bad apex seal, cheapest temp solution?
#1
bad apex seal, cheapest temp solution?
basicly i have a 86 sport with high miles with a bad alex seal in the rear rotor, wont really idle below 1500 and runs really rough, sounds like the rear rotar is missing every time.
i dont have enuf money to rebuild this engine or get a diff 1, but i have LOTS of time on my hands,
im pulling the motor anyway now, i was wondering if i could pull the rear housing off, and replace the 1 bad apex seal( 60 dollars), IF the other ones werent toasted too, and it didnt damage anything else either. then put the rear housing back on.
my question is would the engine run if i did this, given nothing else was damaged,it doesnt have to run real good, or go real fast, it just have to be driveable, it doesnt even have to last more then a month or 2.
who thinks this might work, and if u dont think it will work explain why please.
i dont have enuf money to rebuild this engine or get a diff 1, but i have LOTS of time on my hands,
im pulling the motor anyway now, i was wondering if i could pull the rear housing off, and replace the 1 bad apex seal( 60 dollars), IF the other ones werent toasted too, and it didnt damage anything else either. then put the rear housing back on.
my question is would the engine run if i did this, given nothing else was damaged,it doesnt have to run real good, or go real fast, it just have to be driveable, it doesnt even have to last more then a month or 2.
who thinks this might work, and if u dont think it will work explain why please.
#2
Need an E6x
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Phoenix, AZ
Posts: 842
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by kompressorlogic
basicly i have a 86 sport with high miles with a bad alex seal in the rear rotor, wont really idle below 1500 and runs really rough, sounds like the rear rotar is missing every time.
i dont have enuf money to rebuild this engine or get a diff 1, but i have LOTS of time on my hands,
im pulling the motor anyway now, i was wondering if i could pull the rear housing off, and replace the 1 bad apex seal( 60 dollars), IF the other ones werent toasted too, and it didnt damage anything else either. then put the rear housing back on.
my question is would the engine run if i did this, given nothing else was damaged,it doesnt have to run real good, or go real fast, it just have to be driveable, it doesnt even have to last more then a month or 2.
who thinks this might work, and if u dont think it will work explain why please.
i dont have enuf money to rebuild this engine or get a diff 1, but i have LOTS of time on my hands,
im pulling the motor anyway now, i was wondering if i could pull the rear housing off, and replace the 1 bad apex seal( 60 dollars), IF the other ones werent toasted too, and it didnt damage anything else either. then put the rear housing back on.
my question is would the engine run if i did this, given nothing else was damaged,it doesnt have to run real good, or go real fast, it just have to be driveable, it doesnt even have to last more then a month or 2.
who thinks this might work, and if u dont think it will work explain why please.
This could happen and could not, myself if you wanted to replace just 1 apex seal you'd also need some new gaskets to seal up your housings because reusing old gaskets is only asking for trouble.
Matt
#4
The rubber gaskets tend to crack and break when you take the engine apart. So, chances are, you're not going to be able to take it apart and reuse them. Also, if you did lose an apex seal, you most likely will have to replace the rotor and housing. Not always, but I doubt they are both still reuseable.
#7
ERTW
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Ottawa, Canada
Posts: 4,328
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
that wasn't even a one-word reply dude, it was a quote with a smiley face, lol
but everyone is pretty much right. the route you want to go is to take care of everything and get a rebuilt engine.
having said that, you could waste your time trying to replace that one seal. you may want to assume that your car won't run after you do this, just so you aren't surprised when that happens...mind if you if your replace any seals that need to be replaced there is the chance it should at least run as good as it did before.
but everyone is pretty much right. the route you want to go is to take care of everything and get a rebuilt engine.
having said that, you could waste your time trying to replace that one seal. you may want to assume that your car won't run after you do this, just so you aren't surprised when that happens...mind if you if your replace any seals that need to be replaced there is the chance it should at least run as good as it did before.
Trending Topics
#8
Lives on the Forum
You guys are missing a major point here- if you've lost a seal, it probably cracked or "rolled out" and also probably performed a little dance inside the rotor housing before it exited stage left (which is the exhaust port). So not only are you concerned with just a $60 apex seal, but also a $500 rotor housing...And at this point, you might as well perform a complete rebuild...
