Question: S6/S5 vs. S4 Counterweights Comparision Dimensions and Pics Inside
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Question: S6/S5 vs. S4 Counterweights Comparision Dimensions and Pics Inside
Ok. I think I have the front counterweights figured out. The wider (1.02")is for the S4 rotors and other (0.92") is for the S5/S6 rotors.
My question is what rear counterweight (0.55" wide)do I have in this pic? Is it for the heavier S4 rotors or the lighter S5/S6 rotors?
Thanks
Justin
My question is what rear counterweight (0.55" wide)do I have in this pic? Is it for the heavier S4 rotors or the lighter S5/S6 rotors?
Thanks
Justin
#2
Lives on the Forum
Someone mentioned all rear CW's for FC's are *unbalanced* if you buy them brand new from the Mazda dealer?
This means you need to drill them yourself.
The FC Zenki versus Kouki CW's are identical in size and shape.
Hell, even the weight is only off by a few hundreths of a pound.
-Ted
This means you need to drill them yourself.
The FC Zenki versus Kouki CW's are identical in size and shape.
Hell, even the weight is only off by a few hundreths of a pound.
-Ted
#4
Lives on the Forum
iTrader: (8)
Front counterweights are pretty easy to tell apart. s4 is the thicker one. s5 is the thinner one. s6 has the larger diameter "pad" for the larger needle bearings and spacer. s3 GSLSE weight is even thicker than the s4.
IT's the rear auto weights are are impossible to tell apart visually. They are visually identical from 84-95 and weight only varies by .02lb according to my observations. The only way to make a guess is by observing the drill holes. 1 or 2 holes usually means it's an s4, and 2.5-4 holes usually means it's an s5/6.
Keep in mind rotor weights are not absolute either, so unless you're getting the assembly balanced as a whole it's a moot point most of the time. You could run 2 E weight s4 rotors with s5 counterweights and be okay...because A weight s5/6 rotors weigh right about the same. E is the lightest weight range in a series, and A the heaviest. So even though an s4 rotor is supposed to weigh 10.5lb and an s5/6 is supposed to weigh 9.5lb, in reality an E weight s4 might weigh closer to 10.1lb and an A weight s5/6 rotor might weigh closer to 9.9. So it is not absolute.
IT's the rear auto weights are are impossible to tell apart visually. They are visually identical from 84-95 and weight only varies by .02lb according to my observations. The only way to make a guess is by observing the drill holes. 1 or 2 holes usually means it's an s4, and 2.5-4 holes usually means it's an s5/6.
Keep in mind rotor weights are not absolute either, so unless you're getting the assembly balanced as a whole it's a moot point most of the time. You could run 2 E weight s4 rotors with s5 counterweights and be okay...because A weight s5/6 rotors weigh right about the same. E is the lightest weight range in a series, and A the heaviest. So even though an s4 rotor is supposed to weigh 10.5lb and an s5/6 is supposed to weigh 9.5lb, in reality an E weight s4 might weigh closer to 10.1lb and an A weight s5/6 rotor might weigh closer to 9.9. So it is not absolute.
Last edited by RotaryResurrection; 01-06-06 at 02:30 AM.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thanks! Very informative.
I am planning on cutting about an 1.5" long bevel on the trailing edges of the rotors to increase intake duration. I was both concerned with selecting the right counterweights to modify and also deciding how much material to remove from the counterweights. From the sound of it the engine doesnt seem to respond very badly to a slight unbalance in this rotor/counterweight system. It looks like I will be removing approx. 0.6lb from each rotor. Since I am using FD rotors, I will shoot to remove half of the mass removed from the S5 to S4 counterweights. I also need to see what letter rotors I have.
Justin
I am planning on cutting about an 1.5" long bevel on the trailing edges of the rotors to increase intake duration. I was both concerned with selecting the right counterweights to modify and also deciding how much material to remove from the counterweights. From the sound of it the engine doesnt seem to respond very badly to a slight unbalance in this rotor/counterweight system. It looks like I will be removing approx. 0.6lb from each rotor. Since I am using FD rotors, I will shoot to remove half of the mass removed from the S5 to S4 counterweights. I also need to see what letter rotors I have.
Justin
Originally Posted by RotaryResurrection
Front counterweights are pretty easy to tell apart. s4 is the thicker one. s5 is the thinner one. s6 has the larger diameter "pad" for the larger needle bearings and spacer. s3 GSLSE weight is even thicker than the s4.
