Mazdaspeed Short Shifter Review
#1
Mazdaspeed Short Shifter Review
I intalled one of these a few weeks ago and thought I'd post my impressions.
There are many short shifters available for the FD (B&M, Cs, RE Amemiya, Mazdatrix, among others) but when searching I found some complaints about pretty much all of them - except the Mazdaspeed one. The complaints mostly centered on some combination of rattling, notchiness, only slightly reduced throws, and increased throw effort. The Mazdaspeed one is also, of course, the most expensive ($350 or so).
The install was pretty easy. The excellent instructions on Mazdatrix's site work well for this install. (Not suprising, since the Mazdatrix shifter is a copy of the Mazdaspeed one.) I used some Neo gear oil in the shift tower and also used some high temperature grease on the spacer to prevent it from rattling.
My initial impression was: ug! Changing gears was no longer like operating a gearbox - it was more like moving a metal stick in a bucket full of nails. Fortunately after a few minutes the oil must have made its way into the various shifter nooks and crannies because things improved considerably.
I have driven short shifters before on other cars and they usually reduce throw by some percentage but operation and feel is more or less similar to stock (with the exception of bad things like notchiness and incresed throw effort with cheap shifters). However, this shifter completely changes the feel of shifting. While the nominal throw length has been reduced by 60% it really feels more like 90%+. Effort is the same as stock and there is no notchiness but changing gears now feels like operating a well-oiled six position switch. You simply select one of six positions and nudge it into gear. Yummy.
All shifters should be like this.
There are many short shifters available for the FD (B&M, Cs, RE Amemiya, Mazdatrix, among others) but when searching I found some complaints about pretty much all of them - except the Mazdaspeed one. The complaints mostly centered on some combination of rattling, notchiness, only slightly reduced throws, and increased throw effort. The Mazdaspeed one is also, of course, the most expensive ($350 or so).
The install was pretty easy. The excellent instructions on Mazdatrix's site work well for this install. (Not suprising, since the Mazdatrix shifter is a copy of the Mazdaspeed one.) I used some Neo gear oil in the shift tower and also used some high temperature grease on the spacer to prevent it from rattling.
My initial impression was: ug! Changing gears was no longer like operating a gearbox - it was more like moving a metal stick in a bucket full of nails. Fortunately after a few minutes the oil must have made its way into the various shifter nooks and crannies because things improved considerably.
I have driven short shifters before on other cars and they usually reduce throw by some percentage but operation and feel is more or less similar to stock (with the exception of bad things like notchiness and incresed throw effort with cheap shifters). However, this shifter completely changes the feel of shifting. While the nominal throw length has been reduced by 60% it really feels more like 90%+. Effort is the same as stock and there is no notchiness but changing gears now feels like operating a well-oiled six position switch. You simply select one of six positions and nudge it into gear. Yummy.
All shifters should be like this.
#2
Urban Combat Vet
iTrader: (16)
Yep. I installed a PETTIT which AFAIK, is identical to MAZDATRIX; MAZDASPEED and RX7Store. My experience was pretty close to yours but it took a little longer to loosen up. I remember that there was definitely more effort required since I lost some leverage, but not enough to make it unpleasant. Don't even notice it now. Had mine for about a year and still happy.
#5
Bought this from DaiOni on this board with a bunch of other Mazdaspeed parts. He lives in Japan and can get any currently available part with pretty quick turnaround.
I believe Corksport also carry it.
To the best of my knowledge: Pettit, RX7Store, and Mazdatrix are Mazdaspeed copies.
I believe Corksport also carry it.
To the best of my knowledge: Pettit, RX7Store, and Mazdatrix are Mazdaspeed copies.
#6
Urban Combat Vet
iTrader: (16)
Originally Posted by moconnor
...To the best of my knowledge: Pettit, RX7Store, and Mazdatrix are Mazdaspeed copies.
[QUOTE=Mahjik]
Just posting an image of the RX-7 Store Short Shifter with the stock on next to it.
#7
2/4 wheel cornering fiend
I bought a slightly used Mazdaspeed SS from Fritz Flynn (who hasn't bought something from Fritz?), so it had none of the initial notchiness issues you speak of. Installation was quick and easy, and I have not had any rattling whatsoever. Just clean, crisp, smooth, positive shifts. Effort is a tad higher than stock, but the tradeoff for the smooth, positive, and short throw made it a very worthwhile investment for $200 (thanx Fritz! )
Trending Topics
#9
Mr. Links
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by XxMerlinxX
Any pics of it in the car? I'm curious as to how short it looks.
http://mahjik.homestead.com/files/FD...3/MVC-001F.JPG
http://mahjik.homestead.com/files/FD...3/MVC-004F.JPG
#12
Originally Posted by XxMerlinxX
Any pics of it in the car? I'm curious as to how short it looks.
#13
White chicks > *
iTrader: (33)
At first i was all about that really short short throw but having a B&M for over a year now, i wanna go back to something with more quality, even though the throw isnt that short.
I hate when shifts feel like you're not even clutching in. Especially if you're in a hurry in city driving yet you're not going WOT. I need something smoother.
Im def gonna pick up one of these MS shifters soon.
I hate when shifts feel like you're not even clutching in. Especially if you're in a hurry in city driving yet you're not going WOT. I need something smoother.
Im def gonna pick up one of these MS shifters soon.
#14
Originally Posted by 1QWIK7
At first i was all about that really short short throw but having a B&M for over a year now, i wanna go back to something with more quality, even though the throw isnt that short.
Last edited by moconnor; 12-23-06 at 08:52 PM.
#15
2/4 wheel cornering fiend
Originally Posted by moconnor
I think you are confusing the Mazdaspeed short shifter with the RE Amemiya one. The throws on the Mazdaspeed are about as short as you can get - shorter than the B&M to the best of knowledge.
#16
White chicks > *
iTrader: (33)
Originally Posted by moconnor
I think you are confusing the Mazdaspeed short shifter with the RE Amemiya one. The throws on the Mazdaspeed are about as short as you can get - shorter than the B&M to the best of my knowledge.
Is that even possible? lol
MY fifth gear position looks like first. lol
Whoever rides with me always looks at the shifter and go, "what gear are you in?" haha
#17
Senior Member
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: SF Bay Area, CA
Posts: 694
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Anyone have experience with the RE Amemiya? I'll be getting a short shifter soon, was going to get the Mazdaspeed (are they all replicas now?) but it'd be cool to have a RE Amemiya part on my car.
-Andy
-Andy
#18
Urban Combat Vet
iTrader: (16)
Originally Posted by aoc007
.....Anyone have experience with the RE Amemiya?........
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
[For Sale] Scratch & Dent, Used, and Open-Box Sale!
SakeBomb Garage
Vendor Classifieds
5
08-09-18 05:54 PM
diy, fd, fd3s, install, installation, installing, instructions, mazdaspeed, mazdatrix, review, reviews, rx7, shifter, short, throw