current and potential users of pineapple sleeves, MUST READ
#1
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
current and potential users of pineapple sleeves, MUST READ
**FIRST OF ALL**
I wish to state clearly up front that this is in no way an attack on PR, their products, services, etc. I have much respect for Rob and his products, and am not seeking to damage that reputation in any way.
The purpose of this post is to serve as a warning/advisory to current and future users of this product in regards to installation. Perhaps by posting this information, I can help save someone else from the tragedy that has occured here.
With that said, some background information. This is a freshly rebuilt (by me) GSLSE hybrid engine (stock rotors with new seals, s5 NA rotorhousings, s4 NA irons, streetport on auxiliary ports only). IF you wish to know why I chose this combo for the hybrid, it was because any original stock 1gen rotorhousings will be trashed, and s5's always come out very well in comparison, and would make a better engine in the long run. I used the s4 irons because the s3 irons have smaller ports.
At the same time the engine was rebuilt, the 6PI sleeves were installed, along with a s4 NA intake manifold set for better flow.
Now, I have installed a couple sets of these before in other cars, and always found them to be a fairly tight fit, requiring a lot of effort to press into place in the sleeve. In fact, I put them in my own freshly rebuilt 89 'vert just over 2k miles ago. Recently, upon disassembly of my intake manifold for emissions removal on the 'vert, I found the same failure that I am about to explain below. I did reinstall the sleeves along with a method that I hope will hold them in place better, but after seeing this, Im considering going right back in and taking them out altogether.
Note that no specific directions for installation are given with the sleeves, and none is really needed. The pineapple website says "The fit is extremely tight and ensures the insert will not move. " I, as did most of you guys, took this advice at face value and threw them in the engine. What you're about to see is the result of this, observed in MORE THAN ONE ENGINE.
What you're seeing is the sleeve installed in the port sleeve JUST as it came out of the engine. Note that the insert is free to move about the sleeve. Note also that the insert has been banging away for some time at the rod at the OPPOSING end of the sleeve. Yes, when these were installed, they were tightly pressed into the end of the sleeve and it did not appear possible to get them out even if you wanted to try.
NOte that the above was observed on MORE THAN ONE ENGINE.
I wish to state clearly up front that this is in no way an attack on PR, their products, services, etc. I have much respect for Rob and his products, and am not seeking to damage that reputation in any way.
The purpose of this post is to serve as a warning/advisory to current and future users of this product in regards to installation. Perhaps by posting this information, I can help save someone else from the tragedy that has occured here.
With that said, some background information. This is a freshly rebuilt (by me) GSLSE hybrid engine (stock rotors with new seals, s5 NA rotorhousings, s4 NA irons, streetport on auxiliary ports only). IF you wish to know why I chose this combo for the hybrid, it was because any original stock 1gen rotorhousings will be trashed, and s5's always come out very well in comparison, and would make a better engine in the long run. I used the s4 irons because the s3 irons have smaller ports.
At the same time the engine was rebuilt, the 6PI sleeves were installed, along with a s4 NA intake manifold set for better flow.
Now, I have installed a couple sets of these before in other cars, and always found them to be a fairly tight fit, requiring a lot of effort to press into place in the sleeve. In fact, I put them in my own freshly rebuilt 89 'vert just over 2k miles ago. Recently, upon disassembly of my intake manifold for emissions removal on the 'vert, I found the same failure that I am about to explain below. I did reinstall the sleeves along with a method that I hope will hold them in place better, but after seeing this, Im considering going right back in and taking them out altogether.
Note that no specific directions for installation are given with the sleeves, and none is really needed. The pineapple website says "The fit is extremely tight and ensures the insert will not move. " I, as did most of you guys, took this advice at face value and threw them in the engine. What you're about to see is the result of this, observed in MORE THAN ONE ENGINE.
What you're seeing is the sleeve installed in the port sleeve JUST as it came out of the engine. Note that the insert is free to move about the sleeve. Note also that the insert has been banging away for some time at the rod at the OPPOSING end of the sleeve. Yes, when these were installed, they were tightly pressed into the end of the sleeve and it did not appear possible to get them out even if you wanted to try.
