this true? Or are you the only one.
Thanks,
Ian
I've seen a motor pulled apart that had ceramic seals after almost a full race season. These seals did not have a mark on them and appeared to be extremely friendly to the housings. i have no idea where these seals came from but they were the same colour of yours.
#280
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There have always been slightly different shades in the material. This does not in any way affect the performance.
The only other ceramics I have seen here were some that came from a lot of core engines purchased by a guy in Calgary. They were green in color and were definetly not as good as these ones.
The seals you saw from the tear down could be mine I don't know.
The only other ceramics I have seen here were some that came from a lot of core engines purchased by a guy in Calgary. They were green in color and were definetly not as good as these ones.
The seals you saw from the tear down could be mine I don't know.
#283
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2pc seals on the way down under
Well, the 2 pc seals are on the way down under. I have equipped Pete with a set of 3mm 2pc and a set of 2mm 2pc. Plus he has some customer built engines that have 2mm 1pc and 3mm 1pc seals in them. So basically he will have 4 engines for testing all using the same set-up and all the work done by Pete, porting, tuning etc. Pete will record all the data both short and long term over these engines.
Also on the way to Pete is a 2mm 2pc set for Scott Flemming's car built by Select Maz. Issy tells me Scott's car as well as Ryan's car have been running the same set of 1pc NRS seals for the past 3 years. Ryan runs to 10,000 rpm regularly. Scott... 3 time National Champion and recently won his class again.
A soon as I can arrange with Gaby I will get the 3mm 2pc seals to him for the Colon car, should be next week.
Also on the way to Pete is a 2mm 2pc set for Scott Flemming's car built by Select Maz. Issy tells me Scott's car as well as Ryan's car have been running the same set of 1pc NRS seals for the past 3 years. Ryan runs to 10,000 rpm regularly. Scott... 3 time National Champion and recently won his class again.
A soon as I can arrange with Gaby I will get the 3mm 2pc seals to him for the Colon car, should be next week.
#286
Rotary Enthusiast
Hello Sven
Do u also sell seals for 3 rotor engines? Or would i need to buy 2 2rotor sets?
I have decided to go with a 3 rotor setup instead of a 2 rotor PP turbo setup. So if it's possible to buy for a 3 rotor it would be great.
JT
Do u also sell seals for 3 rotor engines? Or would i need to buy 2 2rotor sets?
I have decided to go with a 3 rotor setup instead of a 2 rotor PP turbo setup. So if it's possible to buy for a 3 rotor it would be great.
JT
#290
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not after developing the hard faced springs. Check out pg 3 for pics of them compared to stock springs.
Last edited by Glassman; 10-11-07 at 11:05 AM. Reason: added quote
#291
Just in time to die
iTrader: (1)
Theres only one issue with that whole thing and believe me it's not critisism. Spot on tune and solid motor don't account for other mechanical failures that can and do happen even to the best out there. Don't even mention the guy on the street that is far from the best out there. Ceramics can break, and do break, and that means chances for damaged turbine wheels, rotors, and rotor housings. So If you had to deal with a mechanical failure, and wind up having to blow something and your just a kid with a limited budget, wouldn't your prefer to pay the labor on only a seal that bends versus a expensive seal plus potentially a housing, a rotor and a turbine as well? Suddenly your bill just got a whole lot higher. To the average guy on the street $600 bucks for seals and not having to worry about replacing his BB turbine wheel or a rotor housing on top of just replacing a seal is a honest, upfront, feel it now, savings. I'm tired of the arguement to be honest, of band aid this and that, be it seals or AI, or whatever, and believe me when I sincerely say this is in no way knocking you or your product. I've seen ceramics(not yours personally) break and take out internals. To say they wont is being dishonest, and I'm not saying you are, or that you are claiming it. I've heard people say unbreakable seals wont handle boost, yet I know guys running around 50psi on them overseas. That is more than enough for the street guy. Will they wear as well as ceramics over the long haul? I highly doubt it. But honestly how many backyard built cars(which or the majority) last for the long haul. Most are just pieces of junk at this point. (It sucks, I see it daily.) I think you make a great product, I think you have proven it more than adequately. I think each product be it yours, or others each have their merits and their markets. I think it only does a diservice to you to mention others products. And I'm not endorsing yours, or whoevers seals. I'm just making a observation.
