I've always loved the simplicity of a nicely designed 5 poke wheel that never ages IMHO. (The old BMW 5 series split spoke wheel comes to mind as well). I go back and forth on switching to my other set of new aftermarket wheels I have but never in a hurry to slap them on.
Finding 16" tire selections is not an easy take but thankfully a good brand or 2 exits in plus sizing. I'm currently on a set of Toyo T1R's 245/45 that I purchased 2.5 yrs ago.