17" vs 18"...which is better for the fd?
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: NJ
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
17" vs 18"...which is better for the fd?
which do you guys think i should get? 17s or 18s? the fd will be a only be a weekend car, street/strip warrior. the rims will be mated to bfg drags 315. im trying to decide on which size rims would be better.
i want the size to suit the car and make it show worthy. the problem is my area doesnt exactly have "nice" roads. there are many potholes on the streets but the highways are ok.
so which size do you guys think i should get?
i want the size to suit the car and make it show worthy. the problem is my area doesnt exactly have "nice" roads. there are many potholes on the streets but the highways are ok.
so which size do you guys think i should get?
#4
More sidewall = more traction to launch.
People generally go with 18's as a compromise of looks/performance. Go with 17's if you are more performance oriented. Some people go with 19's just for looks. I have a 18/19 staggered setup for the street and r-compounds and drag radials mounted on the stock 16in rims for the track/strip.
People generally go with 18's as a compromise of looks/performance. Go with 17's if you are more performance oriented. Some people go with 19's just for looks. I have a 18/19 staggered setup for the street and r-compounds and drag radials mounted on the stock 16in rims for the track/strip.
#7
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Why don't you put some real tires on some nice 17 or 18" wheels for street use, and mount some M/T Streets on the stockers for going to the drag strip? Unless you're in the 9's, I doubt you'll need more tire than a 26x10x16, which fits on the stock wheels.
Then you can run tires that actually handle well and have some treadlife for street use.
BTW, I'd like to know what some of you guys consider to be lesser performance with 18s..
Then you can run tires that actually handle well and have some treadlife for street use.
BTW, I'd like to know what some of you guys consider to be lesser performance with 18s..
Last edited by rynberg; 05-06-05 at 07:40 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
To clarify, performance = less unsprung weight, and if you are a street-light racer or drag racing on street tires, more sidewall on your street tires for launching.
In addition to performance 2slow4u, you will have a softer ride and less chance of bending a rim on a pot-hole with 17's compared to 18's. I personally prefer the look of 18's myself.
In addition to performance 2slow4u, you will have a softer ride and less chance of bending a rim on a pot-hole with 17's compared to 18's. I personally prefer the look of 18's myself.
#9
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by Hellspawn
To clarify, performance = less unsprung weight, and if you are a street-light racer or drag racing on street tires, more sidewall on your street tires for launching.
2. Anyone running 17 or 18" wheels at the drag strip isn't going for the best time possible, period. Like I said, he should run M/T Streets on stock 16" wheels if he wants to be faster at the strip.
3. It is easy to find 18s that weigh comparable to even a fairly light 17 wheel. With most quality wheels, you are gaining only 1-1.5 lbs in the same width. In addition, 18" tires in the wider sizes are often 1-2 lbs LIGHTER than the same width 17" tire. Other than slight rotational inertia differences, there is no weight difference between a 17 and 18 wheel+tire of the same model.
4. As if 99% of the people here are good enough drivers to notice any differences between 17 and 18" wheels.
5. Running really wide tires is much easier with 18s due to additional suspension clearance in board and the lower profiles in wider 18" tires vs 17" tires.
#11
mhhh
iTrader: (21)
im still saying go for 16's. your getting a light wheel to start with so thatll obviously help your straight line better. 45-50 series is good considering you want it for both street (sidewalls not to high to make it slugish) and drag (always let some air pressure out with enough sidewall for absolute grip). you definantly wont really have to much to worry about with bending your wheels, as long as you arent hiting ditch like pot holes. i dunno......just what i would do. i personally think 18's are rediculous. 17's are good, but it needs something else to back it up if your goin for looks, such as suspension for it to be lower, or even something like a 99spec front.
#12
Originally Posted by rynberg
1. You shouldn't be doing drag style launches on the street anyway.
Originally Posted by rynberg
2. Anyone running 17 or 18" wheels at the drag strip isn't going for the best time possible, period. Like I said, he should run M/T Streets on stock 16" wheels if he wants to be faster at the strip.
Originally Posted by rynberg
3. It is easy to find 18s that weigh comparable to even a fairly light 17 wheel. With most quality wheels, you are gaining only 1-1.5 lbs in the same width. In addition, 18" tires in the wider sizes are often 1-2 lbs LIGHTER than the same width 17" tire. Other than slight rotational inertia differences, there is no weight difference between a 17 and 18 wheel+tire of the same model.
Originally Posted by rynberg
4. As if 99% of the people here are good enough drivers to notice any differences between 17 and 18" wheels.
Originally Posted by rynberg
5. Running really wide tires is much easier with 18s due to additional suspension clearance in board and the lower profiles in wider 18" tires vs 17" tires.