NOte that the above was observed on MORE THAN ONE ENGINE.
#2
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Well, on this rebuilt SE engine for a local friend, it appears the damage went one step further. My theory is that either a) the insert banged away at the rod in the sleeve until it knocked it out of place, allowing it to fall into the engine, or b) the insert banged away at the rod in the sleeve until it cut it in half allowing the pieces to fall inside the engine. Either way, it is clear that the rod from the sleeve went through the engine. No pieces of the rod were recovered from the engine.
Now, these gripping photos are not meant to steer you away from this quality product. What they are meant to do is persuade you to consider opening your intake back up and checking them again to be sure this cant happen to you. My guess is, that if someone fairly competent such as myself can fall victim to this failure, so can many others who have installed them. Im trying to save engines and money here.
I still believe the product design and quality are very good. I believe we should continue to use them. I just think that someone, be it pineapple or one of us, should come up with a bulletproof way to secure these before installation into the engine. Failure to do so, even if they seem nice and tight, can yield the above results.
I am thinking that it might be possible to use some sort of heat rated epoxy in combination with the inserts to keep them secure. Also, it might be possible to use a vise or other clamping device to make dimples in the sleeve itself right in front of the installed insert to prevent movement backwards. The only problem here is doing so without distorting the sleeve itself which could result in the sleeve fitting too tightly and not opening properly or at all. Regardless, I think this issue needs a little extra R & D which is why I made this post. Dont let it happen to you. Check your sleeves today.
Now, these gripping photos are not meant to steer you away from this quality product. What they are meant to do is persuade you to consider opening your intake back up and checking them again to be sure this cant happen to you. My guess is, that if someone fairly competent such as myself can fall victim to this failure, so can many others who have installed them. Im trying to save engines and money here.
I still believe the product design and quality are very good. I believe we should continue to use them. I just think that someone, be it pineapple or one of us, should come up with a bulletproof way to secure these before installation into the engine. Failure to do so, even if they seem nice and tight, can yield the above results.
I am thinking that it might be possible to use some sort of heat rated epoxy in combination with the inserts to keep them secure. Also, it might be possible to use a vise or other clamping device to make dimples in the sleeve itself right in front of the installed insert to prevent movement backwards. The only problem here is doing so without distorting the sleeve itself which could result in the sleeve fitting too tightly and not opening properly or at all. Regardless, I think this issue needs a little extra R & D which is why I made this post. Dont let it happen to you. Check your sleeves today.
#4
ROTOR THAT PUSSY BITCH
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: CANOGA PARK
Posts: 623
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Anybody bought sleeves with inserts from PR??? before they started selling the inserts alone...
PR sold sleeves with inserts in them before... how was the process done by PR... was it welding on the sleeve??? i was thinking maybe brazing the insert on the sleeve...
PR sold sleeves with inserts in them before... how was the process done by PR... was it welding on the sleeve??? i was thinking maybe brazing the insert on the sleeve...
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: dinwiddie VA
Posts: 652
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Nice info kevin,when i recently put my engine back together and installed the sleeves,i noticed they were a little loose fitting so i JB welded the sleeves into place.After seeing those pics im gonna have to pull my ntake just to make sure they are not moving around in there and waiting to muck something up.Once again(and always) very good info from kevin.
#7
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
PR sold sleeves with inserts in them before...
When I heard of the problem they were having with getting useable core sleeves in order to sell their product, I offered to GIVE Rob 32 SETS (64 sleeves) of sleeves FREE, but that wasnt good enough evidently.
Trending Topics
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Parkersburg, West Virginia
Posts: 311
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
He's a guy who works on RX-7's a lot...everytime I've even mentioned a re-build to anyone on this board, he's the person who's been suggested to me, by multiple people. I should think he knows what he's doing...
#11
Lava Surfer
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Kailua, HI
Posts: 2,354
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by hypntyz7
Yes, but they havent done so in nearly a year I believe.
When I heard of the problem they were having with getting useable core sleeves in order to sell their product, I offered to GIVE Rob 32 SETS (64 sleeves) of sleeves FREE, but that wasnt good enough evidently.