#292
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey, I'm just shedding a different perspective here highlighting what my seals have over every other steel seal including Factory seals........they don't bend. Do I have your permission to say that
Right, not knocking my product or saying I'm dishonest.........then why say it. Seeing how this is your first post on this thread it looks like that's exactly what you came on here to do. You are right about one thing I have never claimed that.
If someone hides behind their own words in the very next sentence then they would be considered a coward. Believe me when I say I'm not saying you have ever been or are a coward.
How does highlighting the ceramics benefits over steel seals doing me a disservice? The whole point of ceramics is to compare their advantages to other steel seals. That's what makes them different and set's them apart.
Hey, if I am way off on your motives then I apologise for that. I won't however apologise for having a superior product.
I'm tired of the arguement to be honest, of band aid this and that, be it seals or AI, or whatever, and believe me when I sincerely say this is in no way knocking you or your product. I've seen ceramics(not yours personally) break and take out internals. To say they wont is being dishonest, and I'm not saying you are, or that you are claiming it.
If someone hides behind their own words in the very next sentence then they would be considered a coward. Believe me when I say I'm not saying you have ever been or are a coward.
How does highlighting the ceramics benefits over steel seals doing me a disservice? The whole point of ceramics is to compare their advantages to other steel seals. That's what makes them different and set's them apart.
Hey, if I am way off on your motives then I apologise for that. I won't however apologise for having a superior product.
#293
And the Revolution...
What the hell does AI have to do with anything? What are you bandaiding? You're saying AI and ceramics are a temp solution to what, eventual engine failure? Well hot damn, as far as I know they don't make an engine that doesn't break when you shove too much boost down its throat. AI and ceramics allow you to push that envelope even further before the engine failure though. Are you saying that when bendable seals fail they don't mess anything up? As far as I'm concerned and I'm sure anyone building an engine worth a **** is behind me in saying that I'd rather have the seals that last longer and are more resistant to detonation. And if I can do that even safer by running a little bit of water into the intake then **** yes I'm gonna do it. Heat is the major killer of rotaries and the main reason behind detonation, preignition, knock, yadda yadda, I want the seals that handle the heat, and the water or meth that kills the heat. That might just be me though.
#294
And the Revolution...
Oh and for the record, regular joe on the street doesn't have a BB CHRA, and if he does, he's serious, and he's gonna get quality products I hope. I'm not gonna spend that much on a turbo and not increase the margin of safety by injecting a little water. I'm gonna do it on my BNR and they're not as expensive as a lot of folks are doing.
#295
Just in time to die
iTrader: (1)
What the hell does AI have to do with anything? What are you bandaiding? You're saying AI and ceramics are a temp solution to what, eventual engine failure? Well hot damn, as far as I know they don't make an engine that doesn't break when you shove too much boost down its throat. AI and ceramics allow you to push that envelope even further before the engine failure though. Are you saying that when bendable seals fail they don't mess anything up? As far as I'm concerned and I'm sure anyone building an engine worth a **** is behind me in saying that I'd rather have the seals that last longer and are more resistant to detonation. And if I can do that even safer by running a little bit of water into the intake then **** yes I'm gonna do it. Heat is the major killer of rotaries and the main reason behind detonation, preignition, knock, yadda yadda, I want the seals that handle the heat, and the water or meth that kills the heat. That might just be me though.
Wow
It was a simple point I was making obviously above your head for some reason. I'll make it simple for you.
