Problems with leading coil
#1
Rotary mind...
Thread Starter
Problems with leading coil
I've been having problems with my '86 RX7.
About 2 weeks ago, while I was driving, it started acting funny. I could tell right away that it was flooding. I managed to get home but just barely. The exaust smelled different and the cat got very hot. Engine stalled as soon as I let go of the throttle. Didn't start after that and flooded right away.
I swapped 3 more ECU's that I have for back up. Same simptoms.
Plugged in a spare CAS and spun by hand. The trailing coils fire strong.
Took the injector to be cleaned and checked. They reported no problems but were cleaned well.
I then checked the leading coil for spark. No Spark at the plugs. Unplug both wires from the coil and there's spark between both towers. If i stick a piece of bare copper wire in a tower and point it close to the coils base, there's spark.
Here's the twist. As soon as I plug in a plug cable. NO SPARK!!! I have MSD super conductor wires and they're fine. All four cables work in the trailing coils. The measured resistance in them goes from 130 to 165 ohms.
The CAS is not the problem. I have a spare coil with ignitor that was working before I put it in storage. Both coils do the exact same.
I noticed that with bare towers in the coil, when spinning the spare CAS by hand, the spark only goes from one tower to the other. If you put a bare metal conductor with close to 0 ohms, you can make the spark jump to something else. But if the conductor has higher resistance. No spark.
Also, with bare towers, 6 out of 10 sparks between them are strong, and the rest are tiny little sparks, only visible in complete darkness and barely audible.
I'm lost as to what this may be.
I thought the coil would be bad (both measure at 0.9 Ohms). I'm unsure about the ECU's or something else.
Any ideas?
About 2 weeks ago, while I was driving, it started acting funny. I could tell right away that it was flooding. I managed to get home but just barely. The exaust smelled different and the cat got very hot. Engine stalled as soon as I let go of the throttle. Didn't start after that and flooded right away.
I swapped 3 more ECU's that I have for back up. Same simptoms.
Plugged in a spare CAS and spun by hand. The trailing coils fire strong.
Took the injector to be cleaned and checked. They reported no problems but were cleaned well.
I then checked the leading coil for spark. No Spark at the plugs. Unplug both wires from the coil and there's spark between both towers. If i stick a piece of bare copper wire in a tower and point it close to the coils base, there's spark.
Here's the twist. As soon as I plug in a plug cable. NO SPARK!!! I have MSD super conductor wires and they're fine. All four cables work in the trailing coils. The measured resistance in them goes from 130 to 165 ohms.
The CAS is not the problem. I have a spare coil with ignitor that was working before I put it in storage. Both coils do the exact same.
I noticed that with bare towers in the coil, when spinning the spare CAS by hand, the spark only goes from one tower to the other. If you put a bare metal conductor with close to 0 ohms, you can make the spark jump to something else. But if the conductor has higher resistance. No spark.
Also, with bare towers, 6 out of 10 sparks between them are strong, and the rest are tiny little sparks, only visible in complete darkness and barely audible.
I'm lost as to what this may be.
I thought the coil would be bad (both measure at 0.9 Ohms). I'm unsure about the ECU's or something else.
Any ideas?
#3
This is my social media.
iTrader: (22)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: WA
Posts: 2,744
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That leading coil MUST be grounded very well. (Making good contact with the engine bay.) - I actually run a ground wire from the negative terminal to the base of the leading coil.
#5
Rotary mind...
Thread Starter
FYI. Just got the car to start. Runs rough but is on. The problem seems to be the spark plug wires that are arcing really bad.
I bought these MSD about 3 years ago an have no more than 15K miles on them. I thought MSD made better quality products. These are **** IMHO, because they just arc from the entire length of the wire. Terrible.
The engine is almost flooding because the spark is crap at the plug. All energy is lost along the way.
Any suggestions on the best wires for street use available?
I bought these MSD about 3 years ago an have no more than 15K miles on them. I thought MSD made better quality products. These are **** IMHO, because they just arc from the entire length of the wire. Terrible.
The engine is almost flooding because the spark is crap at the plug. All energy is lost along the way.
Any suggestions on the best wires for street use available?
#6
Rotary mind...
Thread Starter
I spoke today with an MSD tech about my problem. He offered no solution and had no idea of what could have caused the problem. He did mention though, that the measured resistance of my wires is higher than their specs and that it indicates that the wires are shot.
He said that the expected life of these wires is short because they are racing wires.
Needless to say I'm very disapointed and will most likely not buy these wires again.
He said that the expected life of these wires is short because they are racing wires.
Needless to say I'm very disapointed and will most likely not buy these wires again.
Trending Topics
#10
Sharp Claws
iTrader: (30)
why?
why do people put so much stock in the plug wires?
there is no noticable gain from spending that extra money in almost all cases unless you absolutely need the maximum spark energy you can get, in almost all cases you do not. in almost all cases you wind up with an unreliable set of wires.
if you insist on aftermarket, get a set of tailor wires for a SBC V8, you can put together about 3 sets for the same price. then you get some nice brightly colored plug wires.
why do people put so much stock in the plug wires?
there is no noticable gain from spending that extra money in almost all cases unless you absolutely need the maximum spark energy you can get, in almost all cases you do not. in almost all cases you wind up with an unreliable set of wires.
if you insist on aftermarket, get a set of tailor wires for a SBC V8, you can put together about 3 sets for the same price. then you get some nice brightly colored plug wires.
