want to get silicon hose job done on the motor but was told not to do it because...
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Langley
Posts: 371
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
want to get silicon hose job done on the motor but was told not to do it because...
hey guys i am debating weather to spend my 500 dollars on either getting all my vacuum hoses changed to silicon or lowering the car. I have 55,000k miles on my second engine now and according to the mechanic he says that i shouldnt do the full silicone hose job yet but to wait when i need a rebuild because it be worth while doing because the engine will be apart anyway, now i was wondering why i would have to wait for a rebuilt do get this kind of work done, i mean whats the difference if i get the silicon hose job done now or if i am getting the motor rebuilt? i mean if i get it done now those hoses wont be touched when a rebuild needs to be done because all that gets touched are the rotors, so you think he has a good point and wait if i need a rebuilt which i say wont ever be needed atleast till 200,000 k the way i look after it or should i spend the 500 dollars and get it done? the other option i have is to get the car lowered, what you guys think? i need your guys help here to get me to decide, what should i do!
#2
canadian monster
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Trois-Rivières, Qc, Can
Posts: 2,083
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
500? why don't you do it yourself? it is an excellent way of learning how your car works.
otherwise, don,t do it until you get boost problem i guess.
i personnally do everything on my car so it is far from costing me 500 so i guess my point of view is kind of useless...
otherwise, don,t do it until you get boost problem i guess.
i personnally do everything on my car so it is far from costing me 500 so i guess my point of view is kind of useless...
#4
Moderator
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: https://www2.mazda.com/en/100th/
Posts: 30,827
Received 2,595 Likes
on
1,843 Posts
you should leave it alone unless you need to fix it. dont lower the car either
mike
mike
#5
Blow up or win
Originally posted by puma
500? why don't you do it yourself? it is an excellent way of learning how your car works.
otherwise, don,t do it until you get boost problem i guess.
i personnally do everything on my car so it is far from costing me 500 so i guess my point of view is kind of useless...
500? why don't you do it yourself? it is an excellent way of learning how your car works.
otherwise, don,t do it until you get boost problem i guess.
i personnally do everything on my car so it is far from costing me 500 so i guess my point of view is kind of useless...
#7
If you are having no trouble with the sequential operation of the turbos, don't do it. You will save money by not doing it.
When you rebuild the engine, the hoses have to disconnected. This is a very good time to do the hose replacement.
Your mechanic's advice is a good one.
When you rebuild the engine, the hoses have to disconnected. This is a very good time to do the hose replacement.
Your mechanic's advice is a good one.
Trending Topics
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 625
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
agreed... no reason to fix those unless there's a problem. It'd be like replacing your tires with the same type of tires before they needed to be replaced - there's no advantage to doing it whatsoever.
get yourself some nice lowering springs & a boost gauge (if you don't already have one).
edit: ...and the reason he says it would be better to wait for a rebuild is that the engine is apart and out of the car - easier to get to all of the hoses (UIM is off, turbos aren't right next to the fender, plumbing removed for the most part, etc)
get yourself some nice lowering springs & a boost gauge (if you don't already have one).
edit: ...and the reason he says it would be better to wait for a rebuild is that the engine is apart and out of the car - easier to get to all of the hoses (UIM is off, turbos aren't right next to the fender, plumbing removed for the most part, etc)
Last edited by BrianK; 01-09-03 at 08:50 PM.
#9
Recovering Milkaholic
iTrader: (7)
no no no,
Do the job and do it now.
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
You can get it through www.hosetechniques.com
The job is not hard. check www.iluvmyrx7.com and download a workshop manual.
Then check robinettes site and lightning and a world of thunder.
Both have detailed instructions on how to do the job.
It's about a 5 hour job for the fist time.
Fairly simple as long as you pay attention and take your time.
PM if you need you decide to do it yourself.
BTW your engine won't live to 200k.
Do the job and do it now.
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
You can get it through www.hosetechniques.com
The job is not hard. check www.iluvmyrx7.com and download a workshop manual.
Then check robinettes site and lightning and a world of thunder.
Both have detailed instructions on how to do the job.
It's about a 5 hour job for the fist time.
Fairly simple as long as you pay attention and take your time.
PM if you need you decide to do it yourself.
BTW your engine won't live to 200k.
#10
Full Member
iTrader: (1)
Agree with BrianK but I don't think silicon is better than rubber. Silicon breaks apart after it breaks down from heat cycling. Use a good rubber or Viton is best but if it isn't broke now don't fix it. You could end up doing the job. putting it all back together and find out you screwed up and have to take the upper intake off again to fix it. Best to wait until you have to do it or engine is out.
#11
Blow up or win
Originally posted by Fd3BOOST
no no no,
Do the job and do it now.
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
You can get it through www.hosetechniques.com
The job is not hard. check www.iluvmyrx7.com and download a workshop manual.
Then check robinettes site and lightning and a world of thunder.
Both have detailed instructions on how to do the job.
It's about a 5 hour job for the fist time.
Fairly simple as long as you pay attention and take your time.
PM if you need you decide to do it yourself.
BTW your engine won't live to 200k.
no no no,
Do the job and do it now.
