Compression Test
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Compression Test
I found this video on You Tube on how to perform a compression test on an RE using a conventional compression tester.
Is this the next best way to perform a compression test on an RE if an RE compression tester is not available?
I will be performing this test Tuesday, because my engine is idling low, is low on power, and stalls sometimes when I'm coming to a stop. Sometimes the engine does not restart after the engine is shut off after driving around. It will start after it sit for an hour though.
Is this the next best way to perform a compression test on an RE if an RE compression tester is not available?
I will be performing this test Tuesday, because my engine is idling low, is low on power, and stalls sometimes when I'm coming to a stop. Sometimes the engine does not restart after the engine is shut off after driving around. It will start after it sit for an hour though.
Last edited by S4 Vert; 03-31-13 at 11:03 PM.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Comression Tests
Here are the results from my compression tests I performed today.
I'm not too sure about the readings even after watching them countless times .
What are your thoughts?
I'm not too sure about the readings even after watching them countless times .
What are your thoughts?
#6
Top Down, Boost Up
iTrader: (7)
For the rear rotor video, it looks like the cranking speed might have dropped after the first ~10 seconds of cranking, which may explain why the pulses drop to around 60 psi.
Otherwise, both videos appear to show relatively even pulses around 75-80 psi. Was the throttle open, and was the engine warm? Having a fully charged battery is also important. Minimum spec in the manual is something like 85 psi, but there will be some variation between gauges. Length of the hose connected also plays a role.
Otherwise, both videos appear to show relatively even pulses around 75-80 psi. Was the throttle open, and was the engine warm? Having a fully charged battery is also important. Minimum spec in the manual is something like 85 psi, but there will be some variation between gauges. Length of the hose connected also plays a role.
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ah! I knew I was forgetting a step, I forgot to hold the throttle wide open. The battery is good, the engine was warm, but cooled down a little since I had to prep for the compression test. The connection/plug that was inserted in the spark plug hole was short like the one in the top You Tube video. It did not have the same length of threads as the spark plug threads, the hose is about a 1' to 1' 1/2" long.
Trending Topics
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For the rear rotor video, it looks like the cranking speed might have dropped after the first ~10 seconds of cranking, which may explain why the pulses drop to around 60 psi.
Otherwise, both videos appear to show relatively even pulses around 75-80 psi. Was the throttle open, and was the engine warm? Having a fully charged battery is also important. Minimum spec in the manual is something like 85 psi, but there will be some variation between gauges. Length of the hose connected also plays a role.
Otherwise, both videos appear to show relatively even pulses around 75-80 psi. Was the throttle open, and was the engine warm? Having a fully charged battery is also important. Minimum spec in the manual is something like 85 psi, but there will be some variation between gauges. Length of the hose connected also plays a role.
#9
Junior Member
iTrader: (1)
I am about to do this test for my 90 vert and would like to know if you need to disconnect the CAS while performing the test as well? The manual says to, but some confirmation would be helpful. Thanks for this thread because I was using that first vid as a starting point also.
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Awesome
I am about to do this test for my 90 vert and would like to know if you need to disconnect the CAS while performing the test as well? The manual says to, but some confirmation would be helpful. Thanks for this thread because I was using that first vid as a starting point also.
I will follow up again.
#13
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Your good man . The two lower pulses followed by an above 90psi pulse is good .
I hope my retest with the throttle wide open and CAS disconnected will get me similar results .
I hope my retest with the throttle wide open and CAS disconnected will get me similar results .
#14
Retired Moderator, RIP
iTrader: (142)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Smiths Falls.(near Ottawa!.Mapquest IT!)
Posts: 25,581
Likes: 0
Received 131 Likes
on
114 Posts
I'd just pull the EGI fuse instead of disconnecting the CAS.
That connector is a pain in the ***.
You just don't want Spark ,or fuel,(haha!),when testing for compression...Ftt,fft,fftt..Woosh..(holy crap!)
That connector is a pain in the ***.
You just don't want Spark ,or fuel,(haha!),when testing for compression...Ftt,fft,fftt..Woosh..(holy crap!)
#15
Senior Member
maybe it's my hearing/vision getting old but to me the needle from both 'S4 Vert''s and 'Lonely Driver''s is not bouncing evenly on every pulse.
to me there is skeeping going on. I like to back off the schrader valve a bit to bleed off some pressure which minimizes the needle's tarvel. Makes it easier for me to see what the needle does on every pulse. I also suggest hooking up vacumm gauge to see where the #s are @ idle.
p.s. 'S4 Vert', notice 'Lonely Driver''s RPM is higher. That will give higher #s.
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.
to me there is skeeping going on. I like to back off the schrader valve a bit to bleed off some pressure which minimizes the needle's tarvel. Makes it easier for me to see what the needle does on every pulse. I also suggest hooking up vacumm gauge to see where the #s are @ idle.
p.s. 'S4 Vert', notice 'Lonely Driver''s RPM is higher. That will give higher #s.
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.
Last edited by Clubuser; 04-08-13 at 12:02 PM.
#16
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
maybe it's my hearing/vision getting old but to me the needle from both 'S4 Vert''s and 'Lonely Driver''s is not bouncing evenly on every pulse.
to me there is skeeping going on. I like to back off the schrader valve a bit to bleed off some pressure which minimizes the needle's tarvel. Makes it easier for me to see what the needle does on every pulse. I also suggest hooking up vacumm gauge to see where the #s are @ idle.
p.s. 'S4 Vert', notice 'Lonely Driver''s RPM is higher. That will give higher #s.
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.
to me there is skeeping going on. I like to back off the schrader valve a bit to bleed off some pressure which minimizes the needle's tarvel. Makes it easier for me to see what the needle does on every pulse. I also suggest hooking up vacumm gauge to see where the #s are @ idle.
p.s. 'S4 Vert', notice 'Lonely Driver''s RPM is higher. That will give higher #s.
