Compression Testing
#1
Compression Testing
Recently I have seen a few threads with videos of compression tests done by "rotary shops". These were done with a piston compression tester which will not yield any real results besides showing that it is blown (0 compression). Trying to determine that an engine has low compression with a piston tester is a bad idea. The cranking speed of the engine plays a huge role in capturing the correct compression.
Here is the newest edition of the Mazda Rotary Engine Compression Tester, that we have had for several years. Notice that in the first picture the compression is low 6.7, 6.6, 6.8 (around 95psi) with the rpm reading at 175. The Mazda tester has a 250 RPM normalization button, in the next picture you can see that the compression is perfect 8.5,8.5,8.6 (around 125psi)
Here is the newest edition of the Mazda Rotary Engine Compression Tester, that we have had for several years. Notice that in the first picture the compression is low 6.7, 6.6, 6.8 (around 95psi) with the rpm reading at 175. The Mazda tester has a 250 RPM normalization button, in the next picture you can see that the compression is perfect 8.5,8.5,8.6 (around 125psi)
#3
Lousy Crew Chief
iTrader: (10)
No he's showing how much of a difference the proper RPM makes in determining compression...
I'm sure a Mazda compression tester like that runs an arm and a leg. There is a vender that just popped up that has something similar that's around $350.
Thanks for this banzai racing!
Matt
I'm sure a Mazda compression tester like that runs an arm and a leg. There is a vender that just popped up that has something similar that's around $350.
Thanks for this banzai racing!
Matt
#7
Piston testers will really only tell you if the engine has some sort of seal failure. The actual numbers that it yields should not be used. The recent video that I saw was a "shop" showing the customer they had low compression, which simply can not be determined with a piston tester since there is no way to capture the cranking speed. It is pretty easy for an unscrupulous "shop" to show 60-70 psi compression, if the engine we were testing above had compression of 105 @ 250rpm it would be down in the 70's @175rpm and this is if the test is done properly with the throttle held wide open. Leave the throttle closed and the compression drops even more drastically.
Last edited by Banzai-Racing; 04-09-16 at 06:59 AM.
Trending Topics
#10
Junior Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But gas is cheap and the drive through the smokies is fantastic! Seriously though, we have family in Carmel so this would likely be just a side trip to consider while visiting this summer. Maybe we can talk about some mods as well. I'll look you up.
#17
Problem there is that the ECU needs to be disabled to prevent fuel and spark. It also does not solve the problem for anyone with a stock ECU.
FSM instructions are to pull the circuit opening relay and unplug the igniter.
FSM instructions are to pull the circuit opening relay and unplug the igniter.
Last edited by Banzai-Racing; 04-13-16 at 07:21 AM.
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Posts: 301
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why not unplug the coil harness and take the EGI relay out, that would stop the spark and fuel and then you can read the engine RPM on the commander?
#19
half ass 2 or whole ass 1
iTrader: (114)
Yes something along those lines. When I deflood, I unplug the coil pack harness and unplug the the fuel pump in the trunk. I remove the spark plugs too of course and I get an rpm reading on the power fc. What im interested in is how to regulate cranking rpm.
#20
You can't regulate cranking RPM, that is why there is a normalization table in the FSM for cranking speed and altitude. page C-10
#21
Eats, Sleeps, Dreams Rotary
My rule of thumb is taking the car to the track and measuring it's trap speed. If that numbers makes you happy then rotor on.
Of course this doesn't help when buying a used car but I prefer this test to any other.
Of course this doesn't help when buying a used car but I prefer this test to any other.
Recently I have seen a few threads with videos of compression tests done by "rotary shops". These were done with a piston compression tester which will not yield any real results besides showing that it is blown (0 compression). Trying to determine that an engine has low compression with a piston tester is a bad idea. The cranking speed of the engine plays a huge role in capturing the correct compression.
Here is the newest edition of the Mazda Rotary Engine Compression Tester, that we have had for several years. Notice that in the first picture the compression is low 6.7, 6.6, 6.8 (around 95psi) with the rpm reading at 175. The Mazda tester has a 250 RPM normalization button, in the next picture you can see that the compression is perfect 8.5,8.5,8.6 (around 125psi)
Here is the newest edition of the Mazda Rotary Engine Compression Tester, that we have had for several years. Notice that in the first picture the compression is low 6.7, 6.6, 6.8 (around 95psi) with the rpm reading at 175. The Mazda tester has a 250 RPM normalization button, in the next picture you can see that the compression is perfect 8.5,8.5,8.6 (around 125psi)
#23
Eats, Sleeps, Dreams Rotary
#25
rotorhead
iTrader: (3)
I realize that I suggested people reading this thread use the compensation curves in the service manual, but it's not entirely obvious how to do that. So I went ahead and made a Microsoft Excel tool to assist. I am going to make a separate thread to spread the word.
The tool is available here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_j...ew?usp=sharing
It uses the cranking speed (from some source besides the tachometer in the instrument panel), compression reading in psi, and altitude that can be easily looked up online (whatismyelevation.com). The compensation formula came from determining the linear slope of the curves in the service manual diagrams.
This isn't as good as using a real Mazda compression tester but it's a step towards a more accurate understanding of engine health.
The tool is available here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_j...ew?usp=sharing
It uses the cranking speed (from some source besides the tachometer in the instrument panel), compression reading in psi, and altitude that can be easily looked up online (whatismyelevation.com). The compensation formula came from determining the linear slope of the curves in the service manual diagrams.
This isn't as good as using a real Mazda compression tester but it's a step towards a more accurate understanding of engine health.
Last edited by arghx; 04-16-16 at 08:13 AM.