Last edited by RotaryEvolution; 09-25-12 at 07:54 PM.
#11
talking head
+1 .. a scenario played out time and time again..
owner: but i paid $150 for these wires .. they are good !
8 hrs later..
me : you need new wires.. i need a life back now i proved it wasnt anything else BUT these frigging wires ..////
if i charged $110 an hour like other rotor specialists ,, would you argue the point ?
buy $7 efi bosch 8mm items ,,they work fine with HEI.. when they are dead,, they are dead,, and it doesnt hurt at $7 a piece to just swap these FIRST
owner: but i paid $150 for these wires .. they are good !
8 hrs later..
me : you need new wires.. i need a life back now i proved it wasnt anything else BUT these frigging wires ..////
if i charged $110 an hour like other rotor specialists ,, would you argue the point ?
buy $7 efi bosch 8mm items ,,they work fine with HEI.. when they are dead,, they are dead,, and it doesnt hurt at $7 a piece to just swap these FIRST
#13
Rotary mind...
Thread Starter
I have nothing bad to say about the stock wires.
The thing is that, undeniably, within the realm of a relatively stock engine, the stronger the spark, the better.
The OEM wires are long on reliabilty but short on performance. We all know that all cars can be improved on by using aftermarket parts.
The trick is to buy the good aftermarket parts instead of the cheap or crummy ones.
Even a brand name can sometimes be synonymus with not so good stuff, my problem being an example.
This is my second bad experience with an MSD product. The first was a hi performance coil that went bu-bu on a Chevy SB V8 that I had. It quit (arcing from the bottom of the plastic body) in less than a year of use.
If you could chose two wires to conduct energy, wouldn't you pick the one that does so better?
I don't mind spending some $$$ if the part is worth it.
The thing is that, undeniably, within the realm of a relatively stock engine, the stronger the spark, the better.
The OEM wires are long on reliabilty but short on performance. We all know that all cars can be improved on by using aftermarket parts.
The trick is to buy the good aftermarket parts instead of the cheap or crummy ones.
Even a brand name can sometimes be synonymus with not so good stuff, my problem being an example.
This is my second bad experience with an MSD product. The first was a hi performance coil that went bu-bu on a Chevy SB V8 that I had. It quit (arcing from the bottom of the plastic body) in less than a year of use.
If you could chose two wires to conduct energy, wouldn't you pick the one that does so better?
I don't mind spending some $$$ if the part is worth it.
#14
Sharp Claws
iTrader: (30)
yes, well i hear people say the same thing about stock ignitors and coils, yet i have pushed over 500whp from STOCK coils/ignitors(magnacor wires, but they're junk and fall apart each plug change). how much spark energy do you think you need? FC ignition including the rather thin plug wires still perform VERY well.
after a point you're just burning money for nothing.
anyways, i'll end trying to convince you at that.
after a point you're just burning money for nothing.
anyways, i'll end trying to convince you at that.
Last edited by RotaryEvolution; 09-25-12 at 10:20 PM.
#16
New Turbo time!
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 91
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you want to go aftermarket then i would recommend getting the Re Amemiya leads since Mazdaspeed no longer make them for the FC. Its the highest quality your going to get but its not cheap.
I agree with RotaryEvolution the OEM ones are excellent and if you want more spark go buy a twin power, but the NGK ones generally last longer than an engine from what ive seen.
I agree with RotaryEvolution the OEM ones are excellent and if you want more spark go buy a twin power, but the NGK ones generally last longer than an engine from what ive seen.
#17
Rotary mind...
Thread Starter
I ended up buying NGK Power Cables
NGK quality but better than the stock ones.
Also, while those get in, I had to put a set of Denso Iridium Racing Plugs. They have a lower resistnace than the standard NGK plugs and diminished the arcing from the wires, to the point where it now starts and drives.
If resistance in the calbes or the plugs was good for performance why do racing plugs don't have a resistor?
Denying that resistance in the conductor of the electric energy that will ultimately produce a spark as it jumps between the center electrode and the ground one, is stupid.
Resistance is the oposite of conductance. You must use energy tio overcome resistance, energy that otherwise would be used to create the spark in mention.
If OEM was enough, then lets all keep using the OEM air filter, OEM tires, OEM brake pads, OEM exhaust, OEM ECU's. Bottom line is that OEM manufacturers have priorities:
Reliabilty (to avoid warranty claims or lawsuits)
Cost (to fill their pockets)
The best possible performance is not at the top of their list. If such was the case, the aftermarket bussines would not exist. People would realize that OEM performs better and stick to it.
Improved performance is not only meassured in HP. It can also mean reduced emmisions, improved mileage, smoother running etc.
I have to pass smog test and HC levels in a rotary are always high, if I can help the air/fuel mixture ignite better and more throughly, I'll be happy.