Yes, but they havent done so in nearly a year I believe.
When I heard of the problem they were having with getting useable core sleeves in order to sell their product, I offered to GIVE Rob 32 SETS (64 sleeves) of sleeves FREE, but that wasnt good enough evidently.
#16
Do a barrel roll!
iTrader: (4)
When I got my aux. port sleeves, it was when pineapple used to sell the sleeves with the inserts already installed. I have had them in my FC for about a year, and removed them, and they are now in a friends FB. The inserts were still in place and tight. Maybe someone should contact Rob and ask him if there is any type of epoxy that was used when they installed the inserts? I think a 2-stage epoxy would work well, or even drilling a small hole at the base of the sleeve, putting in the insert , and then making a small tach weld to hold in into place.
#17
Rotary Freak
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: MN
Posts: 1,697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for this post Kevin. This needs to be looked into further.
I'm running these sleeves for about 1 year now in my S5. I did just what a member above suggested. I sent Rob my core, and he pressed the sleeves in himself and returned my sleeves back to nice and ready to install.
I'm running these sleeves for about 1 year now in my S5. I did just what a member above suggested. I sent Rob my core, and he pressed the sleeves in himself and returned my sleeves back to nice and ready to install.
#18
Turbo Driver
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Delaware
Posts: 615
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I dunno if I should be worried or not....I'm the one who has rxmfn7's sleeves, and he ran them in his car for some time. I was swapping engines, and he offered to give them to me, since I had my engine apart, to save me from opening it up later on. We took them out of his car, and they looked fine, like brand new. So I threw them in my car.
His were already exposed to use and heat and they held up....I would think if they haven'tdone this yet that they won't in the future, but I'm still not sure.
His were already exposed to use and heat and they held up....I would think if they haven'tdone this yet that they won't in the future, but I'm still not sure.
#20
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
You guys had good ideas for holding the insert in place. Keep in mind that the sleeve and the inside of the iron are a pretty tight fit, and a rollpin inserted through the length of the sleeve would likely interfere with the sleeve's ability to rotate freely. Since the sleeve is so thin, if you ground down the rollpin so that it didnt protrude from the sleeve, it'd barely have any sleeve material to hold onto, and probably wouldnt be as strong as one would think. If you look at where the factory pin goes through the sleeve, youll notice the sleeve is made smaller there, so that the rollpin cant come in contact with the iron, but it can still maintain contact with the sleeve well.
As far as welding, well, not everyone has the ability to weld aluminum.
As for epoxy, well, that's what Im trying now.
As far as welding, well, not everyone has the ability to weld aluminum.
As for epoxy, well, that's what Im trying now.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Dublin, VA
Posts: 593
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by SureShot
A 1/8" roll pin in a drilled hole through the sleeve into the insert would be a simple way to hold it..
A 1/8" roll pin in a drilled hole through the sleeve into the insert would be a simple way to hold it..
Don't want to mess around when there is a possibility of something falling in the engine.
#22
Plastic Jedi
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Kentwood, Michigan
Posts: 583
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OMG I just helped my friend install these in his GXL...
I noticed that they were built on used core sleeves. Perhaps these cores are getting older and not properly cleaned before the ramps are glued in?
Anybody hear from Pineapple yet as far as their responsibility to their customers?
Anyway, I'm going to show my friend these pics right away, and then we will take them right back out and secure those little buggers. Fingers crossed...
I noticed that they were built on used core sleeves. Perhaps these cores are getting older and not properly cleaned before the ramps are glued in?
Anybody hear from Pineapple yet as far as their responsibility to their customers?
Anyway, I'm going to show my friend these pics right away, and then we will take them right back out and secure those little buggers. Fingers crossed...
#23
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
I noticed that they were built on used core sleeves. Perhaps these cores are getting older and not properly cleaned before the ramps are glued in?
IF anything, a used sleeve that is even a little dirty should serve as a deterrent to the insert moving around, since you're bound to have some residual carbon in the corners and cracks that would make it an even tighter fit than on a new sleeve.