So, best case scenario- the seal is just stuck "down", and can be "revived" by pulling the rear housing, removing the seal & springs, cleaning up the rotor groove (and anything else you could possibly clean up at this point), and reinstalling the seal. Now IF none of the other housing mating surfaces moved (or "cracked open"), you may be able to retorque everything back down and have no leaks, provided you change at least the rear housing combustion & water jacket seals. You have many other items to worry about, too, including the front needle bearings moving on you (so don't break the front bolt, and keep the engine sitting "face down" on that front bolt the entire time)...
If the above scenario is what's happening, try the ATF trick, to "unstick" it...
Myself, I would never try this, but on paper, it is feasible...
So, best case scenario- the seal is just stuck "down", and can be "revived" by pulling the rear housing, removing the seal & springs, cleaning up the rotor groove (and anything else you could possibly clean up at this point), and reinstalling the seal. Now IF none of the other housing mating surfaces moved (or "cracked open"), you may be able to retorque everything back down and have no leaks, provided you change at least the rear housing combustion & water jacket seals. You have many other items to worry about, too, including the front needle bearings moving on you (so don't break the front bolt, and keep the engine sitting "face down" on that front bolt the entire time)...
If the above scenario is what's happening, try the ATF trick, to "unstick" it...
Myself, I would never try this, but on paper, it is feasible...
#11
ok did compression test 90 90 90 front and 95 30 30 rear
so 1 seal is either stuck or messed up, tried water trick and not much of a diff after that, i did notice that it will start when its hot now where as it wouldnt quite get goin enuf to start before.
gonna pull the xhast manifold off and try and see the seals, look and see if 1 is gone, stuck, or maybe had a spring failure.
any other ways to cure a stuck seal?? if thats the case
so 1 seal is either stuck or messed up, tried water trick and not much of a diff after that, i did notice that it will start when its hot now where as it wouldnt quite get goin enuf to start before.
gonna pull the xhast manifold off and try and see the seals, look and see if 1 is gone, stuck, or maybe had a spring failure.
any other ways to cure a stuck seal?? if thats the case
#12
I R SAD PANDA W/O BAW
2 of your seals are damaged. There are 3 sides to each rotor. The readings on the first rotor are 3 consistent readings while the second rotor has 2 readings that are greatly lower than the 3rd.
#14
I R SAD PANDA W/O BAW
Haha actually you are right. I'm trying to forum and do a paper at the same time. Regardless at least one of your seals is damaged and there isnt really a cheap fix for this.
#15
Check out the antifreeze "trick" and have a think about what you can do real cheap. Also if you've got the origional cold start system still on the car. Fill it up with the recommended 90%AF-10%water mix. Rewire the little pump on it with a power source you can control by hand, start the engine up and **** a couple of bottles thru the engine. By the way guys this is also an easier way to do the water "trick" using a 50/50 AF-water mix.
Have fun.
Gerrard
PS: Do this outdoors at night so you don't get the nieghbors all stirred up about the local "smog" you'll be putting out the tailpipe.
Have fun.
Gerrard
PS: Do this outdoors at night so you don't get the nieghbors all stirred up about the local "smog" you'll be putting out the tailpipe.
#17
Rotary Enthusiast
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: California, Bay Area
Posts: 1,165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
no trick is going to get you through this,.. bite the bullet but the basic rebuild kit for 500 bux, pull the motor down and check the damage. If it needs a new housing buy a good used one for 100-200 bux or get a semi low milage motor from pick and pull for ~100 bux.
#18
I live in an igloo
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: calgary alberta
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
drago, its obvious I think by now that those options are not open to this guy. He probably doesn't have the tools, money, or maybe even experience to pull out the motor and do a rebuild. He's looking for a temp solution, and all I can recommend is the atf..
Sadly atf isn't the best way to get rid of gummed up carboned apex seals, but its cheap and its worth a go, what else does he have to lose? either way the engine is gonna die out sooner or later.
Sadly atf isn't the best way to get rid of gummed up carboned apex seals, but its cheap and its worth a go, what else does he have to lose? either way the engine is gonna die out sooner or later.
