A/F Gauge Worth It?
#1
Y00s a h000
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Central NJ
Posts: 1,913
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A/F Gauge Worth It?
I've heard buying anything but a crazy expensive air fuel gauge is worthless, because they give crappy readouts. Is this true? If not, whats the best affordable one that can give decent readings?
#2
Eat Rice Don't Drive it.
iTrader: (3)
A guage is only as good as its sensor which is where it gets information from. Given our stock O2 sensors are narrow band units they aren't very good for tunning as they only read, as the name hints, a narrow band of Air to fuel ratios because they are meant to optimize fuel ratio's(fuel economy increases) at cruise and low throttle. If you want your own tuning device look for DIY Wide band kits or pre-made kits. These can go for as little as 350 dollars.
Santiago
PS- I had a thread about widebands and engine management systems a while ago. I'll find the link.
Santiago
PS- I had a thread about widebands and engine management systems a while ago. I'll find the link.
#3
Y00s a h000
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Central NJ
Posts: 1,913
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well for tuning i'll probably be taking it somewhere to dyno tune it with a wideband, but I was just thinking something along the lines of telling me if something is way out of wack.
#7
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by Ocelot
...I was just thinking something along the lines of telling me if something is way out of wack.
...I was just thinking something along the lines of telling me if something is way out of wack.
Most people appear to have no clue about that.
Trending Topics
#8
Rotorhead
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
Posts: 9,136
Likes: 0
Received 39 Likes
on
33 Posts
Re: A/F Gauge Worth It?
Originally posted by Ocelot
I've heard buying anything but a crazy expensive air fuel gauge is worthless, because they give crappy readouts. Is this true? If not, whats the best affordable one that can give decent readings?
I've heard buying anything but a crazy expensive air fuel gauge is worthless, because they give crappy readouts. Is this true? If not, whats the best affordable one that can give decent readings?
Originally posted by 1987RX7guy
Well from what I understand about the stock sensor it only goes into its accurate range while cruising at low throttle to optimize "highway mileage"
Well from what I understand about the stock sensor it only goes into its accurate range while cruising at low throttle to optimize "highway mileage"
Modern engine control units and O2 sensors are not able to react fast enough for rapidly changing engine conditions, so the O2 sensor is only used to control fuel delivery at more steady-state conditions. This works out well because the best economy air-fuel ratio is usually pretty close to the stoich mixture. The engine control unit ignores the O2 reading during changing engine conditions, such as acceleration and deceleration.
#9
Rotorhead
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
Posts: 9,136
Likes: 0
Received 39 Likes
on
33 Posts
Originally posted by NZConvertible
Most people appear to have no clue about that.
Most people appear to have no clue about that.
#10
Eat Rice Don't Drive it.
iTrader: (3)
Re: Re: A/F Gauge Worth It?
Originally posted by Evil Aviator
All of the people who don't know how to tune an engine will tell you that you must have a wideband O2 sensor. While this is a good tool, it is not going to instantly make a novice into a pro. If you just want to monitor the engine, or if you are interested in fuel economy, a narrowband O2 sensor will work just fine. The wideband is better for tuning for power because it registers the richer "best power" air-fuel ratios more accurately. However, some of the better tuners that I know don't even use a wideband sensor.
A narrow band sensor is most accurate near the stoich (chemically correct) air-fuel ratio, and it gets less accurate as the scale gets more rich or lean from this point. Also, heat will affect the sensor's output.
Modern engine control units and O2 sensors are not able to react fast enough for rapidly changing engine conditions, so the O2 sensor is only used to control fuel delivery at more steady-state conditions. This works out well because the best economy air-fuel ratio is usually pretty close to the stoich mixture. The engine control unit ignores the O2 reading during changing engine conditions, such as acceleration and deceleration.
All of the people who don't know how to tune an engine will tell you that you must have a wideband O2 sensor. While this is a good tool, it is not going to instantly make a novice into a pro. If you just want to monitor the engine, or if you are interested in fuel economy, a narrowband O2 sensor will work just fine. The wideband is better for tuning for power because it registers the richer "best power" air-fuel ratios more accurately. However, some of the better tuners that I know don't even use a wideband sensor.
