The 20000 Mile Question
#1
RX-7 Alumni
Thread Starter
The 20000 Mile Question
I saw some threads talking about this 20K switch but did not definitively answer my question. I don't want to burn up my ECU so here's the question.
Can I ground the L/B wire (F-31 connector) from ECU pin 1O and simulate over 20k mileage to the ECU?
This is for an 1988 Turbo II ECU (N333). I've installed the engine and ECU system into my 84 GSL-SE and that car is not equipped with a 20k switch. Installing the gauge unit is not an option. Currently during my engine break-in I've got the wire disconnected and taped off (the engine is running good and I can't wait to really open it up a bit).
The T2 original cluster gauge unit has about 2.8 ohms thru the switch which isn't much of a load. It looks like to me that the ECU has an internal load on this circuit and just grounding the wire should simulate over 20k miles and not burn up the ECU.
If the switch did supply the load (all 2.8 ohms of it) then the ECU would still see the 12 volts so it doesn't look like this 2.8 ohms is the load on this circuit.
Thanks in advance for your help.
Scott
(edit...remove enormous signature...check your PMs)
Can I ground the L/B wire (F-31 connector) from ECU pin 1O and simulate over 20k mileage to the ECU?
This is for an 1988 Turbo II ECU (N333). I've installed the engine and ECU system into my 84 GSL-SE and that car is not equipped with a 20k switch. Installing the gauge unit is not an option. Currently during my engine break-in I've got the wire disconnected and taped off (the engine is running good and I can't wait to really open it up a bit).
The T2 original cluster gauge unit has about 2.8 ohms thru the switch which isn't much of a load. It looks like to me that the ECU has an internal load on this circuit and just grounding the wire should simulate over 20k miles and not burn up the ECU.
If the switch did supply the load (all 2.8 ohms of it) then the ECU would still see the 12 volts so it doesn't look like this 2.8 ohms is the load on this circuit.
Thanks in advance for your help.
Scott
(edit...remove enormous signature...check your PMs)
Last edited by Aaron Cake; 02-24-04 at 12:54 PM.
#2
Seduced by the DARK SIDE
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Orange Park FL (near Jax)
Posts: 7,323
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Hmm - The FSM wiring chart shows the 20K switch as just an open/close contact that closes after 20K.
I never quite understood why it opens at 100K & closes again at 120K, then again at 200K
I never quite understood why it opens at 100K & closes again at 120K, then again at 200K
Last edited by SureShot; 02-24-04 at 07:20 AM.
#4
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
The only thing I know of that it controls is the PORT AIR solenoid. After twenty grand that solenoid isn't energized anymore.............til 100,000 comes up then it's energized for the next twenty grand. Been there, seen that. Obviously there might be more going on here than the Port Air Solenoid.
#6
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
By the power vested in me......I now grant you permission to ground that wire. You must do it this day. After midnight the permission is withdrawn and you will have to wait another thirty days for permission to do it again, all depending on what mood I'm in at that point in time.
In other words.....your ground or the combination meters ground.....one and the same thing. Go get 'em.
In other words.....your ground or the combination meters ground.....one and the same thing. Go get 'em.
#7
RX-7 Alumni
Thread Starter
Cool, thanks HAILERS--ehh but I gotta wait for engine break-in first--guess I'll have to wait 30 days--oh well.
Yea I thought it was ok, just wanted some confirmation, ya know about taking a 12v wire and grounding it.
thanks again,
Scott
p.s. oh yea, look like I got busted on my sig. No big deal already fixed.
Yea I thought it was ok, just wanted some confirmation, ya know about taking a 12v wire and grounding it.
thanks again,
Scott
p.s. oh yea, look like I got busted on my sig. No big deal already fixed.
Trending Topics
#8
Rotary Enthusiast
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Caldwell,ID
Posts: 968
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
just curious whats with this 20k mile ground biz?
my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?
but what all does it do?
my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?
but what all does it do?
#9
Seduced by the DARK SIDE
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Orange Park FL (near Jax)
Posts: 7,323
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally posted by rxspeed87
just curious whats with this 20k mile ground biz?
my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?
but what all does it do?
just curious whats with this 20k mile ground biz?
my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?
but what all does it do?
