Attn Engine Builders, Do You Re-Use Main Bearings and/or Rotor Bearings?
#26
rotary sensei
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Virginia
Posts: 2,312
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
New main and rotor bearings increase the break in time. Rarely are they out of spec, when they are we replace them. Using the bearings that have already been broken in to the eshaft is preferred.
Mazdaspeed Tech
"Check for abnormal abrasions or signs of flaking or seizing. The bearing should be replaced if flaking is evident over one-half of its total area. If the old bearing does not have any excessive wear, reuse it, as an old bearing is generally preferred over a new one."
Mazdaspeed Tech
"Check for abnormal abrasions or signs of flaking or seizing. The bearing should be replaced if flaking is evident over one-half of its total area. If the old bearing does not have any excessive wear, reuse it, as an old bearing is generally preferred over a new one."
#27
That is correct. Straight from Racing Beat's tech section:
"Rotor bearings do cause occasional problems during high RPM operation. It is important to use properly clearanced rotor bearings. In general, do not replace rotor bearings when you are re-using rotors unless they are over the recommended clearance or show some damage from dirt, heat, or lack of oil. Our experience has shown that used bearings in good condition are safer than new, untried bearings."
At the bottom, from the rotor bearing section http://www.racingbeat.com/Tech/Tech.Engine.2.htm
Rich, you are not doing your customers any favors by replacing in spec bearing during an engine rebuild. Also, it is not free, you are including it in the cost of the build somewhere. You are not getting the bearings for free and you are not installing them for free.
"Rotor bearings do cause occasional problems during high RPM operation. It is important to use properly clearanced rotor bearings. In general, do not replace rotor bearings when you are re-using rotors unless they are over the recommended clearance or show some damage from dirt, heat, or lack of oil. Our experience has shown that used bearings in good condition are safer than new, untried bearings."
At the bottom, from the rotor bearing section http://www.racingbeat.com/Tech/Tech.Engine.2.htm
Rich, you are not doing your customers any favors by replacing in spec bearing during an engine rebuild. Also, it is not free, you are including it in the cost of the build somewhere. You are not getting the bearings for free and you are not installing them for free.
Last edited by Banzai-Racing; 05-16-10 at 07:12 AM. Reason: punctuation
#28
7th Heaven
iTrader: (9)
the rotor bearing is broken into the eshaft...
you replace the rotor bearing with the new one, but you reuse that old eshaft that had been worn to the old bearing...
i believe it is best only to replace it on an as-needed basis under that circumstance.
unless you have a new e-shaft with a rotor bearings... i fail to see any gain from using a new rotor bearing - esspecially when it will wear at an accelerated rate against your 20 years old worn out e-shaft....
you replace the rotor bearing with the new one, but you reuse that old eshaft that had been worn to the old bearing...
i believe it is best only to replace it on an as-needed basis under that circumstance.
unless you have a new e-shaft with a rotor bearings... i fail to see any gain from using a new rotor bearing - esspecially when it will wear at an accelerated rate against your 20 years old worn out e-shaft....
#29
Original Gangster/Rotary!
iTrader: (213)
Originally Posted by Banzai-Racing
Rich, you are not doing your customers any favors by replacing in spec bearing during an engine rebuild. Also, it is not free, you are including it in the cost of the build somewhere. You are not getting the bearings for free and you are not installing them for free.
I've never seen an engine with fresh bearings spin one for no reason. However, over the years I've seen three (three!) FD engines spin bearings under normal driving conditions, all of them with 90k+ miles. As mentioned, one had already been rebuilt 25k miles ago with 'in-spec' bearings.
We've built over 100 engines, most of them with new bearings, and have had zero (zero) problems. These engines all were original and had the original bearings, and all of them had ~50k+ miles. All showed excessive wear and many had a high percentage of copper showing. Were they in spec? Nope, not the majority of them.
They are installed for free, and the markup on the cost of the bearings is negligible. Frankly I'd rather leave them in there, but in many cases I feel the right thing to do with a new engine build..... is to start with new parts, including new bearings (which are a wear item).
As I've already stated, different strokes for different folks. Let people make up their own minds..... cost/benefit analysis is pretty easy to figure out in this case. I for one don't enjoy arguing for the sake of arguing.
