When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Not sure loctite will do much, other than before first start-up, permitted upper temp range is somewhere around 200C from what I remember.
The grip section of the stud should be the stop when it contacts the timesert, so not sure how that is working, unless the timesert counterbore is deeper and torquing it is winding it in? I'd be wary running a tap through too, idea is the fastener forms it's own threads, at the lower levels at least....might be tempted to remove and reinstall a new one. Only time I've worried about torque on the studs in that area are turbo to manifold, where you could crack stuff if you go nuts.
The insert is definitely not twisting deeper. I didn't get a picture unfortunately but the first row or two of threads were definitely getting flattened by the flat middle of the stud. I only ran a tap through the outer end to clean it up a bit, but not all the way through the insert.
I have other inserts I could install but I am not sure how safe it is to remove this one. If I damage the new threads in the aluminum that I tapped with the timesert kit, I will really be stuck.
I dunno how you botched it man. the Bevel tool should stop the insert from spinning without damaging the threads. did you use it? You could always jb weld it into place and pray, but i dont want to be responsible for any bad ideas.
I dunno how you botched it man. the Bevel tool should stop the insert from spinning without damaging the threads. did you use it? You could always jb weld it into place and pray, but i dont want to be responsible for any bad ideas.
^^^^Cancel that, didnt see your last post.^^^
Are you sure you bought the correct thread pitch?
Yes, I bought M10x1.5. The stud easily screws in like it should and if the size were wrong it wouldn't do that. It's a brand new stud too. I think the timesert threads are smaller to start, so there is less material for the stud to 'stop' on. That's all I can think of... I am at a loss honestly
Here's a picture of the stud as it currently sits, and you can see the timesert flange is flush and not deeper than it should be. The stud is maybe 1mm deeper than the others. I am also now getting the 'click' when I tighten it at 22ftlbs although I am not sure how much of that is from the two drops of loctite I used.
Last edited by derSchwamm; 01-02-18 at 08:19 PM.
Reason: picture
The insert is definitely not twisting deeper. I didn't get a picture unfortunately but the first row or two of threads were definitely getting flattened by the flat middle of the stud. I only ran a tap through the outer end to clean it up a bit, but not all the way through the insert.
I have other inserts I could install but I am not sure how safe it is to remove this one. If I damage the new threads in the aluminum that I tapped with the timesert kit, I will really be stuck.
You're more than likely going to be Ok, if you only got two threads deeper into the insert, it's only 3mm short. If you get really stuck with timeserts there are oversize too, but I'd leave that well alone for now. A smoke test will tell you if it's not sealing, prior to buttoning everything up, if really concerned....but that's more stuffing around and dough. Probably have more worries with the gasket not sealing is my tip, with 2ft/lb diff, it's not going to decide the outcome.
Bro if you have a click at 22 id just leave it. Id be comfortable with 22ftlbs and having the stud at least flush with the top of the nut when the manifold is installed.
and the only part of the timesert threads that should be smaller is the end that locks it into place.are you sure you put the driver tool in enough?
Yeah, I'm just going to continue with my build at this point. If it's not at the factory torque spec, it's close enough. I feel like I won't be able to get it any better and I'm tired of messing with it.
And yeah, I know how the timeserts work and which end should have shorter threads, but the end with the flange is what's giving me trouble (not what you circled here). Once you get to the 20ftlb ballpark the tapered flat part of the stud just starts compacting those threads, driving the stud in further. It was a new m10x1.5 insert, and a new stud, and a torque wrench set to 22ftlbs, and the insert didn't move. Don't really know what else to say
I did previously get the manifold installed, and I got the nuts torqued correctly on all 4 (50-something ftlbs). I'm pretty confident I can torque them down to that again even on this stud, so as long as the stud doesn't back out in the future it should be ok. I'm a perfectionist though and I really wish I could be 100% confident in this fix
How'd this shake out? I just stripped my same stud hole. rear lower.
