engine rebuilding rotary vs. piston
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: detroit
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
engine rebuilding rotary vs. piston
which is easier to rebuild in your guys' opinion, im new to this rotary stuff. just doing some research, feel free to elaborate on whatever you think i need to know.
thanks
thanks
#3
Dont like it? I dont care
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Gold's Gym
Posts: 931
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I personally think the piston motor is easier because of the larger amount of knowledge out there. Jim bob doesn't exactly rebuild a rotary in his backyard much like he would a chevy smallblock. Piston motors are what I was raised on so I'd be more familiar with those.
#5
50mpg - oooooh yeah!
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
rotaries would cost the most, due to the cost of the gaskets (not a lot of aftermarket companies would make them - you'd mainly have to get dealer ones)
But how many moving bits do rotary engines have to go wrong?
# x2 Rotors
# eccentric driveshaft
now compare that to a standard 4cl 8v piston jobbie:
# x4 pistons
# x4 camrods
# driveshaft
# cam
# x8 valves
# x8 valve springs
# and all the other timing stuff
a rotary has 3 main bits to go wrong when taking it apart, a piston has more than 26 that can either be bent, broken, or put in wrong.
So if nothing need replacing, and you have a full set of gaskets, I would say the rotary would be the easiest to rebuild
But how many moving bits do rotary engines have to go wrong?
# x2 Rotors
# eccentric driveshaft
now compare that to a standard 4cl 8v piston jobbie:
# x4 pistons
# x4 camrods
# driveshaft
# cam
# x8 valves
# x8 valve springs
# and all the other timing stuff
a rotary has 3 main bits to go wrong when taking it apart, a piston has more than 26 that can either be bent, broken, or put in wrong.
So if nothing need replacing, and you have a full set of gaskets, I would say the rotary would be the easiest to rebuild
#7
Old [Sch|F]ool
Rotaries are easier (less measuring) but piston engines are cheaper. You could buy all of the parts needed to do a proper rebuild on many boingers for less than the cost of a single rotor housing.
I was asked recently to rebuild an engine for someone. I quoted an absurdly low labor price, because I felt bad about the parts cost. $1100 for for the hard seals and gasket set. We ain't even bought new housings yet ($500 each, should use two) or rotors (at least one is bad, another $500 or so each). It'd be cheaper to buy a complete running RX-7 and put its engine in the car, then part out the rest. (Or let weeds and small trees grow through it in the backyard, depending on your neighborhood and/or the tolerance of other people in your household)
Economics sucks, don't it.
I should specify that the cost problem isn't due to it being a rotary, it's due to Mazda's grab-your-ankles pricing strategy for parts. Talk to old timers, many of 'em will tell you about how prices for engine parts went up about TENFOLD, two-odd decades ago. They haven't been getting lower, either.
I was asked recently to rebuild an engine for someone. I quoted an absurdly low labor price, because I felt bad about the parts cost. $1100 for for the hard seals and gasket set. We ain't even bought new housings yet ($500 each, should use two) or rotors (at least one is bad, another $500 or so each). It'd be cheaper to buy a complete running RX-7 and put its engine in the car, then part out the rest. (Or let weeds and small trees grow through it in the backyard, depending on your neighborhood and/or the tolerance of other people in your household)
Economics sucks, don't it.
I should specify that the cost problem isn't due to it being a rotary, it's due to Mazda's grab-your-ankles pricing strategy for parts. Talk to old timers, many of 'em will tell you about how prices for engine parts went up about TENFOLD, two-odd decades ago. They haven't been getting lower, either.
Last edited by peejay; 07-22-03 at 05:21 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ncds_fc
New Member RX-7 Technical
1
08-15-15 10:06 AM
KAL797
Test Area 51
0
08-11-15 03:47 PM