Batteries - Which one? Optima Red Top?
#1
Batteries - Which one? Optima Red Top?
Well, it looks like I am going to need a new battery - but which one.
While I've heard that the quality isn't as good as it used to be, I've been told that Optima Red Tops are still the best bet when price is a consideration, but which Red Top?
Here are the different models of Red Top - basically there are two sizes (Big and Small) and each size comes with either 2 or 4 terminals. I'd imagine that the small one would be listed as "OEM size", but is the big one too big? Which ones do you guys use?
<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD><TABLE borderColor=#000000 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=1><TBODY><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="100%" colSpan=6 height=13>STARTING BATTERIES</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>MODEL NUMBER</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>34 & 34R</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>75/25</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>34/78</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>25 & 35</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6V</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>PERFORMANCE</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Voltage</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>12V</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6v</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Cold Cranking Amps @ 0F</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>800</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>720</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>800</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>720</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>800</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Cranking Amps @ 32F</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>1000</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>910</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>1000</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>910</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>1000</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Reserve Capacity</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>110</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>90</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>110</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>90</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>110</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Capacity (C/20 Rate)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>50</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>44</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>50</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>44</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>50</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Internal Resistance (ohms)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0019</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>PHYSICAL SPECS</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Length</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>10"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>9 5/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>10"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>9 5/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>10"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Width</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6 7/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>6 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>6 7/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>3 9/16"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Height</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>7 5/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 5/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Mimimum Weight (lbs)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>37.9</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>33.1</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>38.8</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>31.7</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>18.4</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Type Post/Terminal</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>Dual SAE & GM</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>Dual SAE & GM</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>BCI Group</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>34 & 34R</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>75/35</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>34/78</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>25 & 35</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>N/A</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE></TD></TR><TR><TD colSpan=2 height=8>
So, for all you guys that have Red Tops, Which one do you have? The big one or the small one?
Thanks!
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
While I've heard that the quality isn't as good as it used to be, I've been told that Optima Red Tops are still the best bet when price is a consideration, but which Red Top?
Here are the different models of Red Top - basically there are two sizes (Big and Small) and each size comes with either 2 or 4 terminals. I'd imagine that the small one would be listed as "OEM size", but is the big one too big? Which ones do you guys use?
<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD><TABLE borderColor=#000000 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=1><TBODY><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="100%" colSpan=6 height=13>STARTING BATTERIES</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>MODEL NUMBER</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>34 & 34R</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>75/25</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>34/78</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>25 & 35</TD><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6V</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>PERFORMANCE</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Voltage</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>12V</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>12v</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6v</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Cold Cranking Amps @ 0F</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>800</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>720</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>800</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>720</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>800</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Cranking Amps @ 32F</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>1000</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>910</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>1000</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>910</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>1000</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Reserve Capacity</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>110</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>90</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>110</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>90</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>110</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Capacity (C/20 Rate)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>50</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>44</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>50</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>44</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>50</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Internal Resistance (ohms)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0030</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>.0019</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText style="FONT-WEIGHT: bold" vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>PHYSICAL SPECS</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13></TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Length</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>10"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>9 5/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>10"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>9 5/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>10"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Width</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6 7/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>6 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>6 7/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>6 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>3 9/16"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Height</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>7 5/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 5/8"</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>7 13/16"</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Mimimum Weight (lbs)</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>37.9</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>33.1</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>38.8</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>31.7</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>18.4</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>Type Post/Terminal</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>Dual SAE & GM</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>Dual SAE & GM</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>SAE Post</TD></TR><TR><TD class=tableText vAlign=center width="28%" height=13>BCI Group</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>34 & 34R</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="18%" height=13>75/35</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="17%" height=13>34/78</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>25 & 35</TD><TD class=tableText vAlign=center align=middle width="12%" height=13>N/A</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE></TD></TR><TR><TD colSpan=2 height=8>
So, for all you guys that have Red Tops, Which one do you have? The big one or the small one?
Thanks!
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
#3
Originally Posted by Nismo Convert86
I don't have a Optima, but I do have the spiral wound one from Crappy T, I think i paid 130 for it, never left me stranded.
#5
Rotoholic Moderookie
iTrader: (4)
Wow, with prices like that, how can you not opt for the Red Top?
Mine is a C-Tire battery, and so is my friend Joel's. The CT in Aylmer is good at replacing it. Joel left his on cement out in the snow over the winter and it split at the sides. He brought it in, they put it on the tester and said "Yeah, you've got a month left in your warranty and it wont' charge, so here's your new one, along with 3 more years of warranty".
So that's why I don't mind having a bargain bin $99 CT battery.... but crap man, if you have the choice of getting a Red Top, I can't help with which one to choose, but go for it!
Jon
Mine is a C-Tire battery, and so is my friend Joel's. The CT in Aylmer is good at replacing it. Joel left his on cement out in the snow over the winter and it split at the sides. He brought it in, they put it on the tester and said "Yeah, you've got a month left in your warranty and it wont' charge, so here's your new one, along with 3 more years of warranty".
So that's why I don't mind having a bargain bin $99 CT battery.... but crap man, if you have the choice of getting a Red Top, I can't help with which one to choose, but go for it!
Jon
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Calgary, A.B.