I forgot how much trouble I had with this a year ago! It seems to be holding up. I've put 2000 miles on the car since the rebuild, a lot of which was lighter driving since I was breaking it in. I've gotten into full boost a couple time recently and I have yet to see any evidence of an exhaust leak. I'm pulling the turbos soon to install BNRs so I'll take a look and make sure the stud hasn't backed out or anything, so I'll report back after then.
FYI I've used helicoils quite a bit and they are good, but the timesert definitely seems more durable. I'd recommend it for something this important
I personally went with the helicoil instead of the timesert. I was able to get full torque spec all around. Why are we all beating up the lower studs so often?
I personally went with the helicoil instead of the timesert. I was able to get full torque spec all around. Why are we all beating up the lower studs so often?
Good to know that helicoil holds up too! I haven't taken my turbos off yet but I was under the car last night and could see that the messed up stud seemed to be holding. I'll know for sure soon
Why are we all beating up the lower studs so often?
Because people are impatient, and dont want to wait for the PB blaster to soak over night before trying to remove manifold bolts/nuts (myself included).
Because people are impatient, and dont want to wait for the PB blaster to soak over night before trying to remove manifold bolts/nuts (myself included).
... or because we are dumb and use a lock washer on aluminum threads
Just wondering, but I use lock washers on aluminum threads all the time. Why would that make it strip out?
When I torqued it down, a few seconds later I heard a pop and the stud had popped backwards and taken the threads with it. This was due to the tension from the lock washer. Aluminum threads are weak and apparently this can happen. Mazda didn't use them from the factory so I shouldn't have either. It's happened once on the head of my protege too (also aluminum, at the exhaust manifold)
When I torqued it down, a few seconds later I heard a pop and the stud had popped backwards and taken the threads with it. This was due to the tension from the lock washer. Aluminum threads are weak and apparently this can happen. Mazda didn't use them from the factory so I shouldn't have either. It's happened once on the head of my protege too (also aluminum, at the exhaust manifold)
I doubt it was the lock washer. The exhaust manifold torque spec is higher than the tension that lock washer puts on it, at least i think. You probably just over tightened it, or maybe the stud wasnt deep enough.
I doubt it was the lock washer. The exhaust manifold torque spec is higher than the tension that lock washer puts on it, at least i think. You probably just over tightened it, or maybe the stud wasnt deep enough.
Absolutely correct. Once the threads sheared off, THEN the lock washer popped the stud further out.
I doubt it was the lock washer. The exhaust manifold torque spec is higher than the tension that lock washer puts on it, at least i think. You probably just over tightened it, or maybe the stud wasnt deep enough.
Or maybe my Harbor Freight torque wrench let me down!!
I'm not sure that's caused by the force of a lock washer. The strength of 1" of threads in aluminum is pretty strong. There was likely something wrong with the threads in the first place.
The FSM torque spec is for a prevailing torque nut without anti-seize lubricant on it. Both of those variables will change the required torque to get the desired bolt stretch and clamping force.
Fasteners are generally torqued to ~75% of their rated strength and the use of a lubricant like anti-seize alone has been said to reduce required torque by 30-50%.
Get rid of the crimped prevailing torque nut, put some anti-seize on your threads, then torque to FSM spec.... doesn't take much imagination to predict what happens next.
Bumping because this forum is such a great resource. The block I’m dressing had one stud that was different, I replaced it with a new OEM and sent it home without checking torque. I probably damaged what were already compromised threads more. When I bolted up the turbo manifold using stainless washers and new OEM nuts it got tight…. and then I felt the unsettling feeling of it tightening a little too easy. Sure enough, it pulled the threads.
The manifold and turbo are back off an I’m waiting on a time-sert kit. I’m going to put it in correctly with loctite and then I hope I can torque to 50ftlbs on all the nuts. The other 3 studs seemed to tightened up fine and I hit torque on the top front prior to the failure of the top rear.
01-02-18, 07:54 PM
HF is great for some things, but precision tools is not one of them.