A narrow band sensor is most accurate near the stoich (chemically correct) air-fuel ratio, and it gets less accurate as the scale gets more rich or lean from this point. Also, heat will affect the sensor's output.
Modern engine control units and O2 sensors are not able to react fast enough for rapidly changing engine conditions, so the O2 sensor is only used to control fuel delivery at more steady-state conditions. This works out well because the best economy air-fuel ratio is usually pretty close to the stoich mixture. The engine control unit ignores the O2 reading during changing engine conditions, such as acceleration and deceleration.
I understand that a wideband isn't needed for tunning. I have talked to REted and he only uses an EGT guage out on the road for tunning. But I usually tell people to just use a wide band because it makes it less easy to mess up. Its like trying to perform a delicate operation with beer gogles(narrow band) compared to proper perscription glasses(wideband). I guess I also didn't word my explenation of narrowband correctly. :/ I need to work on those skills. But From what I had read on the tech edge site your right on the money. The narrow band only becomes accurate where it counts for econommy of fuel consumption.
Santiago
PS- I'm still learnin cut me some slack. :-/
#11
Rotorhead
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
Posts: 9,136
Likes: 0
Received 39 Likes
on
33 Posts
Re: Re: Re: A/F Gauge Worth It?
Originally posted by 1987RX7guy
I have talked to REted and he only uses an EGT guage out on the road for tunning.
I have talked to REted and he only uses an EGT guage out on the road for tunning.
Originally posted by 1987RX7guy
The narrow band only becomes accurate where it counts for econommy of fuel consumption.
The narrow band only becomes accurate where it counts for econommy of fuel consumption.
Originally posted by 1987RX7guy
PS- I'm still learnin cut me some slack. :-/
PS- I'm still learnin cut me some slack. :-/
#14
Lives on the Forum
Damn, I didn't even know I was being talked about.
Back to the original question...
The AFR gauge is the best gauge to show you if you're too rich or too lean. Do not use this for fine tuning, as it doesn't have the resolution to give you accurate and repeatable results. I recommend the AFR gauge because it's the fastest reacting gauge (for the price) that can tell if you're in TROUBLE (too lean)!
A wide-band will do the same thing, but it requires a lot more money and installation of it's own dedicated sensor.
People will disagree with me, but I stant behind my statements.
-Ted
Back to the original question...
The AFR gauge is the best gauge to show you if you're too rich or too lean. Do not use this for fine tuning, as it doesn't have the resolution to give you accurate and repeatable results. I recommend the AFR gauge because it's the fastest reacting gauge (for the price) that can tell if you're in TROUBLE (too lean)!
A wide-band will do the same thing, but it requires a lot more money and installation of it's own dedicated sensor.
People will disagree with me, but I stant behind my statements.
-Ted
#16
Jesus is the Messiah
About all the gauges are the same accuracy, they all do exactly the same thing, they translate a relitively innacurate, varying voltage. This is whether you get it for $28 from summit (Nine LEDs) or a $100 Nordskog (270 degree sweep gauge).
#17
hey sorry to dig up anther old thread, but im not getting instructions with my afr, how do you hook it up? how does it hook to the o2 sensor, just twist the wires?
and then after its hooked up, is there any other ways to significantly affect/adjust your a/f ratio other than the screw next to the pressure sensor? (87 gxl)
and then after its hooked up, is there any other ways to significantly affect/adjust your a/f ratio other than the screw next to the pressure sensor? (87 gxl)
#20
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by evelhalo
hey sorry to dig up anther old thread...
...im not getting instructions with my afr, how do you hook it up? how does it hook to the o2 sensor, just twist the wires?
and then after its hooked up, is there any other ways to significantly affect/adjust your a/f ratio other than the screw next to the pressure sensor? (87 gxl)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
t-von
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
9
09-10-15 01:56 PM
The1Sun
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
0
09-07-15 10:21 PM