Other than that, it looks like an early idea in design whose function later became unneeded.
I grounded mine theorizing if might be holding off my Aux ports & VDI, but that was wrong.
It turned out to be a bad neutral switch connection.
#10
Rotary Enthusiast
Originally posted by SureShot
Hmm - The FSM wiring chart shows the 20K switch as just an open/close contact that closes after 20K.
I never quite understood why it opens at 100K & closes again at 120K, then again at 200K
Hmm - The FSM wiring chart shows the 20K switch as just an open/close contact that closes after 20K.
I never quite understood why it opens at 100K & closes again at 120K, then again at 200K
Hot_Dog
90 RX7 GXL
02 Acura RSX-S
#12
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
*********The 20K miles switch is only active during the first 20K miles of the car's life. It does not reactivate again after 100K, 200K, 300K miles and so on. The 20K mileage switch will recycle after the odometer turns past the 999,999.9 mile mark. It's unlikely that such an event will ever occur.
Hot_Dog
90 RX7 GXL
02 Acura RSX-************88
No, it works just like that. I've got the living proof out there in my driveway. 212,000 miles and the PortAir solenoid is energized. The other car at some obscene figure 144,000 miles and no Port Air activation and the third one at 184,000 and no Port Air activation.
I don't know who started this idea about the 20,000 mile reactivating, but I was a doubter til I looked at my odometer last year and whoa, its true.
I'm anxiously waiting for the next eight grand to turn over on the first vehicle. If there is not a change I'll be sure to say so on this site.
It ain't unlikely. It's so.
Hot_Dog
90 RX7 GXL
02 Acura RSX-************88
No, it works just like that. I've got the living proof out there in my driveway. 212,000 miles and the PortAir solenoid is energized. The other car at some obscene figure 144,000 miles and no Port Air activation and the third one at 184,000 and no Port Air activation.
I don't know who started this idea about the 20,000 mile reactivating, but I was a doubter til I looked at my odometer last year and whoa, its true.
I'm anxiously waiting for the next eight grand to turn over on the first vehicle. If there is not a change I'll be sure to say so on this site.
It ain't unlikely. It's so.
#13
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
****my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?****
No is the answer. BUT it would be interesting if you went out to your car and pulled your PortAir solenoid out and turn the engine on and see if the solenoid pulls the poppet valve *in* or not. It's just an emission thing. That PortAir passage is quite small. Adds extra airpump air to the exaust ports. Not much.
No is the answer. BUT it would be interesting if you went out to your car and pulled your PortAir solenoid out and turn the engine on and see if the solenoid pulls the poppet valve *in* or not. It's just an emission thing. That PortAir passage is quite small. Adds extra airpump air to the exaust ports. Not much.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Syracuse, New York
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by HAILERS
No, it works just like that. I've got the living proof out there in my driveway. 212,000 miles and the PortAir solenoid is energized. The other car at some obscene figure 144,000 miles and no Port Air activation and the third one at 184,000 and no Port Air activation.
No, it works just like that. I've got the living proof out there in my driveway. 212,000 miles and the PortAir solenoid is energized. The other car at some obscene figure 144,000 miles and no Port Air activation and the third one at 184,000 and no Port Air activation.
#15
Rotary Enthusiast
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Caldwell,ID
Posts: 968
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by HAILERS
****my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?****
No is the answer. BUT it would be interesting if you went out to your car and pulled your PortAir solenoid out and turn the engine on and see if the solenoid pulls the poppet valve *in* or not. It's just an emission thing. That PortAir passage is quite small. Adds extra airpump air to the exaust ports. Not much.
****my car just passed 200k so is there something with that ground point that I am going to deal with once again?****
No is the answer. BUT it would be interesting if you went out to your car and pulled your PortAir solenoid out and turn the engine on and see if the solenoid pulls the poppet valve *in* or not. It's just an emission thing. That PortAir passage is quite small. Adds extra airpump air to the exaust ports. Not much.
or is that the thing in the ACV?
anyway to check if it is working without taking it off?
#16
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
Two solenoids on the acv. The fwd one is the PortAirSolenoid. The aft one is the SplitAirSolenoid.