So you have your spot on tune and need not worry about detonation. If that is the case what is your need for a expensive seal? Stock 2 piece seals can easily handle the wear of mileage and power of 90+% of users on this board. It's been done over and over and over. Are they a perfect solution? Hardly... So the other arguement is what... why bother with seals that don't break? It's band aid fix? How many 700whp+ 13b's have you put together? Ever had a pump, or injector fail during a hard run? What good did your spot on tune and perfect built motor do you then? So what benefit did I gain when the ceramic breaks? I spent more on a seal and now possibly more on the parts it took out. (Anyone who has been around enough of these knows sometimes you win, sometimes you lose when it comes to wether or not your broken seal will take anything else out. No seal when it breaks can be guaranteed to not damage turbines or other parts. ) Or the other option... possibly I spent less on a seal that handles the power and if I have such a failure I don't have to play the wait and see what all I damaged game. Am I losing out on the wear properties of ceramics? Sure. Could there be other benfits I would lose out on as well? Sure. But I didn't lose a expensive seal or the parts that most likely got damaged as well on top of the labor. What you choose to not read is I'm not knocking Sven or his product. Nor am I endorsing someone elses, which is hardly what can be said of some in this thread. I'm simply saying to say the other side has no merit is not needed. Sven makes a good product and it sells itself by be a proven performer. Sven I have no problem with you getting these posts removed. It wasn't my intention for it to turn into a pissing match with forum nitwits.
-S-
Last edited by Zero R; 10-16-07 at 09:40 PM.
#296
Just in time to die
iTrader: (1)
Hey, I'm just shedding a different perspective here highlighting what my seals have over every other steel seal including Factory seals........they don't bend. Do I have your permission to say that
Right, not knocking my product or saying I'm dishonest.........then why say it. Seeing how this is your first post on this thread it looks like that's exactly what you came on here to do. You are right about one thing I have never claimed that.
If someone hides behind their own words in the very next sentence then they would be considered a coward. Believe me when I say I'm not saying you have ever been or are a coward.
How does highlighting the ceramics benefits over steel seals doing me a disservice? The whole point of ceramics is to compare their advantages to other steel seals. That's what makes them different and set's them apart.
Hey, if I am way off on your motives then I apologise for that. I won't however apologise for having a superior product.
Right, not knocking my product or saying I'm dishonest.........then why say it. Seeing how this is your first post on this thread it looks like that's exactly what you came on here to do. You are right about one thing I have never claimed that.
If someone hides behind their own words in the very next sentence then they would be considered a coward. Believe me when I say I'm not saying you have ever been or are a coward.
How does highlighting the ceramics benefits over steel seals doing me a disservice? The whole point of ceramics is to compare their advantages to other steel seals. That's what makes them different and set's them apart.
Hey, if I am way off on your motives then I apologise for that. I won't however apologise for having a superior product.
-S-
#297
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For the record I do not think you are a coward and you are certainly entitled to your opinion.
If you do not see the benefit of torque gains, better sealing, maintained sealing, lighter, stronger, much less to non existant wear to rotor housings, rotor grooves and apex seals alike then I am lost to convince you. They are definitely worth every penny as an upgrade.
As you say I am way off on your intentions, if this is true then you already have my apology.
Regards
#298
Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When we first finished the car, we spent 3 days on the dyno trying to figure out different issues, most of which were things related to our intake manifold. Some pin holes and things like that were the first problem. Then after we sorted those out, the car would detonate, and I mean detonate hard. Sounded kinda like an automatic shotgun. I was freaking out, thinking that for sure the motor was done and I had lost a seal with all of that going on. The end result was that 2 of our 4 secondary injectors that were brand new were only pushing out 200cc instead of 1000cc, and they were both on the front rotor! So we corrected that, and the motor was fine! There is no doubt in my mind that we would have lost the engine without these seals in there.
#300
Just in time to die
iTrader: (1)
Right but immediately you felt like I called you a coward didn't you?? So did everyone else I'm sure who has read this. That's my point, your words are suggestive even if that's not what you meant.
For the record I do not think you are a coward and you are certainly entitled to your opinion.
For the record I do not think you are a coward and you are certainly entitled to your opinion.
If you do not see the benefit of torque gains, better sealing, maintained sealing, lighter, stronger, much less to non existant wear to rotor housings, rotor grooves and apex seals alike then I am lost to convince you. They are definitely worth every penny as an upgrade.
-S-