Paint weight debate
I went over to a shop today to speak with the owner about painting my FD track car. Some friends and I were just talking about the weight of a paint job the other night so I thought Id ask about it. I brought up the possibility of media blasting the car down to the metal before painting in order to shed the weight of the old paint. He pretty much didnt take me very seriously and insisted that the total weight of a completed paint job could not be over 5lbs. Part of me thinks this is total bs as I wouldnt be surprised if paint weight 20-30lbs (multiple coats of primer, top coat, and clear), but I couldnt call him out on it due to lack of evidence/knowledge on the subject.
So Im wondering...have any of you ran into any data regarding painted/unpainted weight comparisons? >> The matter is kind of a moot point considering media blasting the entire car is only like $180, so I will do it anyways. Still curious though. |
You'd be better off skipping McDonalds IMO.
|
Is your real name Mark Webber?
|
Well it does add weight obviously and I will not be surprised if it is that much. Back in the days when I used to work with A-6 Intruder and we used the glossy paint we were limited to apply no more than 2 coats of paint because the added weight and drag. On the F/A-18 it isn't a big of a deal because the flat/matte finish of the paint isn't as thick as the glossy paint but we are only limited to 3 coats. Only on a few areas where the lead coating is applied to the aircraft is where we are limited to one coat. When I say coats I mean a full paint job of the base colors. Plane markings and decorative designs don't apply.
BTW I forgot where I read it but red is proven to be the lightest color. |
^^win!
I'm off to McD's for an Angus burger :lol: |
I have a brand new unpainted fender from mazda and 2 CYM ones. IMO, the CYM fenders were noticably heavier (although they had the fender vents on them as well). 20 - 30 lbs would not surprise me in the least. I'm sure someone with more knowledge will post up any time now.
|
I have seen a lot of stupid threads over the years. This one has to be near the top.
Guess what?? You have to paint your car. It is going to add some minimal amount of weight to the car. That little bit of extra weight doesn't make any difference!!!! You have to paint the car!!!! Do you think that professional racers (like Nascar) don't want all those logos on the car because it weighs the car down? Maybe its time for a reality check?
Originally Posted by hondasr4kids
(Post 10592834)
BTW I forgot where I read it but red is proven to be the lightest color. |
I wouldn't be surprised if the paint weighs a bit more than 20-30lbs. My painted carbon fiber Scoote hood is alot heavier than an unpainted Scoote hood, it has to be at least a 5lb difference or more. Its surprisingly noticeable, I couldn't believe it.
|
Originally Posted by adam c
(Post 10593284)
I have seen a lot of stupid threads over the years. This one has to be near the top.
Guess what?? You have to paint your car. It is going to add some minimal amount of weight to the car. That little bit of extra weight doesn't make any difference!!!! You have to paint the car!!!! Do you think that professional racers (like Nascar) don't want all those logos on the car because it weighs the car down? Maybe its time for a reality check? |
Originally Posted by adam c
(Post 10593284)
You can't be serious!!! A gallon of red paint isn't going to have a different weight than a gallon of ANY other color.
|
I do remember reading that United Airlines saved a shitload of weight by not painting their planes white anymore, and just applying graphics on the bare skin... it was enough to offer fuel savings, but I don't have any idea how that compares to automotive paint jobs.
|
I imagine any paint shop that has painted enough cars could give you an estimate on how much primer, paint and clear they go through to cover the car. You could just find out what that stuff weighs according to those amounts. Not all the paint obviously ends up on the car and some is sanded down but it should give a pretty good estimate and is a lot easier than weighing things before and after painting.
|
Originally Posted by madbouncy
(Post 10593422)
Not all the paint obviously ends up on the car and some is sanded down
|
Mercedes used to strip all of their GP cars back in the day to meet weight requirements. Thats how the acquired the "silver arrow" nickname. All of the GP cars were just a shining aluminum body.
|
Originally Posted by 2RotorsNaDream
(Post 10593361)
You have to read the post better, hes not saying hes not going to paint the car. He wants to remove all the old paint first so that he doesnt have the extra weight under the new paint. Nobody is dumb enough to just leave their cars at bare metal and not paint them. I hope haha.
|
You really only get one shot at a decent paint job. Strip the car, and do it right. You'll thank me in a year or two.
|
Originally Posted by mkiv98
(Post 10593878)
john delorean did...
|
Originally Posted by madbouncy
(Post 10593422)
I imagine any paint shop that has painted enough cars could give you an estimate on how much primer, paint and clear they go through to cover the car. You could just find out what that stuff weighs according to those amounts. Not all the paint obviously ends up on the car and some is sanded down but it should give a pretty good estimate and is a lot easier than weighing things before and after painting.
|
Originally Posted by adam c
(Post 10593284)
You can't be serious!!! A gallon of red paint isn't going to have a different weight than a gallon of ANY other color.
It's the finished paint coat that is being considered. Red is known for having poor solids content and therefore more solvents as the balance. If you apply a gallon of liquid paint to a car it is reasonable that the red paint coat will have the least solids and the lightest finished weight. If you're debating whether paint weight matters to you, it's a pretty easy decision: pull a fender, weigh it accurately, and strip the paint. There's your weight savings. Now consider the benefit (if any) and make a decision on the rest of the car. Don't take any of our word for it. |
What I am saying is that it doesn't make any difference what the color is. The car has to be painted, and the weight of one color (or another) isn't going to effect the performance of the car. If it did effect performance (and red was measurably lighter), all professional race cars would be red.
Stripping old paint off to repaint isn't going to provide any measurable gain in performance. Next we will be suggesting that drivers shouldn't wear socks or underwear to save weight. We certainly won't be able to race any more with coins in our pockets :) |
Originally Posted by dgeesaman
(Post 10594079)
It's the finished paint coat that is being considered. Red is known for having poor solids content and therefore more solvents as the balance. If you apply a gallon of liquid paint to a car it is reasonable that the red paint coat will have the least solids and the lightest finished weight.
|
wow, so this answers the lingering question about painting flames on your car and it making it faster.
IMO the easiest way to find out weight is to find out how many cans of mixed primer, paint, and clear coat you need. You can't go off the paint before premix because it get deluted during the process. Its got to weigh more than 30lbs because I know I could not carry all the paint it would take to do a whole car. |
Originally Posted by ptrhahn
(Post 10593415)
I do remember reading that United Airlines saved a shitload of weight by not painting their planes white anymore, and just applying graphics on the bare skin... it was enough to offer fuel savings, but I don't have any idea how that compares to automotive paint jobs.
|
The facts from an expert
My car is currently at the body shop. It has a couple of scratches on the drivers door, and a very small dent in the rear quarter panel. I just called the owner and asked about paint weights. He said that it would take about eight pounds of materials to cover my entire car. That includes primer, paint, and clear coat. Eight pounds for the whole car.
Stripping a car to paint it (for weight savings) seems a huge waste of time. |
Painted cars have less drag!!!!!
Pile it on! |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:27 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands