a look into the world of piston engines vs rotary technical forums..
#1
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
a look into the world of piston engines vs rotary technical forums..
http://mr2oc.com/showthread.php?t=148460
i found this unusual because its seems soo easy for us as rotary turbo people to make power upwards to this i guess we just dont make much of a fuss about it all...could it be because the way our engines respond to boost vs recipircating engines? someone some insight pleasE?
to me i thought its all about getting a fresh broken in rebiuld....throw on a haltech TD07, or a TO4e or R and RB exhuast, some larger injectors waste gate, front mount OR water to air... and dyno tune to your horsepower perfection and liking(i mentioned those turbos because they can make 300+ easy...if u read the above thread youll see what i mean) i dunno maybe im over estimating our cars?
i found this unusual because its seems soo easy for us as rotary turbo people to make power upwards to this i guess we just dont make much of a fuss about it all...could it be because the way our engines respond to boost vs recipircating engines? someone some insight pleasE?
to me i thought its all about getting a fresh broken in rebiuld....throw on a haltech TD07, or a TO4e or R and RB exhuast, some larger injectors waste gate, front mount OR water to air... and dyno tune to your horsepower perfection and liking(i mentioned those turbos because they can make 300+ easy...if u read the above thread youll see what i mean) i dunno maybe im over estimating our cars?
Last edited by --MAstermind--; 11-28-05 at 11:50 AM.
#5
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Old Smokey (MR2OC.com)
We have all heard the magic 300rwhp number brought up many times in many threads. We all drool at 300+rwhp dyno’s and marvel at the level of commitment that it must have taken to achieve those numbers. And yes, we also daydream about what it must be like to step on the throttle with so much horsepower on tap.
On the other hand, we have all heard about certain obstacles and problems faced with aiming for more than 300rwhp, and we wonder about what issues we might not commonly hear about. We also have to keep in mind that the majority of members on this board, for one reason or another, will never get beyond that 300rwhp mark, though I am sure they face the temptation to try.
For these people, and for those who may be planning to go for big horsepower one day, but do not yet realize what this really means, I thought it may be informative and entertaining to attempt to list as many of those “reasons not to aim for more than 300rwhp” as we can think of.
*Please know that I have nothing against those who have or want more than 300rwhp, and I hope those who have done so will chime in with some of the wisdom gained and lessons learned from achieving their level of power.
Also, I hope that anyone even considering upgrading near and above 300whp has read the Power Primer, but even if that is the case, sometimes it helps to look at things in a different way.
Anyway, to get the ball rolling here are a couple obvious reasons:
1-Say goodbye to the CT26.
2-Say hello to the world of compressor maps and proper turbo sizing.
On the other hand, we have all heard about certain obstacles and problems faced with aiming for more than 300rwhp, and we wonder about what issues we might not commonly hear about. We also have to keep in mind that the majority of members on this board, for one reason or another, will never get beyond that 300rwhp mark, though I am sure they face the temptation to try.
For these people, and for those who may be planning to go for big horsepower one day, but do not yet realize what this really means, I thought it may be informative and entertaining to attempt to list as many of those “reasons not to aim for more than 300rwhp” as we can think of.
*Please know that I have nothing against those who have or want more than 300rwhp, and I hope those who have done so will chime in with some of the wisdom gained and lessons learned from achieving their level of power.
Also, I hope that anyone even considering upgrading near and above 300whp has read the Power Primer, but even if that is the case, sometimes it helps to look at things in a different way.
Anyway, to get the ball rolling here are a couple obvious reasons:
1-Say goodbye to the CT26.
2-Say hello to the world of compressor maps and proper turbo sizing.
this is just be begining
Originally Posted by Bruce H.
It's not unobtainable at all...just around 21 other things so far to consider.
22. Lag
23. Loss of stock ECU (for those that just prefer to keep factory stuff) somewhere above 300
Some may consider changes to the stock engine bay to be a negative incl.
24. Loss of AFM
25. Loss of heat shield (maybe)
26. Need for Ext WG at some point
27. Loss of insurability if an adjuster comes within a mile of your car.
28. The cost of stuff or repairs you don't anticipate (ie blowing knock sensors and then adding water injection)
29. Loss of vehicle use when it does break.
30. Calming furious wife or gf when they discover the amount of time and money you are spending.
Great thread Chris!
Bruce
22. Lag
23. Loss of stock ECU (for those that just prefer to keep factory stuff) somewhere above 300
Some may consider changes to the stock engine bay to be a negative incl.
24. Loss of AFM
25. Loss of heat shield (maybe)
26. Need for Ext WG at some point
27. Loss of insurability if an adjuster comes within a mile of your car.
28. The cost of stuff or repairs you don't anticipate (ie blowing knock sensors and then adding water injection)
29. Loss of vehicle use when it does break.
30. Calming furious wife or gf when they discover the amount of time and money you are spending.
Great thread Chris!
Bruce
Originally Posted by ATSAaron
This is just a sad, sad thread.
The first time I made 300whp, it cost me about $20,000 (not including the car). The same motor went on to make 500whp, but that is not the point.
