Exhaust dilemma, advice and suggestions please.
#1
Gone to the dark side
Thread Starter
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: New Orleans, LA
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Exhaust dilemma, advice and suggestions please.
I have a Racing Beat dual tip cat-back, I love it. I love how my car is anything but obnoxious (noise wise). I am about to install a HKS DP on Friday. I am happy with this as it is a huge reliability mod.
My question is this, I have a hi-flow cat that I can't decide whether or not to install. I am worried about 2 main things: Noise and Boost creep (which I do not totally understand btw).
I would be happy to let out more heat as the hi-flo would allow and the hp that comes with I am just stuck trying to decide.
For anyone who has a Hi-flow cat, please tell me what you think of them as well as anyone who happens to have with a Racing Beat dual tip (IMO this is the quietest after market muffler I have ever owned.
All comments welcome.
Thanks
Z
My question is this, I have a hi-flow cat that I can't decide whether or not to install. I am worried about 2 main things: Noise and Boost creep (which I do not totally understand btw).
I would be happy to let out more heat as the hi-flo would allow and the hp that comes with I am just stuck trying to decide.
For anyone who has a Hi-flow cat, please tell me what you think of them as well as anyone who happens to have with a Racing Beat dual tip (IMO this is the quietest after market muffler I have ever owned.
All comments welcome.
Thanks
Z
#3
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
It will only be a little louder with the hi-flow cat, more so after transition.
The much more open exhaust will result in elevated boost levels, which you can control with a boost controller. Installing a hi-flow cat will NOT result in boost creep, which is uncontrolled rising of boost (and is due to an overwhelmed wastegate).
Go for it.
The much more open exhaust will result in elevated boost levels, which you can control with a boost controller. Installing a hi-flow cat will NOT result in boost creep, which is uncontrolled rising of boost (and is due to an overwhelmed wastegate).
Go for it.
#4
2/4 wheel cornering fiend
I seriously doubt that you will experience any boost creep with a hi-flow cat. However, one thing that I would be worried about is exceeding the capabilities of the stock ECU with that exhaust combination. Do you have a boost gauge? I'd be hesitant to install the hi-flow cat unless you have an upgraded ECU (or standalone) of some sort. EDIT: Or, a boost controller as rynberg recommends.
Noise level will definitely pick up a bit with the hi-flow. I have an RB dual with DP and hi-flow, and it definitely got a bit louder, especially when the secondary comes online at WOT.
Noise level will definitely pick up a bit with the hi-flow. I have an RB dual with DP and hi-flow, and it definitely got a bit louder, especially when the secondary comes online at WOT.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Clearwater, FL
Posts: 364
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Kento
I seriously doubt that you will experience any boost creep with a hi-flow cat. However, one thing that I would be worried about is exceeding the capabilities of the stock ECU with that exhaust combination. Do you have a boost gauge? I'd be hesitant to install the hi-flow cat unless you have an upgraded ECU (or standalone) of some sort. EDIT: Or, a boost controller as rynberg recommends.
Noise level will definitely pick up a bit with the hi-flow. I have an RB dual with DP and hi-flow, and it definitely got a bit louder, especially when the secondary comes online at WOT.
Noise level will definitely pick up a bit with the hi-flow. I have an RB dual with DP and hi-flow, and it definitely got a bit louder, especially when the secondary comes online at WOT.
As for noise it will be heard when you open it up and you will loose some low end torque which will be more than made up for up high. At idle its not bad at all, do it.
#6
Gone to the dark side
Thread Starter
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: New Orleans, LA
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
oh, sorry forgot to mention I have a PFC, just haven't installed. Was waiting till I put the Intercooler in this weekend.
I am ok if noise is mainly different when WOT and 2nd Turbo comes in.
I also was going to put in a "newer" set of turbos in (mine have 92k on them) and the ones I got from another FD guy in New Orleans have about 40k and a ported wastegate.
