Why wouldn't handling be better with spacers?
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why wouldn't handling be better with spacers?
I would think with spacers that you would have a wider wheel base and therefor handling would be better.
Right?
George
Right?
George
#2
Lives on the Forum
You mean wider track, not wider wheel base
Yes, I'd agree that a wider track coupled with a lower center of gravity will give nice handling and stick through the turns (given sticky tires of course).
Yes, I'd agree that a wider track coupled with a lower center of gravity will give nice handling and stick through the turns (given sticky tires of course).
#3
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by SleepR1
You mean wider track, not wider wheel base
You mean wider track, not wider wheel base
#5
Formula Mazda Driver
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
Posts: 680
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is also very hard on your wheel bearings and wheel studs. You need to get longer studs, that are stronger than stock as well. It is MUCH better to get wider tires with proper offsets, than to use spacers. Anything more 1/4" thick is not recommended for racing or any hard driving, as your wheel could fall off. Chances are, that won't happen, but most of us, won't take that chance.
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Bellingham, WA
Posts: 723
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
just because it alters the suspension geometry. In general, they will give you better handling, but like someone else suggested, it best to just get wheels with the offset you're looking for..
#7
SOLD THE RX-7!
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
Posts: 7,451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
read here for some info http://home1.gte.net/macross/offsetFAQ.html
and a post from somewhere else.
"I've seen nationally competitive, track record holding cars with front wheel spacers over 1" thick, with terrible scrub radius, that held track records and title wins for years...with no ill effect.
What you do by running wheel spacers, is increase the static and cornering loads on the wheels bearings, as you are creating more torque on the bearings from spacing your wheels farther out towards the fenders, HOWEVER if you could literally prove that you are abusing your wheel bearings to the point of failure on today's modern designed suspensions, then your car was poorly designed from the factory.
(think about it..... how much freaking force are you exerting just from auto-xing at BB with R compound tires ?!!! hahahaha
Don't worry about it Mase....I'm supposed to run 40mm offsets on my street car, and run a 19mm hubcentric spacer on a 35mm offset rim, for effective offset of 16mm. I've never had a problem yet, and that's still on my original OEM Nissan wheel bearings.
What you are changing is the track of the car, and the scrub radius of the tire...which will in effect make a car that scrubs off speed (more friction in a turn) than a car with proper offsets, but like I said, I didnt' see it slow down Collin Jackson too much in his untouchable GT4 Datsun 510 that literally owned track records at Seattle,Portland, Sears Point, Laguna Seca, Willow Springs etc. etc. for year.
It WILL wear your tires out faster, and give them uneven wear, but that's at the extreme instance.
"
and a post from somewhere else.
"I've seen nationally competitive, track record holding cars with front wheel spacers over 1" thick, with terrible scrub radius, that held track records and title wins for years...with no ill effect.
What you do by running wheel spacers, is increase the static and cornering loads on the wheels bearings, as you are creating more torque on the bearings from spacing your wheels farther out towards the fenders, HOWEVER if you could literally prove that you are abusing your wheel bearings to the point of failure on today's modern designed suspensions, then your car was poorly designed from the factory.
(think about it..... how much freaking force are you exerting just from auto-xing at BB with R compound tires ?!!! hahahaha
Don't worry about it Mase....I'm supposed to run 40mm offsets on my street car, and run a 19mm hubcentric spacer on a 35mm offset rim, for effective offset of 16mm. I've never had a problem yet, and that's still on my original OEM Nissan wheel bearings.
What you are changing is the track of the car, and the scrub radius of the tire...which will in effect make a car that scrubs off speed (more friction in a turn) than a car with proper offsets, but like I said, I didnt' see it slow down Collin Jackson too much in his untouchable GT4 Datsun 510 that literally owned track records at Seattle,Portland, Sears Point, Laguna Seca, Willow Springs etc. etc. for year.
It WILL wear your tires out faster, and give them uneven wear, but that's at the extreme instance.
"
Trending Topics
#8
Originally posted by maxcooper
It changes your scrub radius and spring rate (at the wheel), too.