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
You can get it through www.hosetechniques.com
The job is not hard. check www.iluvmyrx7.com and download a workshop manual.
Then check robinettes site and lightning and a world of thunder.
Both have detailed instructions on how to do the job.
It's about a 5 hour job for the fist time.
Fairly simple as long as you pay attention and take your time.
PM if you need you decide to do it yourself.
BTW your engine won't live to 200k.
Don't worry, be happy. DIY damnit!!! It's not rocket science and you will have a MAJOR warm fuzzy feeling after you've done it.......OR.........you will curse the day you ever bought your FD3S.
BE A MAN.
(I must be a wussy though, it took me a WEEK, but then again it required a 6 pack every night!)
#12
Originally posted by Fd3BOOST
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
The hose will run you about $30 or so.
#13
Blow up or win
Originally posted by RX7 8U
Agree with BrianK but I don't think silicon is better than rubber. Silicon breaks apart after it breaks down from heat cycling. Use a good rubber or Viton is best but if it isn't broke now don't fix it. You could end up doing the job. putting it all back together and find out you screwed up and have to take the upper intake off again to fix it. Best to wait until you have to do it or engine is out.
Agree with BrianK but I don't think silicon is better than rubber. Silicon breaks apart after it breaks down from heat cycling. Use a good rubber or Viton is best but if it isn't broke now don't fix it. You could end up doing the job. putting it all back together and find out you screwed up and have to take the upper intake off again to fix it. Best to wait until you have to do it or engine is out.
ESPECIALLY on the silcone advice!
#16
Blow up or win
Originally posted by Mr. Stock
From the data I have reviewed:
Viton better than silicone which is better than rubber
From the data I have reviewed:
Viton better than silicone which is better than rubber
But 4X the cost? Not for me. Good quality silicone will last 10 years easily - and not the JUNK from Hose Techniques. Garbage with a capital "G".
Viton is awesome and absolutely the best, but total overkill for a car, - ANY car.
Buna N - "nitrile" is pretty good to begin with, but it cannot handle the heat, and that's where all the problems began...if it wasn't for that damn pre-cat.
If you stay clear of direct oil contact silicone is still the best choice.
#17
Blow up or win
Originally posted by RX7 8U
yeah no b.s. viton is better and thats why it costs a lot more too. get off your trike and do your homework ronkmiller.
yeah no b.s. viton is better and thats why it costs a lot more too. get off your trike and do your homework ronkmiller.
(Wanna race?)
I've done my homework. That's why I am trying to help you out. About 25 years ago.
I Graduated Summa *** ******* Fast.
I realize it's difficult to to more superior knowledge, but if you don't believe me I can show you the way - and it is righteous, my friend:
www.McMasterCarr.com. Start reading. You'll be amazed.... a great place to buy all kinds of **** you've never heard about!
.
#18
Full Member
iTrader: (1)
Gee I struck a nerve. yeah I've bought plenty from McMasterCarr from their big thick yellow catalog before websites even existed. Amazing how you judge people by reading a few words.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Go ahead make my day...throw in another cheap shot. You won't get a reply from me.
EDIT: Just a warning, keep it technical. If you want flame, take it to PM's. _Mahjik
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Go ahead make my day...throw in another cheap shot. You won't get a reply from me.
EDIT: Just a warning, keep it technical. If you want flame, take it to PM's. _Mahjik
Last edited by Mahjik; 01-09-03 at 11:32 PM.
#19
All out Track Freak!
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 412 Likes
on
250 Posts
Originally posted by RX7 8U
Agree with BrianK but I don't think silicon is better than rubber. Silicon breaks apart after it breaks down from heat cycling. Use a good rubber or Viton is best but if it isn't broke now don't fix it. You could end up doing the job. putting it all back together and find out you screwed up and have to take the upper intake off again to fix it. Best to wait until you have to do it or engine is out.
Agree with BrianK but I don't think silicon is better than rubber. Silicon breaks apart after it breaks down from heat cycling. Use a good rubber or Viton is best but if it isn't broke now don't fix it. You could end up doing the job. putting it all back together and find out you screwed up and have to take the upper intake off again to fix it. Best to wait until you have to do it or engine is out.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: California
Posts: 373
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by RonKMiller
....and not the JUNK from Hose Techniques. Garbage with a capital "G".
....and not the JUNK from Hose Techniques. Garbage with a capital "G".
I did my vacuum hoses (and my whole car for that matter) myself and I had purchased 3 products:
- Viton from McMaster Carr
The Viton is by far the most resistant to cutting. It's even HARD to cut it with a razor blade!! But it crinks WAY too easy when you have to make a curve. - silicone hose from Neo Oil/Baker Precision
The Neo/Baker hose also crinked (but not as easily) when you have to make a curve or bend because the wall thickness is actually too thick. - silicone hose from HoseTechniques
The Hose Techniques hose was the best all around. Perfect-thickness hose wall keeps it from crinking even when making tight turns. The stuff worked great!!!
So I'm really curious why you would call it garbage when I had all 3 choices side by side and HoseTechniques was clearly the winner.