The second time I made 300whp...or I should say, the current recipe is around $4000 not including labor. 300whp on 93 octane is a simple, simple package. 1 ATS combo kit + exhaust + intake + MBC. It negates most of the points made in this thread.
For those that are still scared we offer a 275whp (CT27 based) combo kit for less ;-)
Aaron
The first time I made 300whp, it cost me about $20,000 (not including the car). The same motor went on to make 500whp, but that is not the point.
The second time I made 300whp...or I should say, the current recipe is around $4000 not including labor. 300whp on 93 octane is a simple, simple package. 1 ATS combo kit + exhaust + intake + MBC. It negates most of the points made in this thread.
For those that are still scared we offer a 275whp (CT27 based) combo kit for less ;-)
Aaron
Originally Posted by magikspl
I agree with ATS, I don't think 300 is a high enough number for this cause. Now 400 is a more suitable number. I could go on forever about reasons not to. I just past the 400 mark and I have lost 1.5 years of my life, $16,000, one girlfriend, many sleepless nights, weight loss, 1 hour in jail, attorney fee's, 1 wrecked MR2. Any sane person would quickly judge the costs are not worth it. But it only takes one moment for you to justify all the sacrifices you made, and my moment was standing proud in front of 45 other cars and taking home the highest hp car at the dyno day while everyone watched in envy and congratulated. :thumbup
lmao
how do you guys feel about this?
#6
Lives on the Forum
No, it is basically the same...but the dollar amounts is a bit different.
Our stock 13BT's can do 300.
Anything over that it is highly recommended to rebuild...might as well port at the same time.
Now, that's very similar to the SW20 and their 3S-GTE...
While a 13BT rebuild will cost...
$1000 - $2000 in labor
$2000 in Mazda OEM parts + upgrade items (i.e. OPR, FD corner seal springs, etc.)
$1000 in porting
So we're looking at a $5,000 rebuild + porting there.
Now, I know people are going to scoff at those prices, but I'm talking about getting a top-notch shop to handle all of this, and not some backyard tuner...
The piston engine (3S-GTE) would require a rebuild...
PLUS:
Upgrade pistons
Upgrade con rods
Forged crank?
New cams
Head work
New valvetrain? (cam on bucket lifters?)
We're talking $5k in parts there if you want something that can sustain 500hp (as the guy mentioned).
So, all of a sudden, we're talking about a piston engine starting to approach $10k!
Now, add the turbo, turbo exhaust manifold, IC, stand-alone EMS, fuel system, exhaust, etc...and that $20k estimate can be believable.
Same levels of upgrades, but prices for parts are vastly different...
-Ted
Our stock 13BT's can do 300.
Anything over that it is highly recommended to rebuild...might as well port at the same time.
Now, that's very similar to the SW20 and their 3S-GTE...
While a 13BT rebuild will cost...
$1000 - $2000 in labor
$2000 in Mazda OEM parts + upgrade items (i.e. OPR, FD corner seal springs, etc.)
$1000 in porting
So we're looking at a $5,000 rebuild + porting there.
Now, I know people are going to scoff at those prices, but I'm talking about getting a top-notch shop to handle all of this, and not some backyard tuner...
The piston engine (3S-GTE) would require a rebuild...
PLUS:
Upgrade pistons
Upgrade con rods
Forged crank?
New cams
Head work
New valvetrain? (cam on bucket lifters?)
We're talking $5k in parts there if you want something that can sustain 500hp (as the guy mentioned).
So, all of a sudden, we're talking about a piston engine starting to approach $10k!
Now, add the turbo, turbo exhaust manifold, IC, stand-alone EMS, fuel system, exhaust, etc...and that $20k estimate can be believable.
Same levels of upgrades, but prices for parts are vastly different...
-Ted
#7
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hmm well what say u to a NON ported 13bt.....lee tuscano here has done it about 550hp....non ported running about 34psi......water to air intercooler...runs 10 around here...its a great car hes helped me personally get my car in order....BUT he claims he has to rebiuld every 4-5 months after 40 passes and like 5-10 dyno runs is that considered unreliable? (hes movin' to the 13b-RE i belive....and still not porting it)
Trending Topics
#8
Lives on the Forum
Non-ported?
Well, whatever floats his boat...
Porting just adds to efficiency, so I dunno why he doesn't do it...
As for frequency of rebuilds...I'd say that's about right...if not a bit paranoid.
Reliability really drops when you start hitting 500+ hp.
-Ted
Well, whatever floats his boat...
Porting just adds to efficiency, so I dunno why he doesn't do it...
As for frequency of rebuilds...I'd say that's about right...if not a bit paranoid.
Reliability really drops when you start hitting 500+ hp.
-Ted
#9
Rotary Enthusiast
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by --MAstermind--
hmm well what say u to a NON ported 13bt.....lee tuscano here has done it about 550hp....non ported running about 34psi......water to air intercooler...runs 10 around here...its a great car hes helped me personally get my car in order....BUT he claims he has to rebiuld every 4-5 months after 40 passes and like 5-10 dyno runs is that considered unreliable? (hes movin' to the 13b-RE i belive....and still not porting it)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rx8volks
Canadian Forum
0
08-13-15 04:55 AM
KAL797
Test Area 51
0
08-11-15 03:47 PM