There is 12v on the black/white wire all day long as long *** the key is to ON. What triggers the solenoid is the other wire. It puts a ground on the solenoid from the ECU. That will pull the 12v down to waaay low like 1-2volts. So if you back probe the other wire with everything connected up...you should read 12v if the odometer reads over 20,000 miles but about 1-2volts from 0-20,000 miles.
BAck probe means finding the connector and shoving the probe (or a piece of wire attached to the probe) thru the backside of the connector. Put the negative lead of the meter on any good chassis ground or engine block/whatever.
And the other solenoid, the SplitAirSolenoid, will have 12v all day long UNTIL you put the car in ffith gear, whereupon it drops to 1-2volts. In fifth it opens the SplitAirSolenoid to add air to the Split Air Pipe for the catalytic converter. You don't need to start the engine to see that happen. Just have the key to ON.
There is 12v on the black/white wire all day long as long *** the key is to ON. What triggers the solenoid is the other wire. It puts a ground on the solenoid from the ECU. That will pull the 12v down to waaay low like 1-2volts. So if you back probe the other wire with everything connected up...you should read 12v if the odometer reads over 20,000 miles but about 1-2volts from 0-20,000 miles.
BAck probe means finding the connector and shoving the probe (or a piece of wire attached to the probe) thru the backside of the connector. Put the negative lead of the meter on any good chassis ground or engine block/whatever.
And the other solenoid, the SplitAirSolenoid, will have 12v all day long UNTIL you put the car in ffith gear, whereupon it drops to 1-2volts. In fifth it opens the SplitAirSolenoid to add air to the Split Air Pipe for the catalytic converter. You don't need to start the engine to see that happen. Just have the key to ON.
Last edited by HAILERS; 02-25-04 at 08:22 PM.
#17
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by theloudroom
The port air solenoid and the 20,000 mile switch are SEPERATE wires. They run to seperate pins on the ECU .
The port air solenoid and the 20,000 mile switch are SEPERATE wires. They run to seperate pins on the ECU .
#19
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
*****The port air solenoid and the 20,000 mile switch are SEPERATE wires. They run to seperate pins on the ECU .******
See the NZ explanation above. It's no different than engaging fifth gear which in turn triggers the SplitAir solenoid being energized thru the ECU. Or the signal from the TPS triggering a ground on the Switching or Relief solenoid thru the ECU.
See the NZ explanation above. It's no different than engaging fifth gear which in turn triggers the SplitAir solenoid being energized thru the ECU. Or the signal from the TPS triggering a ground on the Switching or Relief solenoid thru the ECU.
Last edited by HAILERS; 02-26-04 at 07:18 AM.
#20
Rotary Enthusiast
Originally posted by SureShot
When I saw the 20K switch was a seperate 5 wheel odometer, I just jumpered it closed.
No worries..
When I saw the 20K switch was a seperate 5 wheel odometer, I just jumpered it closed.
No worries..
Hot_Dog
90 RX7 GXL
02 Acura RSX-S
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Syracuse, New York
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by HAILERS
*****The port air solenoid and the 20,000 mile switch are SEPERATE wires. They run to seperate pins on the ECU .******
See the NZ explanation above. It's no different than engaging fifth gear which in turn triggers the SplitAir solenoid being energized thru the ECU. Or the signal from the TPS triggering a ground on the Switching or Relief solenoid thru the ECU.
*****The port air solenoid and the 20,000 mile switch are SEPERATE wires. They run to seperate pins on the ECU .******
See the NZ explanation above. It's no different than engaging fifth gear which in turn triggers the SplitAir solenoid being energized thru the ECU. Or the signal from the TPS triggering a ground on the Switching or Relief solenoid thru the ECU.
If you've got a car with 212,000 miles on it in your driveway, go measure the 20k mile switch.
#22
HAILERS
Join Date: May 2001
Location: FORT WORTH, TEXAS,USA
Posts: 20,563
Likes: 0
Received 21 Likes
on
19 Posts
No. That's not right. The ECU is NOT controlling the 20,000 switch. The twenty grand switch, when it switches over twenty grand, puts a ground ON the ECU pin. The ECU then stops putting a ground on the Port Air Solenoid.