Guess that would have helped...
My biggest concern was daily put putting around in town, didn't want to sound like a civic with 5" Folgers can exhaust.
My past 2 months has been doing fixes to broken things in the car and reliability mods. Now on to the fun stuff....
Hopefully by Monday I will have installed: My stainless 3" DP, Efini Y-Pipe, newer turbos, Hi-Flo Cat, Greddy SMIC and PFC. I'm assuming I'll see a nice difference in performance.
Here's to hoping everything goes well.
Thanks for your opinions guys.
I am ok if noise is mainly different when WOT and 2nd Turbo comes in.
I also was going to put in a "newer" set of turbos in (mine have 92k on them) and the ones I got from another FD guy in New Orleans have about 40k and a ported wastegate.
Guess that would have helped...
My biggest concern was daily put putting around in town, didn't want to sound like a civic with 5" Folgers can exhaust.
My past 2 months has been doing fixes to broken things in the car and reliability mods. Now on to the fun stuff....
Hopefully by Monday I will have installed: My stainless 3" DP, Efini Y-Pipe, newer turbos, Hi-Flo Cat, Greddy SMIC and PFC. I'm assuming I'll see a nice difference in performance.
Here's to hoping everything goes well.
Thanks for your opinions guys.
Trending Topics
#8
2/4 wheel cornering fiend
Originally Posted by zonblitz
oh, sorry forgot to mention I have a PFC, just haven't installed. Was waiting till I put the Intercooler in this weekend.
I am ok if noise is mainly different when WOT and 2nd Turbo comes in.
I also was going to put in a "newer" set of turbos in (mine have 92k on them) and the ones I got from another FD guy in New Orleans have about 40k and a ported wastegate.
Guess that would have helped...
My biggest concern was daily put putting around in town, didn't want to sound like a civic with 5" Folgers can exhaust.
My past 2 months has been doing fixes to broken things in the car and reliability mods. Now on to the fun stuff....
Hopefully by Monday I will have installed: My stainless 3" DP, Efini Y-Pipe, newer turbos, Hi-Flo Cat, Greddy SMIC and PFC. I'm assuming I'll see a nice difference in performance.
Here's to hoping everything goes well.
Thanks for your opinions guys.
I am ok if noise is mainly different when WOT and 2nd Turbo comes in.
I also was going to put in a "newer" set of turbos in (mine have 92k on them) and the ones I got from another FD guy in New Orleans have about 40k and a ported wastegate.
Guess that would have helped...
My biggest concern was daily put putting around in town, didn't want to sound like a civic with 5" Folgers can exhaust.
My past 2 months has been doing fixes to broken things in the car and reliability mods. Now on to the fun stuff....
Hopefully by Monday I will have installed: My stainless 3" DP, Efini Y-Pipe, newer turbos, Hi-Flo Cat, Greddy SMIC and PFC. I'm assuming I'll see a nice difference in performance.
Here's to hoping everything goes well.
Thanks for your opinions guys.
#9
King of the Duct Tape
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: PA
Posts: 1,177
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Kento
Just a little suggestion (take it for what it's worth): I'd avoid installing all of your mods at once. Throwing a boatload of aftermarket engine parts onto a car at one time can easily create a boatload of headaches if/when something goes wrong. By installing a ton of stuff at once, you've made your job that much harder when it comes time to diagnose any problems that crop up. Again, just a suggestion.
Of course when installing a new part means getting your car tuned doing it one at a time can be time consuming and/or expensive. +'s and -'s either way.
Also, I have a dp, hiflo, and rb dual tip and its not annoyingly loud in fact i think its pretty doggone good.
#10
Senior Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Pittsburgh
Posts: 289
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Kento
Just a little suggestion (take it for what it's worth): I'd avoid installing all of your mods at once. Throwing a boatload of aftermarket engine parts onto a car at one time can easily create a boatload of headaches if/when something goes wrong. By installing a ton of stuff at once, you've made your job that much harder when it comes time to diagnose any problems that crop up. Again, just a suggestion.