-Tom
Last edited by TomsRX7; 01-09-03 at 10:56 PM.
#21
Blow up or win
Originally posted by RX7 8U
Gee I struck a nerve. yeah I've bought plenty from McMasterCarr from their big thick yellow catalog before websites even existed. Amazing how you judge people by reading a few words.
-------------------------------- (Removed the crap -Mahjik)
Go ahead make my day...throw in another cheap shot. You won't get a reply from me.
Gee I struck a nerve. yeah I've bought plenty from McMasterCarr from their big thick yellow catalog before websites even existed. Amazing how you judge people by reading a few words.
-------------------------------- (Removed the crap -Mahjik)
Go ahead make my day...throw in another cheap shot. You won't get a reply from me.
You are obviously smarter than me.
Really, it's OK if you don't know what you are talking about. It just takes time to grow up and admit that you are wrong:
Buna N: -40 to 212 F
Viton: -15 to 400 F
Silicone:-80 to 450 F
Even though silicone is superior in regard to temperature over Viton, if I was building the Space Shuttle I would probably choose Viton due to the fact that it is more chemically inert. But for my car - I would sure put the money I saved into other things that make it go faster. But wtf, that would be stupid according to you - huh, Chisel Chest?
So, beside your obvious inability to express yourself without lowering yourself to common ghetto slang - ******* (oh, that was a mistake, I lowered myself to your level, I aplogize profusely) - do you have any additional PROOF to back up your claims?
Lead, follow, or get out of the way.
Last edited by Mahjik; 01-09-03 at 11:34 PM.
#22
Blow up or win
Originally posted by TomsRX7
I think you may need to continue your research . Can you give some facts and/or personal experience why the HoseTechniques is garbage???
I did my vacuum hoses (and my whole car for that matter) myself and I had purchased 3 products:
So I'm really curious why you would call it garbage when I had all 3 choices side by side and HoseTechniques was clearly the winner.
-Tom
I think you may need to continue your research . Can you give some facts and/or personal experience why the HoseTechniques is garbage???
I did my vacuum hoses (and my whole car for that matter) myself and I had purchased 3 products:
- Viton from McMaster Carr
The Viton is by far the most resistant to cutting. It's even HARD to cut it with a razor blade!! But it crinks WAY too easy when you have to make a curve. - silicone hose from Neo Oil/Baker Precision
The Neo/Baker hose also crinked (but not as easily) when you have to make a curve or bend because the wall thickness is actually too thick. - silicone hose from HoseTechniques
The Hose Techniques hose was the best all around. Perfect-thickness hose wall keeps it from crinking even when making tight turns. The stuff worked great!!!
So I'm really curious why you would call it garbage when I had all 3 choices side by side and HoseTechniques was clearly the winner.
-Tom
1. It is a major ripoff in regards to price, even if you
buy it by the foot like I did.
2. It you try to follow the original OEM bends it will
kink every time - I needed to insert #1 springs
inside the hose to keep it from failing on tight
curves.
I agree completly with your finding on Viton. Even though it is a pain in the *** to work with, there is no question it is the best stuff out there, but it is WAY overkill for cars, even our hot little bastards.
The ONLY SILICONE HOSE that is mil-spec (that means it has been tested and approved for use in aircraft) that I have found is DuroBlu Si. Having worked on jets, turbines, piston engines, motorcycle engines and yes, rotaries,I can say that it is the ONLY hose I would use and forget about it.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: California
Posts: 373
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by RonKMiller
....
1. It is a major ripoff in regards to price, even if you
buy it by the foot like I did.
2. It you try to follow the original OEM bends it will
kink every time - I needed to insert #1 springs
inside the hose to keep it from failing on tight
curves.
I agree completly with your finding on Viton. Even though it is a pain in the *** to work with, there is no question it is the best stuff out there, but it is WAY overkill for cars, even our hot little bastards.
The ONLY SILICONE HOSE that is mil-spec (that means it has been tested and approved for use in aircraft) that I have found is DuroBlu Si. Having worked on jets, turbines, piston engines, motorcycle engines and yes, rotaries,I can say that it is the ONLY hose I would use and forget about it.
....
1. It is a major ripoff in regards to price, even if you
buy it by the foot like I did.
2. It you try to follow the original OEM bends it will
kink every time - I needed to insert #1 springs
inside the hose to keep it from failing on tight
curves.
I agree completly with your finding on Viton. Even though it is a pain in the *** to work with, there is no question it is the best stuff out there, but it is WAY overkill for cars, even our hot little bastards.
The ONLY SILICONE HOSE that is mil-spec (that means it has been tested and approved for use in aircraft) that I have found is DuroBlu Si. Having worked on jets, turbines, piston engines, motorcycle engines and yes, rotaries,I can say that it is the ONLY hose I would use and forget about it.
As for the DuroBlu Si that you are talking about, is that what you finally used? And, honestly, did it kink when making tight curves? Can you provide a site where it can be purchased? Kinking is my main concern for these hoses cuz no matter which you choose, they will ALL last 10 years or more.
-Tom
Last edited by TomsRX7; 01-09-03 at 11:25 PM.