AnthonyNYC

iTrader: (3)

In a nutshell can anyone explain the difference between the trannies listed above. I know the Gforce is a shifted tranny, Freddy Brown are automatics. It looks like the Liberty is the most expensive of the three, gforce 2nd and FB the cheapest. Which one would be the best option for a street/drag car and which for a drag only car?

Thanks,

Anthony

NOEL MELASA

LIBERTY WILL BE THE BEST.

enzo250

Anthony the automatic would be the only one you could drive on the street.

Gforce's, Liberty's, etc cannot be downshifted and are strictly drag race.

Both Gforce and Liberty are good transmissions, Although i prefer the liberty..

joe-c

iTrader: (2)

wat race transmissions can you downshift with?

crispeed

Both Liberty and G-force make tranies that you can down shift. As long as the tranny is not of a full clutchless shift design and you use the right shifter then it can be downshifted.
I would say Liberty would be the clear winner because they have numerous designs and combinations to suit your needs.
Liberty just re-introduce their version of the famous 'Doughnash' design trannny that many people still use from back in the day.
You can also speak to Liberty about their gear setup for the inside of the stock Mazda tranny something I know 'Enzo' can comment on.

crispeed

Now how did I know you would say that.

NOEL MELASA

THANK YOU SIR

RXn407

i heard that they can be found on e bay for like 1400, the doug nashs' n i heard theyre the bang for the buck, starting point.

AnthonyNYC

iTrader: (3)

Thanks for the responses.

Anthony

ErnieT

iTrader: (2)

Anthony,
I have had nothing but great results with my PPG tranny. I suppose some more testing is in order since I havn't cut a 1.50 60' with it yet, but so far its working great.

AnthonyNYC

iTrader: (3)

How streetable is that tranny? If you wanted to take an hour drive or so, can you or would it be too noisy or damage the tranny etc?

Anthony

ErnieT

iTrader: (2)

If your in 5th gear its quiet as stock because its 1 to 1. The other gears wine because of no syncros, but you CAN get the tranny with syncros, its just not rated for as much power.

RICE RACING

mate

dog engagment has nothing to do with gear noise

this only happens due to gear tooth profile being flat and direct line contact on mating gears v's rolling point contact on semi helical or full helical oem box's therfore almost as much WHINING as a wife long after the honey moon has ended

crispeed

Ernie.
It's not the syncros that make it wine. It's the straight cut gears that do. All transmissions with straight cut gears will exibit noise in the lower gears with 1:1 being the quietest.
The clunking and banging noise is due to the face plate dogs setup. Since there are no more syncros and there's a wide gap between the dogs often only six to eight vs the stock setup which might have three times the amount to smoothen the shift.

RICE RACING

have you done a fluid change on your box yet? let us know how many fragments you find....... generaly dog box's *depending on skill of driver* will shed alot of bits and these are little pieces from your dogs *woof woof* they eventualy loose enough bits (usualy within 3k or less of road running) for the box to either **** a bearing (if not cleaned regularily enough to rid of contaminants) or it will jump out of gear as the dogs *woof woof* have lost too much material to stay engaged under load.

They can take quite a bit of abuse but i have seen dog boxes in everything from motorbikes, to trucks and they all suffer at the hands of an inexperienced operator. Even if you have a lot of sympathy they still have a hard time.

crispeed

Proper driver shifting technique along with frequent oil changes are the key to making those trannies last especially on a street car. If you're serious about racing then you would have an extra set of face plates/dogs along with sliders that is if the design of the tranny allows you to change the face plates/dogs as an individual component or else it's going to get very expensive to have extra spare complete sets of gears with the dogs attached to them. Some companies weld the dogs to the stock gears while others are machined as part of the upgraded gear and offcourse the real pro trannies would have them as a seperate changeable component.

These pics show a compromise in design between a straight cut gear and a stock type gear. This design is a lot stronger than stock and will be a lot quiter than a straight cut design but not as strong. It's a nice option for a street type setup.




Another option for stock type gears.
Proshift dogs. Notice the welded on dogs.

Vs Stock gear.


A gear set with face plate engagement. Notice the removable dogs on some of the gears.


The daddy of all clutchless trannies in my opinion.

RICE RACING

My Quaife gearbox is a semi helical design with full *soft ***** syncro action for crusing duty when it comes time to pick up the local *****

crispeed

*soft *****

crispeed

A fully re-worked T-5 Transmission from G-Force.
I'm going to be testing one of these soon.



Different options.
Syncronised kit with helical-cut gears


Helical-cut with dog rings.


Straight cut with dog rings.

RICE RACING

The daddy box you post above I saw apart at a drag meet here (box out of MR12A) fastest 12A untubbed car in world 730+rwhp 12A and it had weld on gears on the two side shafts (not splined as in that photo), but otherwise ideantical construction with case that allowed it to be easily split in pits.

Long story short it was jumping out of 4th gear and the dogs *woof woof* were fucked on it after 80 passes or so.

Its a fucken BIG BOX ! and is massive in real life, stongest thing I ever seen in such a small car but the dogs *woof woof* still got jamed in the A hardcore

I was spewing because i drove a long way to see it run and they said the box was jumping out of gear on the dyno when tuning it, anyway pulled it down at track and thats what i saw

crispeed

The welded on set is an early design. The dyno does place a lot of stress on the dogs. I've seen brand new transmissions that are damaged after a tuning session on the dyno vs the same box lasting almost a 100 passes at the strip.
It comes down to driving technique most of the times. One **** up and that brand new tranny is going to push out of gears due to damaged dogs and sliders.

RICE RACING

I like the soft **** option

NOEL MELASA

***HEY CRIS I WANT ONE FOR THE STARLET***

crispeed

You know the Tel.#!

crispeed

What about those ***** you mentioned!