And DP, Hi-flow and RB is still pretty quiet. I like mine. Definitely not the obnoxious, droning sound of many setups.
#11
2/4 wheel cornering fiend
Originally Posted by airborne
Of course when installing a new part means getting your car tuned doing it one at a time can be time consuming and/or expensive. +'s and -'s either way.
#12
RX-7 Bad Ass
iTrader: (55)
I think you'll like the sound with downpipe and highflow cat - first off, it's hard for an FD to sound like a Honda with a fart can. FD's just typically sound good with exhaust, period, but it's really about how quiet you want it - it's VERY easy to end up with a deafeningly loud setup. HKS DP/HF cat/RB dual should be good and mellow, but roar at full throttle.
You will VERY likely get boost creep with that setup - I had a spike at transition with just a downpipe and old Trust cat-back. The PFC will control the boost if you don't have a boost controller, but it's pretty basic as a boost controller. If nothing else it will keep things from getting out of control until you get a good boost controller.
I also agree - start with downpipe/cat, get that sorted, go for the next step.
Dale
You will VERY likely get boost creep with that setup - I had a spike at transition with just a downpipe and old Trust cat-back. The PFC will control the boost if you don't have a boost controller, but it's pretty basic as a boost controller. If nothing else it will keep things from getting out of control until you get a good boost controller.
I also agree - start with downpipe/cat, get that sorted, go for the next step.
Dale
#13
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by DaleClark
You will VERY likely get boost creep with that setup
Like I said above, this setup will result in ELEVATED boost, which is NOT boost creep. I have never heard of a single person who experienced boost creep with a hi-flow cat. Some people don't even experience it with a midpipe, for whatever reason.
#14
Gone to the dark side
Thread Starter
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: New Orleans, LA
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ok, just to clear up a few things, my car is not totally stock as of now. I have a apexi power intake, a RB dual tip cat back. Rest are reliability mods, Fluidyne, AST etc. I know that's not too extensive. I was going to install the Intercooler first, and the efini Y-pipe shouldn't make a difference, should it (was going to do when I did DP)?
So are you guys saying wait on the IC and do the Hi flo and DP first? And how long should I wait before installing the PFC then IC or IC then PFC (IC is Greddy SMIC btw)
What about air pump removal? should I wait?
also I am waiting on changing turbos for now. I agree with above could cause more issues if I need to troubleshoot.
So are you guys saying wait on the IC and do the Hi flo and DP first? And how long should I wait before installing the PFC then IC or IC then PFC (IC is Greddy SMIC btw)
What about air pump removal? should I wait?
also I am waiting on changing turbos for now. I agree with above could cause more issues if I need to troubleshoot.
#15
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
If you are going to put new turbos in, you might as well do the y-pipe and the downpipe at the same time, unless you like duplicating a lot of work.
You can put the PFC in at any time and I suggest you do it now, to make sure everything's A-OK. The base map is fine for 10 psi without a midpipe as is.
I think you're making the whole situation more complicated than it needs to be. The intercooler and hi-flow cat, for example, are easy to install at any time and won't really effect anything else. The turbos, downpipe, and y-pipe should be done at the same time. The PFC should go in first.
See, not that complicated...
You can put the PFC in at any time and I suggest you do it now, to make sure everything's A-OK. The base map is fine for 10 psi without a midpipe as is.
I think you're making the whole situation more complicated than it needs to be. The intercooler and hi-flow cat, for example, are easy to install at any time and won't really effect anything else. The turbos, downpipe, and y-pipe should be done at the same time. The PFC should go in first.
See, not that complicated...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Skeese
Adaptronic Engine Mgmt - AUS
65
03-28-17 03:30 PM
fastrx7man
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
33
09-02-15 09:42 PM