OEM cables use technology that's many many years old. Why stick to it?
NGK quality but better than the stock ones.
Also, while those get in, I had to put a set of Denso Iridium Racing Plugs. They have a lower resistnace than the standard NGK plugs and diminished the arcing from the wires, to the point where it now starts and drives.
If resistance in the calbes or the plugs was good for performance why do racing plugs don't have a resistor?
Denying that resistance in the conductor of the electric energy that will ultimately produce a spark as it jumps between the center electrode and the ground one, is stupid.
Resistance is the oposite of conductance. You must use energy tio overcome resistance, energy that otherwise would be used to create the spark in mention.
If OEM was enough, then lets all keep using the OEM air filter, OEM tires, OEM brake pads, OEM exhaust, OEM ECU's. Bottom line is that OEM manufacturers have priorities:
Reliabilty (to avoid warranty claims or lawsuits)
Cost (to fill their pockets)
The best possible performance is not at the top of their list. If such was the case, the aftermarket bussines would not exist. People would realize that OEM performs better and stick to it.
Improved performance is not only meassured in HP. It can also mean reduced emmisions, improved mileage, smoother running etc.
I have to pass smog test and HC levels in a rotary are always high, if I can help the air/fuel mixture ignite better and more throughly, I'll be happy.
OEM cables use technology that's many many years old. Why stick to it?
#19
talking head
if resistance was everything,, youd be back to copper plugs and solid wires .. but since your engine will consume copper plugs at a fearsome rate ,, and the wires would interfere with any ECU .. then you have fine wire electrode plugs with a rare metal coating ( at a compromise of material strength/ resistance )
and you also have an inbuilt resistance in either plug , lead or both ----- to suit the ecu,, and electronic equipment in a fair radius
i use non resistive bike plugs ,, platinum/palladium .. with the bosch generic 8mm leads
..and i can still turn on street lights thats have faulty starters when i pass beneath them
its a good job the ecu has some inbuilt noise reduction and filtering techniques
everywhere there is give take and balance... i need a damn good spark cause i use LPG fuel...
so plugs wires and coil dwell are all balanced in combinations that push just far enough but not too far
-- dwell on LS1 coils is 4.5 ms // not too much that i run out at higher revs // not too much that it overheats the coils // enough to fire this mix at 18 psi
wires are ballasted, cheap and easy to replace when done.. not killing days wondering if they are Ok or not,, just replace and be sure //
plugs are racing bike plugs.. cheap compared to mazda ones.. they leads have just enough ballast resistance to keep the noise sane
--but not super duper iriduim.. and for a reason --
previously ( on three separate occasions ) i have seen two popular brands lose the fine wire tip into the engine ....
and same,, for the cheap copper bike plugs ( NGK B8ES etc ) .. copper expands . fast .. with flooded plugs this can amount to a bit of the porcelin coming adrift....
.... it takes 20 plus years and lots of fuckups to amass this knowledge.. take from it what you want .. you have been pre warned
and you also have an inbuilt resistance in either plug , lead or both ----- to suit the ecu,, and electronic equipment in a fair radius
i use non resistive bike plugs ,, platinum/palladium .. with the bosch generic 8mm leads
..and i can still turn on street lights thats have faulty starters when i pass beneath them
its a good job the ecu has some inbuilt noise reduction and filtering techniques
everywhere there is give take and balance... i need a damn good spark cause i use LPG fuel...
so plugs wires and coil dwell are all balanced in combinations that push just far enough but not too far
-- dwell on LS1 coils is 4.5 ms // not too much that i run out at higher revs // not too much that it overheats the coils // enough to fire this mix at 18 psi
wires are ballasted, cheap and easy to replace when done.. not killing days wondering if they are Ok or not,, just replace and be sure //
plugs are racing bike plugs.. cheap compared to mazda ones.. they leads have just enough ballast resistance to keep the noise sane
--but not super duper iriduim.. and for a reason --
previously ( on three separate occasions ) i have seen two popular brands lose the fine wire tip into the engine ....
and same,, for the cheap copper bike plugs ( NGK B8ES etc ) .. copper expands . fast .. with flooded plugs this can amount to a bit of the porcelin coming adrift....
.... it takes 20 plus years and lots of fuckups to amass this knowledge.. take from it what you want .. you have been pre warned
#20
Dragons' Breath
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Pump Handle, SK. Canada
Posts: 1,129
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
change your spark plugs , If the coils don't fire the plugs they might not be collapsing properly , If they don't collapse proper they can't recharge for the next fire . These guys are correct in saying there is to much talk about plug wires . I have tried old wires from an ( ordinary application ) and they worked just as well as a new expensive set . JMO have a good one Gerald m.
I use 2 trailing coils for my leading set up and they fire very hard.
I use 2 trailing coils for my leading set up and they fire very hard.
Last edited by gerald m; 09-28-12 at 10:42 PM.
#23
Full Member
#25
Full Member
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Jeff20B
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
73
09-16-18 07:16 PM
SakeBomb Garage
Vendor Classifieds
0
09-04-15 05:19 PM