#30
Rotor or no motor
iTrader: (24)
Taking more time to break in for a healthier engine im sure someone serious in the subject is willing to do it.
I personally install(or request to be installed) new bearings in all my rebuilds over the years. never run into the issues Banzai is saying but im sure you guys have seen way more than i have
I personally install(or request to be installed) new bearings in all my rebuilds over the years. never run into the issues Banzai is saying but im sure you guys have seen way more than i have
#31
rotary sensei
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Virginia
Posts: 2,312
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
All showed excessive wear and many had a high percentage of copper showing. Were they in spec? Nope, not the majority of them.
They are installed for free, and the markup on the cost of the bearings is negligible. Frankly I'd rather leave them in there, but in many cases I feel the right thing to do with a new engine build..... is to start with new parts, including new bearings (which are a wear item).
They are installed for free, and the markup on the cost of the bearings is negligible. Frankly I'd rather leave them in there, but in many cases I feel the right thing to do with a new engine build..... is to start with new parts, including new bearings (which are a wear item).
#32
We've built over 100 engines, most of them with new bearings, and have had zero (zero) problems. These engines all were original and had the original bearings, and all of them had ~50k+ miles. All showed excessive wear and many had a high percentage of copper showing. Were they in spec? Nope, not the majority of them.
The fact is that is does not matter if the bearings are 17, 20 or 50 years old. We have customers with cars that have less than 10K original miles on their FDs & FCs, the bearings are not worn out just because they have been sitting in the engine. Most higher mileage FDs are not on their original engines anymore, so even that arguement is moot.
Heat, oil grade, pressure, etc have more to do with bearing wear then mileage or age.
They are installed for free, and the markup on the cost of the bearings is negligible. Frankly I'd rather leave them in there, but in many cases I feel the right thing to do with a new engine build..... is to start with new parts, including new bearings (which are a wear item)..
Rotor and main bearings are $150-$200 depending on where they are purchased, this is not a "negligible" price increase to throw at every engine.
Of course you do.
#33
Original Gangster/Rotary!
iTrader: (213)
Appreciate that, it's always good to hear from other respected engine builders.
Speaking of which, I just got off the phone with Chris Ott from Rotary Performance. When I was active duty Army and stationed out at Fort Hood I spent many weekends there with them. They've been in this game since 1988 and I typically look to Chris and Ari for any advice because I respect their opinion immensely.
In a nutshell, this is what Chris Ott shared with me regarding their practices:
*On FD engines they almost always replace main bearings. Rotor bearings it depends on the condition but more often than not they replace them. Due to their greater surface area they tend to not wear at as high a rate.
*He said that if any copper was showing on the bearing they would absolutely replace them without question.
*They've found that due to early recommended lightweight oil use on original engines as well as typical infrequent oil changes early in the car's life the main bearings in particular bear the brunt of this less than ideal service.
*He said that replacing the main bearings is in his opinion vital to optimal engine health. It takes slop out of the rotating assembly and keeps the rotor more square on the bearing, avoiding any contact of the tips of the rotors with the irons.
*They rarely ship motors out to customers so they're able to run the engines in-shop and with the new main bearings he's found the engines run better.
*He also agreed with me that replacing bearings just makes sense when building a street engine where a customer expects a certain degree of longevity.
Speaking of which, I just got off the phone with Chris Ott from Rotary Performance. When I was active duty Army and stationed out at Fort Hood I spent many weekends there with them. They've been in this game since 1988 and I typically look to Chris and Ari for any advice because I respect their opinion immensely.
In a nutshell, this is what Chris Ott shared with me regarding their practices:
*On FD engines they almost always replace main bearings. Rotor bearings it depends on the condition but more often than not they replace them. Due to their greater surface area they tend to not wear at as high a rate.
*He said that if any copper was showing on the bearing they would absolutely replace them without question.
*They've found that due to early recommended lightweight oil use on original engines as well as typical infrequent oil changes early in the car's life the main bearings in particular bear the brunt of this less than ideal service.