Posts: 407
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Nick86
I wont buy a CT battery just on principal. They were such a pain in the *** to deal with when I got a faulty battery from them that I wont buy another. Besides, the Federal Battery near my place is selling the Red Tops for $127.08.
J
#7
Originally Posted by 86J
Dont even bother buying a Diehard. they will NOT warranty the battey no matter what happens. they will make up something stupid like your cars to old so we cant warranty it. I had a bad experience with a 12 month old bettery from them. They threw me out of the store b/c i was telling them that their warranty was a joke wver since cal tire bought out sears. I felt like throwing the thing through their front window.
J
J
That said, anyone with a Red Top - which one do you have?
Trending Topics
#8
Banned. I got OWNED!!!
iTrader: (2)
i've got a red top in my 84 rx-7 pretty strong and no problems yet ... i've had it for a few months now ... I can't remember which one it is exactly ... its one of the 910 cranking amps. Its was bigger than the stock one so right now its ghetto strapped in there with cables until i can get time to custom fab one. Going to college, and work alot doesn't leave you much time to do things.
#9
Engine, Not Motor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: London, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 29,789
Likes: 0
Received 108 Likes
on
91 Posts
I think the quality problems with Optima are about over. Many of the EV'ers are switching back after a few years of getting poor results. My very own Red Top lasted only a year under moderate abuse and for what I paid for it (and the poor service from the Optima warranty people) I'll never buy another one...But I think it's generally safe to do so at this point.
My personal recommendation is Deka. Since I have been dealing with Deka I've never had a bad battery in a vehicle (I have a Deka PowerSports in my Insight, and will be putting an Intimidator in the RX-7) nor in the MANY UPS battery replacements I have done.
As far the terminals, all you really need are top posts but I think most Optima (as well as the higher end Deka) models come with both. Group 34 is the common size.
My personal recommendation is Deka. Since I have been dealing with Deka I've never had a bad battery in a vehicle (I have a Deka PowerSports in my Insight, and will be putting an Intimidator in the RX-7) nor in the MANY UPS battery replacements I have done.
As far the terminals, all you really need are top posts but I think most Optima (as well as the higher end Deka) models come with both. Group 34 is the common size.
#10
Coming to a track near u!
iTrader: (5)
I have a blue top that I bought for the racecar but then I was hit by lightning and thought better of putting a 30+ lb. battery in a track car so it's going in the SVT.
Odyssey are sweet: http://www.odysseybatteries.com/specs.htm
When it rains money use: http://www.rockracingbattery.com/
Pricing (example) on Rock's (once known as Reactor): http://performanceunlimited.com/cobr...n/battery.html
Odyssey are sweet: http://www.odysseybatteries.com/specs.htm
When it rains money use: http://www.rockracingbattery.com/
Pricing (example) on Rock's (once known as Reactor): http://performanceunlimited.com/cobr...n/battery.html
#12
Rotary Freak
iTrader: (1)
If cold starting isn't really an issue (and I don't think it is in Vanc, even if you drive the car year round there), I'd go for the lightest - either the 25-35 or 75-25. Battery weight is ugly weight, up near the nose of the car, where it has the biggest impact on polar moment of momentum (assuming the battery's in the stock location).
#13
Certified Old Fart
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Inkerman, On, South of Ottawa, the 2nd coldest Capital in the World
Posts: 490
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Nick86
Besides, the Federal Battery near my place is selling the Red Tops for $127.08.
I need a new one too so am interested to see the results of this thread.
I always just put in the most cranking amps that will fit in any car I own. Yes you're carrying a little more weight, but I'd rather have the insurance if the car is hard to start some time. Its paid off for me more than once.
Nick: on another subject - there is a GB being offerred on a really fancy alarm system (remembering your past troubles in Vancouver...)
Rob
Originally Posted by Nick86
I wont buy a CT battery just on principal. They were such a pain in the *** to deal with when I got a faulty battery from them that I wont buy another.
Last edited by Whanrow; 02-08-06 at 08:46 PM.
#14
Originally Posted by Whanrow
Holy crap what a price. Doesn't CT quote their spiral battery starting at $199?
I need a new one too so am interested to see the results of this thread.
Rob
I need a new one too so am interested to see the results of this thread.
Rob
Originally Posted by Whanrow
Nick: on another subject - there is a GB being offerred on a really fancy alarm system (remembering your past troubles in Vancouver...)
Rob
Rob
I got my old alarm working properly again, and have avoided underground lots etc. For now it has worked (knock on wood), but with things like the battery cropping up, my current alarm may just have to do for now!
#15
Rotary Freak
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by Whanrow
Holy crap what a price. Doesn't CT quote their spiral battery starting at $199?
I need a new one too so am interested to see the results of this thread.
I always just put in the most cranking amps that will fit in any car I own. Yes you're carrying a little more weight, but I'd rather have the insurance if the car is hard to start some time. Its paid off for me more than once.
Nick: on another subject - there is a GB being offerred on a really fancy alarm system (remembering your past troubles in Vancouver...)
Rob
I need a new one too so am interested to see the results of this thread.
I always just put in the most cranking amps that will fit in any car I own. Yes you're carrying a little more weight, but I'd rather have the insurance if the car is hard to start some time. Its paid off for me more than once.
Nick: on another subject - there is a GB being offerred on a really fancy alarm system (remembering your past troubles in Vancouver...)
Rob
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post