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.
I will retest my compression, because I did not have WOT, and the ignition was not disconnected. Maybe then I will have either a better, or worse compression reading then my first tests.
I think the hot start issues might be from recent repairs I had done to my engine, because before the repairs my engine started on hot starts and did not stall when coming to a stop.
Thank you for the advice and tips, I will follow up this week when I have the time retest.
#18
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
[QUOTE=
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.[/QUOTE]
I thought about what you said about your hot starting issues you had. Is it really possible that my starter could be causing my engine not to start on hot starts? My brother said he had the same issue with his dually, and a new starter had fixed his hot start issues too. My starter is the original unit, so it's possible a new starter may be needed.
The problem I am having on hot starts is the engine will not fire up, the starter cranks the engine and I smell gas instantly. However the engine will not fire up, so I figured it is a compression issue. Because when the engine has time to cool down the metal retracts and creates a better tolerance for the apex seals to create compression (imo).
The longer I drive my car, the idle gets lower and the power falls off and the engine dies when coming to a stop unless I blip the throttle once, or twice. I figured the hotter the irons get they expand causing a gap between the apex seals and irons. And that is where I am loosing compression.
Correct me if I am wrong, I am still trouble shooting and need any and all correct advise I can get.
Thanks
I recently had hot start issues on my rebuild that turned out to be a **** Autozone rebuilt starter that cranked slow. I got a Mazda rebuilt and now cranks on steroids (like 'Lonely Driver''s) and hot start is a thing of the past.[/QUOTE]
I thought about what you said about your hot starting issues you had. Is it really possible that my starter could be causing my engine not to start on hot starts? My brother said he had the same issue with his dually, and a new starter had fixed his hot start issues too. My starter is the original unit, so it's possible a new starter may be needed.
The problem I am having on hot starts is the engine will not fire up, the starter cranks the engine and I smell gas instantly. However the engine will not fire up, so I figured it is a compression issue. Because when the engine has time to cool down the metal retracts and creates a better tolerance for the apex seals to create compression (imo).
The longer I drive my car, the idle gets lower and the power falls off and the engine dies when coming to a stop unless I blip the throttle once, or twice. I figured the hotter the irons get they expand causing a gap between the apex seals and irons. And that is where I am loosing compression.
Correct me if I am wrong, I am still trouble shooting and need any and all correct advise I can get.
Thanks
#19
Senior Member
^^^^
make sure your battery connections are clean. Hook up a charger set to start assist next time you do the test. this will rule out insufficient voltage as the cause of low RPM.
let's say your hot start issue is low compression. low compression is a function of both mechanical (i.e., poor sealing) and RPM. cranking RPM should be 240-250 RPM. let's say compression shows >95 psi @ 240-250 then at 140-150 RPM compression might come in @ <80 psi. At 95 psi hot start should not be an issue (specially if less fuel than factory is being injected). At 80 psi it's a challenge.
If it turns out compression is pretty even but borderline w/proper RPM and hot start is still an issue, you should have luck by reducing the amount of fuel during cranking. You can do this by introducing a switch on the 12V start signal wire to the ECU (it's pin 3B on the S4 TII, might be the same for the n/a). By cutting the 12V during cranking, the pulse width is ~1/3.
You need to hook up a vacuum gauge. Cheap way to monitor the engine's health. The high compression n/a motor should be north of 18 inHg at idle.
make sure your battery connections are clean. Hook up a charger set to start assist next time you do the test. this will rule out insufficient voltage as the cause of low RPM.
let's say your hot start issue is low compression. low compression is a function of both mechanical (i.e., poor sealing) and RPM. cranking RPM should be 240-250 RPM. let's say compression shows >95 psi @ 240-250 then at 140-150 RPM compression might come in @ <80 psi. At 95 psi hot start should not be an issue (specially if less fuel than factory is being injected). At 80 psi it's a challenge.
If it turns out compression is pretty even but borderline w/proper RPM and hot start is still an issue, you should have luck by reducing the amount of fuel during cranking. You can do this by introducing a switch on the 12V start signal wire to the ECU (it's pin 3B on the S4 TII, might be the same for the n/a). By cutting the 12V during cranking, the pulse width is ~1/3.
You need to hook up a vacuum gauge. Cheap way to monitor the engine's health. The high compression n/a motor should be north of 18 inHg at idle.
Last edited by Clubuser; 04-10-13 at 11:40 AM.
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I do have an AEM 320 Fuel Pump, I am not using an fpr to regulate the fuel pressure, and I am still using the stock fuel injectors and S4 TII ecu.
So now I am leaning towards too much fuel is being introduced. Which could be the cause of the hot start issues, stalling when coming to a stop, poor fuel mileage and performance??
I will try the measures you have advised me to do during my next compression test.
Thanks
So now I am leaning towards too much fuel is being introduced. Which could be the cause of the hot start issues, stalling when coming to a stop, poor fuel mileage and performance??
I will try the measures you have advised me to do during my next compression test.
Thanks
#25
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: LA
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ah!!
I do have an AEM 320 Fuel Pump, I am not using an fpr to regulate the fuel pressure, and I am still using the stock fuel injectors and S4 TII ecu.
So now I am leaning towards too much fuel is being introduced. Which could be the cause of the hot start issues, stalling when coming to a stop, poor fuel mileage and performance??
I will try the measures you have advised me to do during my next compression test.
Thanks
So now I am leaning towards too much fuel is being introduced. Which could be the cause of the hot start issues, stalling when coming to a stop, poor fuel mileage and performance??
I will try the measures you have advised me to do during my next compression test.
Thanks
Thus is such a relief, because I was worried that the problem was worse.