well today i went to start my s4 TII and it didnt crank at first when i turned the key then it started cranking really slow like the battery was dead but i turned the key in the off position and it kept cranking real slow and it sounded really shitty i quick tried to dissconect the battery but it stopped before i got to it...now all it does is make a lound click sound when i turn the key and it wont crank at all...the starter is brand new and before i replaced it it used to do that..i would turn the key and nothing would happen but after a couple trys it would start...so im wondering if this is the starter or a relay or maybe even the ignition in the colum..i did try to pop start it and it fired right up..im stumped what do you guys think?

 

Could be a bad starter. You should bring it back if its new. Was it a rebuild?

 

i also have the same problem with this.. i changed the starter and it still did that.. im just gettin tired of my car =/

 

I have a similar issue. New starter, good battery, good connections, good cables but 60% of the time i have to hit start severaltimes before it will crank. I suspect my ignition switch is bad becaus I drop 5v on the S terminal when starter is acting up. I haven't gone further because I haven't ever had it not start. If anyone know of a common problem with the ignition switches I'm all ears. Good luck.

 

How are your batteries guys?? This causes a lot of probs.

 

Theres a clutch safety switch. (to keep you from starting the car in gear) You might want to check that. If you dont hold the clutch down all the way or if it's not adjusted properly it wont let the starter engage. Also sometimes the switch goes bad.

 

my battery is brand new.. and starter is brand new.. and clutch is brand new lol i never start it in gear and i slam the clutch down 2 the ground.. the car clicks about 5 times b4 i get it 2 crank.. but the engine never turns over..

 

Starter selenoid?? maybe?

 

Battery connections tight and clean?

 

new battery new/rebuilt starter and i have good tight connections....and my clutch safety switch doesnt work i dont have to hold the clutch in to start it.....and like i said this usually doesnt happen and when it does it cranks after a couple trys now it doesnt crank at all?

 

its a bad starter. Sometimes even new ones go bad or even more so used ones. I went through this on Easter Day!

 

damn is it possible that the clutch safety switch or the ignition is causeing this?

 

and another question will the factory securty system cause the car not to start because i noticed the light was flashing on the security light maybe its ******* up or something

 

If the security light is flashing when you are starting the car, this is not good. The security will disable the starter so you cant start the car.

 

can i just unplug the security box to fix that problem? is it under the glove box on a s4?

 

If the starter turns slowly, it's not the security system or clutch switch. Probably a bad starter in that case.

 

it turned slowly the first try but now it dosent crank at all

 

the starter was new but the guy said that it had a faulty solinoid... i think somethings fucked up with my ignition and its causeing it to short out....the new starter sounds really strange and high pitched now...i think the guy who wired up my turbo timer fucked my wireing up because when i put my windows up it makes a buzzing sound in the turbo timer and it trips the ignition and it starts to count down...i dunno wtf is wrong..

 

same problem here. I have 3 starters and they all do the same exact thing. When I turn the key the solenoid will click but the engine wont turn. After a few more tries it might turn over if im lucky but it sounds like the solenoid keeps engaging and disengaging. 3 starters....same thing for every one of them so its a wiring or relay problem for sure. Any ideas? it seems to me the solenoid isnt getting the adequate power it needs.

 

i just replaced my starter, it always started hard and i replaced the battery to no luck so i figured it was the starter and it was.