2012 FD Calendar Picture Submittal
10-31-11, 10:32 AM
#227
11-01-11, 06:25 PM
#228
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Sarasota FL
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
lol ... im not "hating" anything.... are you too overly sensitive that you cannot handle any constructive criticism?
TheAsset and i were not negative negative or disparaging in any way, we simply stated some observations that struck us odd, that maybe you had not considered.
correct me if i'm wrong, but discussion and feedback is one of the major purposes of a forum like this, right?
wouldn't you agree that it's good to learn from other peoples perspectives and feedback?
anyway, thanks for making a community calendar and im sure it will turn out just fine.
TheAsset and i were not negative negative or disparaging in any way, we simply stated some observations that struck us odd, that maybe you had not considered.
correct me if i'm wrong, but discussion and feedback is one of the major purposes of a forum like this, right?
wouldn't you agree that it's good to learn from other peoples perspectives and feedback?
anyway, thanks for making a community calendar and im sure it will turn out just fine.
11-01-11, 09:40 PM
#229
i agree.... the category thing is weird... on some it felt like i was choosing between a all mediocre shots that i didnt really care about... and then others i felt i had to choose from 3 or 4 that i wanted and could only pick 1.
and why is there just one dudes car in one group... that doesnt seem right.
and why is there just one dudes car in one group... that doesnt seem right.
...I guess for some reason after seeing the professionalism in some of the photos people had submitted, I assumed the calender would follow in the same manner. I realize it's not my calender and all that, but I feel like the people who took the time to build such beautiful machines and get photos taken, could at least get a calender that is put together with the same level of time and respect. Given the unorthodox voting system, I'm not sure there's much point to voting at all. Sure you can't make everyone happy, but that's not even the point here.
Let alone the voting is scattered all over the 3rd gen section. A little organization would go a long way. Is this how it has been done in years prior to this calender?
Regardless at least it's a calender full of RX7's
11-02-11, 12:33 AM
#230
Yea you hit it on the head and that's not even covering it all.
...I guess for some reason after seeing the professionalism in some of the photos people had submitted, I assumed the calender would follow in the same manner. I realize it's not my calender and all that, but I feel like the people who took the time to build such beautiful machines and get photos taken, could at least get a calender that is put together with the same level of time and respect. Given the unorthodox voting system, I'm not sure there's much point to voting at all. Sure you can't make everyone happy, but that's not even the point here.
Let alone the voting is scattered all over the 3rd gen section. A little organization would go a long way. Is this how it has been done in years prior to this calender?
Regardless at least it's a calender full of RX7's
...I guess for some reason after seeing the professionalism in some of the photos people had submitted, I assumed the calender would follow in the same manner. I realize it's not my calender and all that, but I feel like the people who took the time to build such beautiful machines and get photos taken, could at least get a calender that is put together with the same level of time and respect. Given the unorthodox voting system, I'm not sure there's much point to voting at all. Sure you can't make everyone happy, but that's not even the point here.
Let alone the voting is scattered all over the 3rd gen section. A little organization would go a long way. Is this how it has been done in years prior to this calender?
Regardless at least it's a calender full of RX7's
As for organisation, the only thing that would make it more organized is stickying the voting threads. However, that is out of twinchargedfds (sp?) hands.
If you had a voting regime that you think would be better, you should suggest it to twinchargedfd (sorry i don't know your name lol). However, I think the colour sorting is great. A calendar of all red or all blue or all black, white... any colour car is boring. This gets the most variety imo.
This method is tried and tested and if you look at past years calendars, it really works well. The finished product is never anything to complain about.
11-02-11, 05:32 AM
#231
This is how its been done in the past, what is your great idea Asset? You can only have 10 items in a voting/poll thread, so if I were to keep it all in 1 thread, then you'd only get a 10 month calendar, gee, that sounds great.
And with regard to professionalism, I spent more time sorting pictures and compiling voting threads than most people spent taking the pictures. In each category, there are at least 2 calendar worthy photos. I also offer these to the club with fast shipping, and cover anything that gets damaged on its way, for a much lower price than most can purchase a nice car calendar for. (40% cheaper than last year's supra club calendar by the way)
Also, winning the voting doesn't guarantee a spot in the calendar, once I close it, if there are a few really good pictures that are close in the amount of votes they received, I put them in a single poll and have a wildcard vote.
