Cost/Benefit seal comparison
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: York, PA
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cost/Benefit seal comparison
OK, so it's about that time when in a few weeks I can buy a rebuild kit, so to give you some back ground I have an S5 NA block which will be Peripheral Ported and resurfaced by Goopy's, I will also have the rotors lightened and clearanced so my question is more of a cost/benefit comparison between:
1. RB carbon apex seals/ Atkins Apex seals/ Cryo. Atkins Apex Seals/ OEM Apex Seals
2. Atkins Cryo. Side Seals/ OEM side Seals
3. Atkins Solid Corner Seals/ Atkins Cryo. Solid Corner Seals/ OEM FD Corner Seals
4. Viton Oil Control Rings/ OEM Oil Control Rings
5. Viton Water Jacket Seals/ OEM Water Jacket Seals
and since it is now 3 AM and I don't feel like spending the next few hours searching the forum, please no " that's what the search button is for" comments
1. RB carbon apex seals/ Atkins Apex seals/ Cryo. Atkins Apex Seals/ OEM Apex Seals
2. Atkins Cryo. Side Seals/ OEM side Seals
3. Atkins Solid Corner Seals/ Atkins Cryo. Solid Corner Seals/ OEM FD Corner Seals
4. Viton Oil Control Rings/ OEM Oil Control Rings
5. Viton Water Jacket Seals/ OEM Water Jacket Seals
and since it is now 3 AM and I don't feel like spending the next few hours searching the forum, please no " that's what the search button is for" comments
#2
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Denver
Posts: 697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why not just use the Goopy seals?
I would not use carbon seals in a street motor unless you plan on replacing them often. Atkins seals are fine but I no longer use them myself.
I think the "new" Atkins corner seals are better than the old ones, but the Goopy ones are working for me. Forget Cryo, Casidium coating is where its at.
I use the black O-rings I get from Goopy almost exclusively now.
I would not use carbon seals in a street motor unless you plan on replacing them often. Atkins seals are fine but I no longer use them myself.
I think the "new" Atkins corner seals are better than the old ones, but the Goopy ones are working for me. Forget Cryo, Casidium coating is where its at.
I use the black O-rings I get from Goopy almost exclusively now.