No fan shroud, or bigger problem?
No fan shroud, or bigger problem?
I was tuning my 'new' engine tonight and after (mostly high) idling for at least 30 minutes, it started overheating. I shut it down just as the temp guage was starting to climb.
I haven't re-installed the fan shroud yet and I'm **REALLY** hoping that's the reason. I've called it a night, and I'll install the shroud tomorrow, but if anybody knows if a missing fan shroud can cause this, please let me know!
I haven't re-installed the fan shroud yet and I'm **REALLY** hoping that's the reason. I've called it a night, and I'll install the shroud tomorrow, but if anybody knows if a missing fan shroud can cause this, please let me know!
What? Put that shroud on now! The fan does absolutly nothing without it. The only way the motor gets cooling at idle is the fan and you took that away. I realy hope you did not smoke your motor.
I had to get rid of my fan shroud due to the fact that the fan kept eating the shroud. There's still melted fan shroud plastic stuck to the fan. Never had a problem with overheating, and the other 2 owners that had it after me never had a problem with it before I bought it back.
^ hey man your just down the road from me a lil ways got allot of friends in Navarre. Oh yea if the hurricane don’t hit us this SAT there will be about 200 of us meeting at the pcola pear as we do every now and then. Races will be deep up in Navarre if you don’t know.
Dood you got allot more issues then the shroud. You really need to get them fixed. As well if you don’t idle and sit you wont notice any issues. The fan is not used above 40mph. As well the S5 temp gauge is not linier and is very pore to judge off of. If it moves up to HOT this means hey you blew your motor I thought I would let you know.
Dood you got allot more issues then the shroud. You really need to get them fixed. As well if you don’t idle and sit you wont notice any issues. The fan is not used above 40mph. As well the S5 temp gauge is not linier and is very pore to judge off of. If it moves up to HOT this means hey you blew your motor I thought I would let you know.
Originally Posted by iceblue
Dood you got allot more issues then the shroud. You really need to get them fixed. As well if you don’t idle and sit you wont notice any issues. The fan is not used above 40mph. .
Just a little FYI.
Trending Topics
Originally Posted by iceblue
^ hey man your just down the road from me a lil ways got allot of friends in Navarre. Oh yea if the hurricane don’t hit us this SAT there will be about 200 of us meeting at the pcola pear as we do every now and then. Races will be deep up in Navarre if you don’t know.
Dood you got allot more issues then the shroud. You really need to get them fixed. As well if you don’t idle and sit you wont notice any issues. The fan is not used above 40mph. As well the S5 temp gauge is not linier and is very pore to judge off of. If it moves up to HOT this means hey you blew your motor I thought I would let you know.
Dood you got allot more issues then the shroud. You really need to get them fixed. As well if you don’t idle and sit you wont notice any issues. The fan is not used above 40mph. As well the S5 temp gauge is not linier and is very pore to judge off of. If it moves up to HOT this means hey you blew your motor I thought I would let you know.
^ Your talking about bayfront, right? I used to go there. You might know my car if you've been going there for a while, it was White w/ blue racing stripes and spoiler, rims. All that good stuff.
Originally Posted by J-Rat
Actually, the clutch fan is thermostatically controlled, so it doesnt differentiate from road speed..
Just a little FYI.
Just a little FYI.
It has just been debated that around / 40 mph that there is enugh flow to free spin the fan and cool from air to air passing.
Thanks for the adidtion.
Yup blue I was talking about bayfront. I dont recall your car maybe I seen it. I am the one there in the green RX-8. Anyways hope you get your REX on the road soon.
Running without a shroud is one thing, but sitting still is - hopefully - another. I definitely do recall that the fan was never really spinning at full tilt...even as the coolant started boiling. I'm hoping that this is because there wasn't enough hot air flowing to the fan's clutch to kick it in.
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 29,798
Likes: 128
From: London, Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted by dsmrx7
It should'nt be the shroud. I'm running mine without the shroud and it never overheated...
Either way, it's very irresponsible to make others think they can just rip it off and be OK.That said, it's nice to see yet another fan shroud topic. As if the existing 5,001 of them was not enough.
Oops...5,002 it'll have to be, I'm afraid 
This I did search for this, but maybe not hard enough....What's the proper procedure for bleeding air out of the cooling system?
I guess it's been a long time since high school auto shop!

This I did search for this, but maybe not hard enough....What's the proper procedure for bleeding air out of the cooling system?
I guess it's been a long time since high school auto shop!
Last edited by johnnyg; Aug 26, 2005 at 02:41 PM.
Well, I alpologize if I'm mis-informing people, I'm just going off of my own experiences, and to date have never had a problem, and I know my temp gauge works, and then again, it may be due to the fact I rarely let the car sit. It's usually above 60mph at anygivien time when being driven.
If you don't believe that removing the shroud doesn't significantly reduce the fan's capacity, you're delusional. You should only have to look it it to understand that. Most of the air the fan is moving is drawn from within the engine bay instead of through the radiator. Airflow through the radiator will be significantly reduced, so the fan will have to work much harder to keep the car cool. This means the clutch spends more time engaged. Under prolonged low-speed conditions (idling, in traffic, etc), temps will eventually rise.
EDIT: That was a general comment, not aimed just at BlueS5.
EDIT: That was a general comment, not aimed just at BlueS5.
Last edited by NZConvertible; Aug 27, 2005 at 12:57 AM.
If you want to shell out for a new one, see Mazda. Otherwise look at the For Sale section or list in the Wanted section. People who've swapped to e-fans successfully won't need them anymore.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Jeff20B
1st Generation Specific (1979-1985)
73
Sep 16, 2018 07:16 PM
msilvia
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
15
Sep 11, 2015 12:13 PM




