n/a 20b or single turbo 13b?
#26
wanna Hit 200+
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ever since i saw the hot version Battle at 10,000 rpm NA 20B has been i my mind if i end up keeping my car that long. Sounds really nice and the power delivery is smooth and at close to 400whp for a street. what more could you ask for?
#27
Stinky nutz!
Thread Starter
Hmmm I didn't even think of useing some s5 na rotors in there.... I think I'll be budgeting them in also.. along with some custom beveling of the rotors... on a side note... I put one of my na s4 motors in my other fc and damn I love the feel of an n/a granted my t2 would blow it out the water... the n/a just felt better... more responsive I guess.. then again it's street ported with a rb header and track pipe to a single can. I'll update this later once I've figured out what I'm going to do, then I'll drop a price list and I'd apretiate it if some of you can critique it so I can see if this is gonna be what I really want to do... oh yea and thanks for all the responses.. they've been helpful!
#28
multipersonality disorder
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: so. cal
Posts: 5,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by FromSilvia2seven
Ever since i saw the hot version Battle at 10,000 rpm NA 20B has been i my mind if i end up keeping my car that long. Sounds really nice and the power delivery is smooth and at close to 400whp for a street. what more could you ask for?
i'm not bashing on the streetability...especially when i used a turbo bridgeport as a daily driver.
but do you know what it costs to make a 3 rotor capable of 10k rpm?
#29
Originally Posted by BMike
For the goal of the original poster, its pretty much flip a coin though, both a turbo 13b and a n/a 20b will do the numbers wanted pretty easily. Personally I'd go 13b turbo since parts are more plentiful and its a much more well documented path.
^ agreed. This is my vote even though I love the 20B
-josh
#31
The Ancient
I am somewhat reluctant to chime in here, but will anyway. I love the NA 20b and have spent a lot of time working on different things with them. I would say that, if you would be happy with about 350 whp, the 20b is a great alternative. Its a great motor. Pulls great and is extremely reliable. Plus it weighs less as installed than the usual single turbo 13b setup. I made 397 whp with mine but heard a little pinging and backed off the power to about 375-380. But 350 is a good number that is attainable without spending a fortune. Defined Auto made 425 with an extreme 20b before going to 4 rotors.
#34
Rotary Enthusiast
iTrader: (3)
I know that the 3 rotor na rx8 in Imsa made over 400. I wonder if it could be reliable at that hp. I would love to have a 3 rotor na making 430wrhp but I dont think it would be reliable or to steerable with a peripheral port. I imagine it would require that type of port to make that type of power.
#35
Senior Member
There are simply too many factors that go in to this decision. Doing a big single 13B or building an NA 20B will most likely cost around the same by the time you turn the key. Now, you can definitely get a better street driving experience with a big single 13b as you don't need the porting a 20B will need to make equivalent power. One thing you should absolutely consider is parts availability with the 20B. I've heard a lot of issues with people finding that rare center iron for the 20b as it's a very special item and comes at a premium cost when needed. I know you said you didn't care too much about cost, but it's still a consideration. The only problem with the turbo 13b I could see is if you cheap out with your cooling and system design i.e. buying a front mount intercooler from ebay. Cheaping out does no good as does a lack of education in the matter. Howard Coleman has a website that you can get lost in that teaches such about the importance of system design. Whatever you do, just be sure about it and don't look back. The biggest importance is research and to do it right and do it once. Don't forget that the 20b does have better power potential if you ever decide to throw a big single at it. Don't forget about that future planning step either!
#36
Rotary Enthusiast
I know that the 3 rotor na rx8 in Imsa made over 400. I wonder if it could be reliable at that hp. I would love to have a 3 rotor na making 430wrhp but I dont think it would be reliable or to steerable with a peripheral port. I imagine it would require that type of port to make that type of power.
#37
I am somewhat reluctant to chime in here, but will anyway. I love the NA 20b and have spent a lot of time working on different things with them. I would say that, if you would be happy with about 350 whp, the 20b is a great alternative. Its a great motor. Pulls great and is extremely reliable. Plus it weighs less as installed than the usual single turbo 13b setup. I made 397 whp with mine but heard a little pinging and backed off the power to about 375-380. But 350 is a good number that is attainable without spending a fortune. Defined Auto made 425 with an extreme 20b before going to 4 rotors.
And what engine mount would you use?
#38
The Ancient
Hi, Johnny. I'm not really sure about the cost today. A lot depends on what you start with. It's hard to get a nice 20b short block. They are pretty expensive these days, I think. The short block, ITB's, headers, exhaust, and EMS are the big costs. I would think you build a solid 350 whp motor for maybe $25-30,000. Going from there to close to 400 whp will add at least $10,000 for the "little things". For instance, to get a motor that revs to over 9,000 rpm you need to dry sump the engine. That adds maybe $3-4,000 right there. I'll tell you that an NA 20b is a connoisseur's motor. There is no way its cost-effective for the power it can make. It is simply a much different kind of power, as I have gone on and on about. Far better for twisty roads and tracks.
#39
The Ancient
Hi, Johnny. 20b shortblocks have become very expensive. Not sure what that cost is, but it could be $7500+++. Then, you need ITB's and they are maybe $3500. You need a good EMS system. I am using Motec and that's at the high end of cost, but there are others that would work, although MicroTech won't work well. Maybe a better Haltech. Figure maybe $3000 for the EMS. Then, you need good headers and exhaust fo0r a few grand. Plus, porting and assembly, including improved oiling. I would think you could get to 325-350 whp for maybe $25-30,000 on the low end. Getting over that means you have to push everything. In particular, you need to dry sump the motor to run over 9,000 rpm and that will pick up a lot of power. Dry sump costs about $3500 or so. Hope that helps a bit.
The following users liked this post:
gmonsen (11-09-19)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post