#20
STUCK. I got SNOWNED!!!!!
iTrader: (7)
Pull the exhaust manifold. Have a look. if one of the apex seals is obviously stuck/cracked/damaged/missing/whatever, then you know.
if it's broken, don't fix it. get another engine. Used good non turbo engines are a dime a dozen. Don't spend more than $500.
if a seal is stuck, try amsoil power foam, brake cleaner, or some other product that munches carbon, and then fire it up after you've got it unstuck, everything should be fine.
30PSI is almost impossibly high compression for a blown seal, I'd suspect either a stuck or cracked seal.
if it's broken, don't fix it. get another engine. Used good non turbo engines are a dime a dozen. Don't spend more than $500.
if a seal is stuck, try amsoil power foam, brake cleaner, or some other product that munches carbon, and then fire it up after you've got it unstuck, everything should be fine.
30PSI is almost impossibly high compression for a blown seal, I'd suspect either a stuck or cracked seal.
#21
Rotary Enthusiast
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: California, Bay Area
Posts: 1,165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
my point is 30 compression is a cracked/ broken seal,.. the atf wont do squat.
http://www.rotaryaviation.com/overhaul_kits.htm
all it doesnt have are side seals, corner seals and oil control rings,.. which are probably all in spec with the possible exception of the oil control rings, they wear a tad faster than the other parts, but still it will run and they have to be majorly worn before they start smoking.
rebuilding isnt that hard if you buy the rebuild vid, and go slow, the whole motor just kinda stacks together.
http://www.rotaryaviation.com/overhaul_kits.htm
all it doesnt have are side seals, corner seals and oil control rings,.. which are probably all in spec with the possible exception of the oil control rings, they wear a tad faster than the other parts, but still it will run and they have to be majorly worn before they start smoking.
rebuilding isnt that hard if you buy the rebuild vid, and go slow, the whole motor just kinda stacks together.
#22
Zero Rotor Motorsports
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Glen Burnie, MD
Posts: 2,525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by drago86
http://www.rotaryaviation.com/overhaul_kits.htm
all it doesnt have are side seals, corner seals and oil control rings
all it doesnt have are side seals, corner seals and oil control rings
I had to pay a restocking fee of over $100 when I sent the rebuild kit back. Overall the whole rebuilding experience that was a big waste of money and left my car in more pieces and my wallet with less money. If I had it to do again, I would get a rebuilt motor that I didn't have to take apart.
#23
well i pulled the xhaust manifold, and all the apex seals are there dont look damaged , i pushed on them and they push back so the springs are still working,
wondeirng if 1 was stuck ran a compression test on it again and seemed to get like 90 in the good chamger then i was getting around 40-45 in the other 2 chambers
wonder if i broke a side seal or corner seal or somethin.... wut u guys think?
wondeirng if 1 was stuck ran a compression test on it again and seemed to get like 90 in the good chamger then i was getting around 40-45 in the other 2 chambers
wonder if i broke a side seal or corner seal or somethin.... wut u guys think?
#24
Lives on the Forum
All of the apex seals had rounded ends? In other words, there wasn't one that seemed to have a sharper edge to it than the others, no?
If you just had a side seal bad, you would only have one low compression chamber. Two side seals, that would be something bordering on amazing...
Corner seal, though, maybe....But you don't hear about them just crapping out too much....
Did you spray the apex seals down with some penetrant or something, just in case?
With the manifold off now, you can do an "auditory" compression test so that you can look more closely at the faces that are "bad" when you hear it...
If you just had a side seal bad, you would only have one low compression chamber. Two side seals, that would be something bordering on amazing...
Corner seal, though, maybe....But you don't hear about them just crapping out too much....
Did you spray the apex seals down with some penetrant or something, just in case?
With the manifold off now, you can do an "auditory" compression test so that you can look more closely at the faces that are "bad" when you hear it...
#25
they all seemed the same to me but ive never seen 1 in an engine before till today lol..... ill try spraying them tommarow,and look more closely at them,
then re test again later, carbon looks kinda sooty black right? looks like theres kinda alot of "carbon"all around by the seals, maybe thats still effecting it.
then re test again later, carbon looks kinda sooty black right? looks like theres kinda alot of "carbon"all around by the seals, maybe thats still effecting it.