It's similar to the fifth gear switch. You put the transmission in fifth gear, which in turn puts a ground on the ECU. The ECU sees the ground and then puts a ground on the Split Air Solenoid.
Oh, the pin 1O with the 212,000 miles shows open with the plug disconnected and with the plug connected shows 12v (no ground results in no voltage drop).
The cars with over 220,000 miles shows .350 something volts because of the ground being put on the wire by the 20,000 mile switch.
The 20,000 mile switch is NOT controlled by the ECU. Its nothing different that the water temp switch at the bottom of a series four radiator having open contacts until the water reaches a certain temp whereupon it puts a ground on pin 1H, which tells the ECU that the water is up to temp now, so you can now put a ground on the Relief Solenoid and close off the dumping of the airpump air at the ACV.
The Port Air Solenoid IS controlled by the ECU and the ECU knows when to close the port air solenoid by the twenty grand switch TELLING THE ECU that its now past twenty grand (by putting a ground on pin 1O).
There's nothing high tech about it. Just a ground at twenty grand and above (until you hit 100,000.1 miles, that is.
It's similar to the fifth gear switch. You put the transmission in fifth gear, which in turn puts a ground on the ECU. The ECU sees the ground and then puts a ground on the Split Air Solenoid.
Oh, the pin 1O with the 212,000 miles shows open with the plug disconnected and with the plug connected shows 12v (no ground results in no voltage drop).
The cars with over 220,000 miles shows .350 something volts because of the ground being put on the wire by the 20,000 mile switch.
The 20,000 mile switch is NOT controlled by the ECU. Its nothing different that the water temp switch at the bottom of a series four radiator having open contacts until the water reaches a certain temp whereupon it puts a ground on pin 1H, which tells the ECU that the water is up to temp now, so you can now put a ground on the Relief Solenoid and close off the dumping of the airpump air at the ACV.
The Port Air Solenoid IS controlled by the ECU and the ECU knows when to close the port air solenoid by the twenty grand switch TELLING THE ECU that its now past twenty grand (by putting a ground on pin 1O).
There's nothing high tech about it. Just a ground at twenty grand and above (until you hit 100,000.1 miles, that is.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Syracuse, New York
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of course the 20k mile switch is a sensor, not an actuator.
My point was the unless you've reverse engineered the ECU, the connection betwen the port air soleniod and the 20k mile switch is a debatable topic in itself.
Maybe the ecu just reads the 20 mile switch and toggles the actuator, 1:1 or maybe it does something more complex. We don't know, so if you want to prove something you should measure the switch itself, not the solenoid.
The only way the 20,000 mile switch interacts with anything else in the car it through the ECU.
My point was the unless you've reverse engineered the ECU, the connection betwen the port air soleniod and the 20k mile switch is a debatable topic in itself.
Maybe the ecu just reads the 20 mile switch and toggles the actuator, 1:1 or maybe it does something more complex. We don't know, so if you want to prove something you should measure the switch itself, not the solenoid.
The only way the 20,000 mile switch interacts with anything else in the car it through the ECU.
#24
I'm a boost creep...
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Auckland, New Zealand
Posts: 15,608
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally posted by theloudroom
My point was the the port air solenoid and 20k mile switch are both controlled by the ECU...
My point was the the port air solenoid and 20k mile switch are both controlled by the ECU...
...and unless you're further along reverse engineering the ECU than me, you shouldn't be checking to port air solenoid to see if the 20,000 mile swich is closed.
Last edited by NZConvertible; 02-26-04 at 01:51 PM.
#25
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Syracuse, New York
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by NZConvertible
The 20K mile switch is an ECU input; the port air solenoid is an ECU output. The ECU can't "control" switches.
The 20K mile switch is an ECU input; the port air solenoid is an ECU output. The ECU can't "control" switches.
Originally posted by NZConvertible
You don't need to have reverse-engineered the ECU to be able to read and understand the FSM. Go look at the table on page F1-77 or F2-75 of the S5 FSM where it explains how the 20K mile switch affects the operation of the port air solenoid.
You don't need to have reverse-engineered the ECU to be able to read and understand the FSM. Go look at the table on page F1-77 or F2-75 of the S5 FSM where it explains how the 20K mile switch affects the operation of the port air solenoid.