Synthetic oil........how harmful?
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Boca Raton
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Synthetic oil........how harmful?
Well im a newbie here as can be seen.....so naturally i have a simple question. I have been looking for a decent 3rd gen to buy and think i have found one but the owner has claimed to have run synthetic oil through the motor. The motor only has 30 k miles on it should i be worried?
#3
Full Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Thousand Oaks, CA
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is a debate that has gone on in countless threads on this forum. My brother runs synthetic in his car and so far no problems. Nearly 60K miles on it. I have run dino oil and no problems,11K miles on the engine. Most shops (Tri Point, M2, etc.) sell synthetic oil, mainly Red Line.
Some people will tell you it will kill youe engine and some say it is the only thing to run. Both groups make good arguments. I don't know what is best. Be prepared for a lot of opposing opinions.
Sorry I couldn't actually help answer your question.
Some people will tell you it will kill youe engine and some say it is the only thing to run. Both groups make good arguments. I don't know what is best. Be prepared for a lot of opposing opinions.
Sorry I couldn't actually help answer your question.
#6
Ghost Ride the Whip
My friend and I just rebuilt a 13b for a second gen owner who has used nothing but synthetic oil. When we opened the motor up, we noticed two very distinct detrimental effects of synthetic oil. First, the rotors had synthetic deposits built on them. As you know, synthetic oil doesn't burn, so it leaves a goo like substance behind. This is the same substance on the rotor. Second thing the synthetic oil did to the motor, it literally destroyed the o-rings. When we took it apart, the o-ring was so brittle that it nearly fell apart when we tried taking it off.
Now of course there are also pros to using synthetic oil. Main reason, I run it is because it keeps the oil temperatures lower than dino oil, but at the same time I do not daily drive my car nor expect the motor to last 100,000 miles. If you go to Japan, everyone there is running full synthetic oil in their FD's, but then again, they don't expect the motor to last more than 30,000-40,000 miles. If you are using yoru car for commuting, maybe you should consider just going to mineral oil, if you are into heavy racing, you should switch to synthetic oil.
Now of course there are also pros to using synthetic oil. Main reason, I run it is because it keeps the oil temperatures lower than dino oil, but at the same time I do not daily drive my car nor expect the motor to last 100,000 miles. If you go to Japan, everyone there is running full synthetic oil in their FD's, but then again, they don't expect the motor to last more than 30,000-40,000 miles. If you are using yoru car for commuting, maybe you should consider just going to mineral oil, if you are into heavy racing, you should switch to synthetic oil.
#7
fart on a friends head!!!
its is good damnit!!!!!!!!!! that turbocharger on your fd NEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEDS it!!!!!!!!!!! use a high quality synthetic. . . period. youll never turn back. it runs so much cleaner. it makes a difference. . . trust me. . . and about 8 bagillion other rotary engine powered vehicle owners.
paul
paul
Trending Topics
#8
Blow up or win
Originally posted by 1FooknTiteFD
My friend and I just rebuilt a 13b for a second gen owner who has used nothing but synthetic oil. When we opened the motor up, we noticed two very distinct detrimental effects of synthetic oil. First, the rotors had synthetic deposits built on them. As you know, synthetic oil doesn't burn, so it leaves a goo like substance behind. This is the same substance on the rotor. Second thing the synthetic oil did to the motor, it literally destroyed the o-rings. When we took it apart, the o-ring was so brittle that it nearly fell apart when we tried taking it off.
Now of course there are also pros to using synthetic oil. Main reason, I run it is because it keeps the oil temperatures lower than dino oil, but at the same time I do not daily drive my car nor expect the motor to last 100,000 miles. If you go to Japan, everyone there is running full synthetic oil in their FD's, but then again, they don't expect the motor to last more than 30,000-40,000 miles. If you are using yoru car for commuting, maybe you should consider just going to mineral oil, if you are into heavy racing, you should switch to synthetic oil.
My friend and I just rebuilt a 13b for a second gen owner who has used nothing but synthetic oil. When we opened the motor up, we noticed two very distinct detrimental effects of synthetic oil. First, the rotors had synthetic deposits built on them. As you know, synthetic oil doesn't burn, so it leaves a goo like substance behind. This is the same substance on the rotor. Second thing the synthetic oil did to the motor, it literally destroyed the o-rings. When we took it apart, the o-ring was so brittle that it nearly fell apart when we tried taking it off.
Now of course there are also pros to using synthetic oil. Main reason, I run it is because it keeps the oil temperatures lower than dino oil, but at the same time I do not daily drive my car nor expect the motor to last 100,000 miles. If you go to Japan, everyone there is running full synthetic oil in their FD's, but then again, they don't expect the motor to last more than 30,000-40,000 miles. If you are using yoru car for commuting, maybe you should consider just going to mineral oil, if you are into heavy racing, you should switch to synthetic oil.
I would especially be interested in the rotor bearings.
On a side note, Mazda used a special synthetic oil made just for them in the 91 LeMans Racer which of course won big time. After teardown the Mazda engineers were amazed how little wear took place. It was about $25.00 a QUART, and you can still buy it! Me? - straight 30W dino, but I live in a warm climate and change it about every 1500 miles or so.
#10
In general, synthetics burn just like mineral (conventional, dyno, whatever) oils do. But certainly there are some that burn cleaner than others in both categories. What kind of synthetic was the owner of the dirty engine running?
There may also be other causes of the apparent problems with that engine. Overheating is likely to harden the o-rings, for instance. It wasn't necessarily the oil that led to the problems you witnessed, though it does seem likely with the deposits. Oil additives, crappy fuel, or an overly rich mixture might contribute to deposits as well.