I have no problem with 18's lol, like I said I run 18/19 setup on the street. Not sure why you are trying to justify the performance of your 18's. We all know they work fine, and the "performance" difference between 18's and 17's is splitting hairs, but you asked.
As I and Turbogarrett said, more sidewall helps with traction and is more forgiving if you hit some bumps, in both ride quality and chances of bending a rim.
#13
Shark Stalker
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: BC Canada
Posts: 374
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
17's all the way...18's are just more for a show type deal. the tires are ALOT more expensive for 18 inch wheels as well. i think 16's are a bit too "small looking" for the fd...perfect for the fc tho
#14
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by jarred
17's all the way...18's are just more for a show type deal. the tires are ALOT more expensive for 18 inch wheels as well. i think 16's are a bit too "small looking" for the fd...perfect for the fc tho
Plenty of options for clearance available in 17in tires.
Most of you guys sound like you are just repeating what you've heard -- any of you guys have direct A to B experience in straightline traction between 17s and 18s?
I'm not arguing that shorter sidewall tires have as much straightline grip as taller profiles -- what I AM saying is that for a street driven FD with good tires, it won't really matter. Like I said, if he is really making THAT much power and wants to run good times at the drag strip, he shouldn't be wasting time running street tires, he should be bolting on a set of stock wheels with M/T Streets or BFG drag radials.
One last point -- I noticed NO difference in ride quality that was attributable to the tires when I went from 16 to 18" wheels.
im still saying go for 16's
#15
Originally Posted by rynberg
I'm not arguing that shorter sidewall tires have as much straightline grip as taller profiles -- what I AM saying is that for a street driven FD with good tires, it won't really matter. Like I said, if he is really making THAT much power and wants to run good times at the drag strip, he shouldn't be wasting time running street tires, he should be bolting on a set of stock wheels with M/T Streets or BFG drag radials.
Originally Posted by rynberg
One last point -- I noticed NO difference in ride quality that was attributable to the tires when I went from 16 to 18" wheels.
#16
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by Hellspawn
That is obviously true, however there are MANY people that are not track/strip rats that only go occasionally and don't want to go to that trouble.
Originally Posted by Hellspawn
I would have to say that you are in the minority or that you just liked your new wheels so much that you are in denial of the ride stiffness change. or perhaps you are just not very sensitive to ride stiffness. I have made the same switch on several cars, and know many, many other people who have and all have said the ride is stiffer. Of course this varies from individual to individual.
That said, I am running slightly tall 18" profiles -- 235/40 and 265/35, vs a 245/35 or 285/30. It's possible those shorter profile tires would be noticeably harsher.
Think about your experiences -- perhaps most of the swaps to 18s involved performance tires vs the stock 15-16 touring/all-season tires on the cars in question? Tire model plays a big role.
#18
Rotary Enthusiast
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Daytona Beach FL
Posts: 836
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
dude,i used to have 17 inch rpo1s on my last fd,now i am running 18 inch HP DESIGN EVOS on my new(10,000 orig miles) fd.I am running toyo 235x40x18 on front and 265x35x18 on rear.The car rides smoother and handles much better than the stock 16inch wheels and tires.The bling bling factor is 1000% more now,go with 18s.
#22
Lives on the Forum
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: San Lorenzo, California
Posts: 14,716
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Originally Posted by Hellspawn
difference of opinion is not necessarily an argument
My opinion is based on personal experience as well as that of several other long term owners who regularly track their cars. I'm not sure what your opinion is based on....
#23
Personal experience on the track with several other cars with both 17's and 18's as well as the experience of many, many, many other people with years and years of track experience who have run 17's and 18's on cars such as M3's, NSX's, vettes, as well as FD rx-7's .
#24
Rotary Freak
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: nyc+li, ny
Posts: 2,690
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hellspawn, you come off as if you too overly impressed with your "experience" to listen to someone who has been there done that. while rynberg is talking in generalities about well known experiences on FDs you seem to be taking personal shots at his comments.
the only thing i disagree with in rynberg's comment is sidewall size contributing to ride quality on 16" and 17 or 18" wheels at least around NY/NJ. I notice the difference on NY/NJ roads with my 2 FDs running 16s vs 17s. other than that, my experience is along the lines of what rynberg expressed.
cheers.
the only thing i disagree with in rynberg's comment is sidewall size contributing to ride quality on 16" and 17 or 18" wheels at least around NY/NJ. I notice the difference on NY/NJ roads with my 2 FDs running 16s vs 17s. other than that, my experience is along the lines of what rynberg expressed.
cheers.