*He said that replacing the main bearings is in his opinion vital to optimal engine health. It takes slop out of the rotating assembly and keeps the rotor more square on the bearing, avoiding any contact of the tips of the rotors with the irons.
*They rarely ship motors out to customers so they're able to run the engines in-shop and with the new main bearings he's found the engines run better.
*He also agreed with me that replacing bearings just makes sense when building a street engine where a customer expects a certain degree of longevity.
#35
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 1,045
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Rich. Next question: it is necessary to yank the motor to replace main bearings?
Also, does anyone believe heavier weight motor oils (e.g. 20w-50) can accelerate bearing wear (particulalry cold start wear)?
Also, does anyone believe heavier weight motor oils (e.g. 20w-50) can accelerate bearing wear (particulalry cold start wear)?
#37
Rotor Head Extreme
iTrader: (8)
Appreciate that, it's always good to hear from other respected engine builders.
Speaking of which, I just got off the phone with Chris Ott from Rotary Performance. When I was active duty Army and stationed out at Fort Hood I spent many weekends there with them. They've been in this game since 1988 and I typically look to Chris and Ari for any advice because I respect their opinion immensely.
In a nutshell, this is what Chris Ott shared with me regarding their practices:
*On FD engines they almost always replace main bearings. Rotor bearings it depends on the condition but more often than not they replace them. Due to their greater surface area they tend to not wear at as high a rate.
*He said that if any copper was showing on the bearing they would absolutely replace them without question.
*They've found that due to early recommended lightweight oil use on original engines as well as typical infrequent oil changes early in the car's life the main bearings in particular bear the brunt of this less than ideal service.
*He said that replacing the main bearings is in his opinion vital to optimal engine health. It takes slop out of the rotating assembly and keeps the rotor more square on the bearing, avoiding any contact of the tips of the rotors with the irons.
*They rarely ship motors out to customers so they're able to run the engines in-shop and with the new main bearings he's found the engines run better.
*He also agreed with me that replacing bearings just makes sense when building a street engine where a customer expects a certain degree of longevity.
Speaking of which, I just got off the phone with Chris Ott from Rotary Performance. When I was active duty Army and stationed out at Fort Hood I spent many weekends there with them. They've been in this game since 1988 and I typically look to Chris and Ari for any advice because I respect their opinion immensely.
In a nutshell, this is what Chris Ott shared with me regarding their practices:
*On FD engines they almost always replace main bearings. Rotor bearings it depends on the condition but more often than not they replace them. Due to their greater surface area they tend to not wear at as high a rate.
*He said that if any copper was showing on the bearing they would absolutely replace them without question.
*They've found that due to early recommended lightweight oil use on original engines as well as typical infrequent oil changes early in the car's life the main bearings in particular bear the brunt of this less than ideal service.
*He said that replacing the main bearings is in his opinion vital to optimal engine health. It takes slop out of the rotating assembly and keeps the rotor more square on the bearing, avoiding any contact of the tips of the rotors with the irons.
*They rarely ship motors out to customers so they're able to run the engines in-shop and with the new main bearings he's found the engines run better.
*He also agreed with me that replacing bearings just makes sense when building a street engine where a customer expects a certain degree of longevity.
Rich I perfectly understand where your comming from by replacing the bearings. When dealing with X amount of customers, it's just added piece of mind. However, we all know those customers will blow the engine by some other means besides bearings now don't we.
#38
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 1,045
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For anyone running used main bearings, I would get a used oil analysis done ASAP, it will give you useful information on how the bearings are wearing (plus other wear metals, % fuel dilution, etc).
#40
Speed Mach Go Go Go
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: My 350Z Roadster kicks my RX7's butt
Posts: 4,772
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Can I jump in here with a related question;
I have a new set of bearing with my lightened & balanced set. I will be getting the rear main race bearings but it just doesn't seem worth replacing the rotor bearings to the race spec when it is something like .0005 more clearance. Expert opinion please?
I have a new set of bearing with my lightened & balanced set. I will be getting the rear main race bearings but it just doesn't seem worth replacing the rotor bearings to the race spec when it is something like .0005 more clearance. Expert opinion please?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
trickster
2nd Generation Specific (1986-1992)
25
07-01-23 04:40 PM