Lots of people have used synthetic in rotaries for a long time. I wouldn't steer away from buying the car because of sythetic oil. It may even be indicative of a higher-than-normal attention to caring for the car.
-Max
There may also be other causes of the apparent problems with that engine. Overheating is likely to harden the o-rings, for instance. It wasn't necessarily the oil that led to the problems you witnessed, though it does seem likely with the deposits. Oil additives, crappy fuel, or an overly rich mixture might contribute to deposits as well.
Lots of people have used synthetic in rotaries for a long time. I wouldn't steer away from buying the car because of sythetic oil. It may even be indicative of a higher-than-normal attention to caring for the car.
-Max
#17
Speed Mach Go Go Go
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: My 350Z Roadster kicks my RX7's butt
Posts: 4,772
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
If I remember correctly, the 15 is for cold starts and the 50 is for extended high temperature periods. 10W-30 is like a med/all purpose comprimise, so to speak.
I was using 10W-30 dyno and mixed 1qt race 50 Royal Purple every 1k. Then I researched the oils and Penzoil is dirtier than Royal Purple, Red Line and Mobil 1.
Now I have decided on 10w-30 & 1qt race 50 RP for summer and 5W-30 & 1qt Race50 for winter. Oh and I spend the extra money on Mobil 1 filter and sometimes substitue Mobil 1 from Costco.
Click below for Mazdatrix's explenation:
http://www.mazdatrix.com/faq/synthetc.htm
I was using 10W-30 dyno and mixed 1qt race 50 Royal Purple every 1k. Then I researched the oils and Penzoil is dirtier than Royal Purple, Red Line and Mobil 1.
Now I have decided on 10w-30 & 1qt race 50 RP for summer and 5W-30 & 1qt Race50 for winter. Oh and I spend the extra money on Mobil 1 filter and sometimes substitue Mobil 1 from Costco.
Click below for Mazdatrix's explenation:
http://www.mazdatrix.com/faq/synthetc.htm
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Cincinnati
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I agree with both sides and see how synthetic can be better, however in the owners manual that came with the car (written by mazda, the people that designed the car) it specificly says not to use synthetics. So until Mazda releases a statement saying the new sythetics are okay, I am going to stick with fossil.
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
#19
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Charlotte
Posts: 552
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mobil 1 15w-50, Redline, or Amsoil....only way to fly....period
the critics of synthetics don't have a leg to stand on, and I believe Mazda recently debunked the whole synthetics in rotaries myth anyway....I'd be very surprised if the RX-8 has any warnings against using it, if anything, synthetics burn cleaner (very low ash)
like max said, regarding the guy who tore down his engine and found "deposits", that could have happened for any number of reasons, including using crap oil in the past, not changing the air/fuel filter, crap gas, etc, etc, etc
synthetic oil rocks, the skeptics are wrong....in a high revving, extremely high temperature turbo engine like the 13B, not using a synthetic is pretty dumb if you ask me, I'll never go back to dino juice
the critics of synthetics don't have a leg to stand on, and I believe Mazda recently debunked the whole synthetics in rotaries myth anyway....I'd be very surprised if the RX-8 has any warnings against using it, if anything, synthetics burn cleaner (very low ash)
like max said, regarding the guy who tore down his engine and found "deposits", that could have happened for any number of reasons, including using crap oil in the past, not changing the air/fuel filter, crap gas, etc, etc, etc
synthetic oil rocks, the skeptics are wrong....in a high revving, extremely high temperature turbo engine like the 13B, not using a synthetic is pretty dumb if you ask me, I'll never go back to dino juice
#20
Synths have evolved considerably since Mazda "banned' them in their rotary engine. One of Royal Purple's head techs races rotaries and uses RP in his own engines. I've used synth in my car since I've owned it (purchased at 9600 miles) and I'm now at 55K running 13psi daily, stock engine stock turbos, producing about 330-340rwhp (for about 1.5 years now). I'm pretty sure synth has done more to help it stay together than tear it to pieces :-)
Michel
Michel
#22
fart on a friends head!!!
just drop this damn discussion. there will never be an end to it. i recommend that the moderators delete any thread that opens up another conversation like this. the key is that everyone has THEIR own reasons. so LET them HAVE their own decisions. LEAVE IT ALONE!!!!!!! this is the most disgusting topic i have come across on the forum.
paul
paul
#23
going ls
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: South Florida
Posts: 602
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by charliegt
I agree with both sides and see how synthetic can be better, however in the owners manual that came with the car (written by mazda, the people that designed the car) it specificly says not to use synthetics. So until Mazda releases a statement saying the new sythetics are okay, I am going to stick with fossil.
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
I agree with both sides and see how synthetic can be better, however in the owners manual that came with the car (written by mazda, the people that designed the car) it specificly says not to use synthetics. So until Mazda releases a statement saying the new sythetics are okay, I am going to stick with fossil.
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: raleigh, nc
Posts: 325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I checked with both amsoil and mobile 1 and they both said that while mazda doesn't recommend sunthetic, they have done extensive testing with the rotary engine and have had great results.
#25
reliable performance
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: MA, USA
Posts: 383
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by charliegt
I agree with both sides and see how synthetic can be better, however in the owners manual that came with the car (written by mazda, the people that designed the car) it specificly says not to use synthetics. So until Mazda releases a statement saying the new sythetics are okay, I am going to stick with fossil.
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
...which was published, where....?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by charliegt
I agree with both sides and see how synthetic can be better, however in the owners manual that came with the car (written by mazda, the people that designed the car) it specificly says not to use synthetics. So until Mazda releases a statement saying the new sythetics are okay, I am going to stick with fossil.
Just my .02 cents
-Charlie
Originally posted by Quik 93 FD
Mazda did release a statement....
Mazda did release a statement....
...which was published, where....?