Currently the tires are 205/60/13, the discs and calipers were changed to rx7 (Now has spacer, possibly for bolt pattern?).

Due to limited choices in the 13 inch tires

I was planning on getting new tires 175/60/13 in the front and 185/60/13 in the back. I was thinking that 185 in the front may still be a bit too wide.
Or
I could try to have a tire shop replace the spacer for a thinner spacer?
Or
Get new tires and rims with a difference off set.
Or
Flare out the fenders again?

Any suggestions?

 

Did you try it without the spacers or will you rub the inboard side? That way you can also check the bolt pattern.