IT's the rear auto weights are are impossible to tell apart visually. They are visually identical from 84-95 and weight only varies by .02lb according to my observations. The only way to make a guess is by observing the drill holes. 1 or 2 holes usually means it's an s4, and 2.5-4 holes usually means it's an s5/6.
Keep in mind rotor weights are not absolute either, so unless you're getting the assembly balanced as a whole it's a moot point most of the time. You could run 2 E weight s4 rotors with s5 counterweights and be okay...because A weight s5/6 rotors weigh right about the same. E is the lightest weight range in a series, and A the heaviest. So even though an s4 rotor is supposed to weigh 10.5lb and an s5/6 is supposed to weigh 9.5lb, in reality an E weight s4 might weigh closer to 10.1lb and an A weight s5/6 rotor might weigh closer to 9.9. So it is not absolute.
IT's the rear auto weights are are impossible to tell apart visually. They are visually identical from 84-95 and weight only varies by .02lb according to my observations. The only way to make a guess is by observing the drill holes. 1 or 2 holes usually means it's an s4, and 2.5-4 holes usually means it's an s5/6.
Keep in mind rotor weights are not absolute either, so unless you're getting the assembly balanced as a whole it's a moot point most of the time. You could run 2 E weight s4 rotors with s5 counterweights and be okay...because A weight s5/6 rotors weigh right about the same. E is the lightest weight range in a series, and A the heaviest. So even though an s4 rotor is supposed to weigh 10.5lb and an s5/6 is supposed to weigh 9.5lb, in reality an E weight s4 might weigh closer to 10.1lb and an A weight s5/6 rotor might weigh closer to 9.9. So it is not absolute.
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by SureShot
That's just about what I did.
After 2500 miles - so far so good..
After 2500 miles - so far so good..
I have been thinking of this for a while, just wanted to do some more research as to how sensitive the engine is to balancing etc. From my initial calcs we are probably fine. It looks like the weight removed is within Mazda's original casting variance.
https://www.rx7club.com/single-turbo-rx-7s-23/my-beveled-s5-turbo-rotors-%2Apics%2A-505525/
Another innovation I will be trying is posted here:
https://www.rx7club.com/single-turbo-rx-7s-23/my-twin-scroll-ssac-manifold-505519/
Justin
Trending Topics
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
FYI for this thread
In regards to:
I did this. I removed approx. 30g from each rotor. Pics are here: https://www.rx7club.com/showthread.php?t=505525
However I decided NOT to remove any material from the counterweights. This is why:
Justin
Originally Posted by pistonsuk
I am planning on cutting about an 1.5" long bevel on the trailing edges of the rotors to increase intake duration. I was both concerned with selecting the right counterweights to modify and also deciding how much material to remove from the counterweights. From the sound of it the engine doesnt seem to respond very badly to a slight unbalance in this rotor/counterweight system. It looks like I will be removing approx. 0.6lb from each rotor.
However I decided NOT to remove any material from the counterweights. This is why:
Originally Posted by pistonsuk
I also weighed these before and after:
Rotor 1=> Letter="C" => Before=>4342.11g After=>4312.68g Net=>29.43g
Rotor 2=> Letter="B" => Before=>4377.57g After=>4347.83g Net=>29.74g
As seen above this should not pose any vibration issues as far as counterweights are concerned. Mazda allows up to 2 letters difference in a factory build. The weight difference between this "C" and "B" rotor is 35.46g. This is more than I removed (~30g)!
Rotor 1=> Letter="C" => Before=>4342.11g After=>4312.68g Net=>29.43g
Rotor 2=> Letter="B" => Before=>4377.57g After=>4347.83g Net=>29.74g
As seen above this should not pose any vibration issues as far as counterweights are concerned. Mazda allows up to 2 letters difference in a factory build. The weight difference between this "C" and "B" rotor is 35.46g. This is more than I removed (~30g)!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rgordon1979
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
40
03-15-22 12:04 PM
Jeff20B
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
73
09-16-18 07:16 PM
tiger18
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
9
09-03-15 08:27 PM
counter, counterweights, dimensions, identification, interior, pics, rear, rotor, rotors, s4, s5, s6, size, weight, weights