Rating Summary #30,731

Purchased an S5 NA rotor from TOOSHORT_88. S5 NA rotor was listed in description as Mint!. Received rotor properly packed. Upon inspection found rotor had multiple areas of pitting across the rotor. Pitting found in oil control ring oring seats and walls. Multiple foreign body gouges found on combustion areas of rotor. Possible denting in combustion pockets when compared to my other S5 NA rotors. Told seller I was not happy and decided I wanted a refund. Was willing to ship rotor back at my expense. Seller said rotor was usable. Part was described as mint not a usable. How usable is up for debate based on how much oil control ring leakage you would be willing to accept. Not to mention the gouging and pitting.