-Max
It changes your scrub radius and spring rate (at the wheel), too.
-Max
Also, I can see how spacers would be hard on the wheel studs, but I don't see how a spacer or a wheel with an equivalent offset is any different to the bearing. The wheel stud thing might be enough to dissuade you from using spacers, but the load on the bearing would seem to be the same whether you acheived the widened track with spacers or wheel offset. Weld the spacer to the wheel and it will give you a wheel with a different offset. The load on the bearing from either one will be the same -- it depends only on where the tires end up (how wide the track is).
Having a wider track reduces load transfer.
-Max
#9
Lives on the Forum
I always imagine it being hard on the bearings for the same reason the scrub radius is so large. When I picture the spindle I see the wheel trying to bend the spindle within the bearing. With the tire sticking way out the bearing is no longer aligned with the contact patch and there is now leverage against the bearing through the spindle.
Not that this doesn't happen in cornering anyway and not that I have ever seen a wheel bearing actually fail, but it must surely shorten their life. I do agree that what I would absolutely most worry about is the studs. I don't like the idea of really long studs going through a spacer more than say 3/8" thick.
Not that this doesn't happen in cornering anyway and not that I have ever seen a wheel bearing actually fail, but it must surely shorten their life. I do agree that what I would absolutely most worry about is the studs. I don't like the idea of really long studs going through a spacer more than say 3/8" thick.
#10
Formula Mazda Driver
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
Posts: 680
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Widening the track by getting a wider rim with the proper offset you will barely be putting any more stress on the bearings because the wheel studs stay the same length. The only extra stress added to the bearings is a result of the car being able to transfer more weight to that tire before sliding. So technically, adding stiffer springs, anti-sway bars, or shocks will all be adding pressure load onto your wheel bearings.
Adding Spacers will require you to lengthen your wheel studs, or get spacers with built in studs. Either way you are changing where the sheer load is being placed on the studs in relationship to the bearings. The leverage point is pressed further away from the bearing, which adds more load.
If you think you can add spacers and not get longer studs, then be VERY careful. Remember the strength of a bolt lies in the shank and not the threads. If the sheer force is acting on the threads and not the shank then your studs could snap and you will wind up losing a wheel.
Adding Spacers will require you to lengthen your wheel studs, or get spacers with built in studs. Either way you are changing where the sheer load is being placed on the studs in relationship to the bearings. The leverage point is pressed further away from the bearing, which adds more load.
If you think you can add spacers and not get longer studs, then be VERY careful. Remember the strength of a bolt lies in the shank and not the threads. If the sheer force is acting on the threads and not the shank then your studs could snap and you will wind up losing a wheel.
#11
Originally posted by SpeedRacer
Widening the track by getting a wider rim with the proper offset you will barely be putting any more stress on the bearings because the wheel studs stay the same length. The only extra stress added to the bearings is a result of the car being able to transfer more weight to that tire before sliding. So technically, adding stiffer springs, anti-sway bars, or shocks will all be adding pressure load onto your wheel bearings.
Adding Spacers will require you to lengthen your wheel studs, or get spacers with built in studs. Either way you are changing where the sheer load is being placed on the studs in relationship to the bearings. The leverage point is pressed further away from the bearing, which adds more load.
Widening the track by getting a wider rim with the proper offset you will barely be putting any more stress on the bearings because the wheel studs stay the same length. The only extra stress added to the bearings is a result of the car being able to transfer more weight to that tire before sliding. So technically, adding stiffer springs, anti-sway bars, or shocks will all be adding pressure load onto your wheel bearings.
Adding Spacers will require you to lengthen your wheel studs, or get spacers with built in studs. Either way you are changing where the sheer load is being placed on the studs in relationship to the bearings. The leverage point is pressed further away from the bearing, which adds more load.
Increasing the track places more load on the bearings, but the load is the same if you use a spacer or wheels with a different offset.
The spacers put big loads on the wheel studs, which would not be an issue with wheels of a different offset.
-Max