And the voting isn't scattered, its in the top level of the 3rd gen section to get the most views/votes, a sub forum would hide it. I also bump it often to keep them on the first page for at least a day once a week.
Everyone loved the end result last year, and they will this year. If you don't like it, don't buy one, its simple. Or maybe you're just upset that you won't be in the calendar?
And with regard to professionalism, I spent more time sorting pictures and compiling voting threads than most people spent taking the pictures. In each category, there are at least 2 calendar worthy photos. I also offer these to the club with fast shipping, and cover anything that gets damaged on its way, for a much lower price than most can purchase a nice car calendar for. (40% cheaper than last year's supra club calendar by the way)
Also, winning the voting doesn't guarantee a spot in the calendar, once I close it, if there are a few really good pictures that are close in the amount of votes they received, I put them in a single poll and have a wildcard vote.
And the voting isn't scattered, its in the top level of the 3rd gen section to get the most views/votes, a sub forum would hide it. I also bump it often to keep them on the first page for at least a day once a week.
Everyone loved the end result last year, and they will this year. If you don't like it, don't buy one, its simple. Or maybe you're just upset that you won't be in the calendar?
11-02-11, 01:57 PM
#232
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Sarasota FL
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thats why there are some 3rd party polling plugins that allow more than 10 items, and are ip secured which would allow you to keep it all in one thread, and also have people choose between all the photos together, rather than groups of 10.
Might be something to try next time
11-02-11, 03:58 PM
#233
what ever is the descision . most of the pics here are woth. i will buy the calendar no mattert what is decided.
if you still take suggestions, try to add pics of engine bay /20B & 13B engines.. extreme interiors.. some ls1/2Jz conversions..
i know its too much to ask. do what you can.
awesome job you doing so far, taking on this work.
Sign me up for 4 when ready.
if you still take suggestions, try to add pics of engine bay /20B & 13B engines.. extreme interiors.. some ls1/2Jz conversions..
i know its too much to ask. do what you can.
awesome job you doing so far, taking on this work.
Sign me up for 4 when ready.
11-02-11, 07:31 PM
#234
This is how its been done in the past, what is your great idea Asset? You can only have 10 items in a voting/poll thread, so if I were to keep it all in 1 thread, then you'd only get a 10 month calendar, gee, that sounds great.
And with regard to professionalism, I spent more time sorting pictures and compiling voting threads than most people spent taking the pictures. In each category, there are at least 2 calendar worthy photos. I also offer these to the club with fast shipping, and cover anything that gets damaged on its way, for a much lower price than most can purchase a nice car calendar for. (40% cheaper than last year's supra club calendar by the way)
Also, winning the voting doesn't guarantee a spot in the calendar, once I close it, if there are a few really good pictures that are close in the amount of votes they received, I put them in a single poll and have a wildcard vote.
And the voting isn't scattered, its in the top level of the 3rd gen section to get the most views/votes, a sub forum would hide it. I also bump it often to keep them on the first page for at least a day once a week.
Everyone loved the end result last year, and they will this year. If you don't like it, don't buy one, its simple. Or maybe you're just upset that you won't be in the calendar?
And with regard to professionalism, I spent more time sorting pictures and compiling voting threads than most people spent taking the pictures. In each category, there are at least 2 calendar worthy photos. I also offer these to the club with fast shipping, and cover anything that gets damaged on its way, for a much lower price than most can purchase a nice car calendar for. (40% cheaper than last year's supra club calendar by the way)
Also, winning the voting doesn't guarantee a spot in the calendar, once I close it, if there are a few really good pictures that are close in the amount of votes they received, I put them in a single poll and have a wildcard vote.
And the voting isn't scattered, its in the top level of the 3rd gen section to get the most views/votes, a sub forum would hide it. I also bump it often to keep them on the first page for at least a day once a week.
Everyone loved the end result last year, and they will this year. If you don't like it, don't buy one, its simple. Or maybe you're just upset that you won't be in the calendar?
Is there some reason some photos were excluded?...as in (Blue 2/Black 2/etc 2.)
11-16-11, 09:59 AM
#241
Group buy will be up next week after thanksgiving. Please be on the lookout for 2 wildcard voting threads. The majority of the calendar is set in line with voting, but there are quite a few really close ones (from the multiple groups), and I'll pair them up and we'll make sure we get the best pics for the calendar.
