Engine Longevity
What surprises me is that the person who made this thread wanted to know what upgrades to give his vehicle so he could drive it the longest amount of time without having to spend a ton of money on mechanic fees, and its being suggested that he should be
What about the transmission? If you're dropping the clutch from a dig all the time, something's bound to break, which is going against what everything this post was originally posted for... Also, I can see how redlining a few times every time you drive can be good for the rotary in cleaning out deposits, but redlining all the time through every gear? Can someone please explain to me how that will make your car last longer?!
Originally Posted by moconnor
driving the **** out of it
Originally Posted by GoodfellaFD3S
Ok, I'll bite. What the hell are you talking about
?
?People using rotary engines for aviation have been doing it for years and they tear down and rebuild their engines on a schedule.
Surely no one exists on the planet that never redlines the car every time they drive it, thats why i bought mine, and i love.... and i do mean love to clean out those carbon deposits at any opportunity, lmao
What is detonation then exactly, i thought it was igniting the mix too early so it trys to send it the other way, im kinda new
What is detonation then exactly, i thought it was igniting the mix too early so it trys to send it the other way, im kinda new
Originally Posted by MADDSLOW
You can enjoy it a lot longer when it's running...
Got 80k on my reman, 148k on chassis and turbos. Daily driven, boosting every time I drive it. It's all about taking care of it. Changed oil/filter every 2k with ONLY Mazda filters and Valvoline 20w-50.
But I could be the exception.
Originally Posted by TheWoganSleeve
Surely no one exists on the planet that never redlines the car every time they drive it
Originally Posted by TheWoganSleeve
Surely no one exists on the planet that never redlines the car every time they drive it...
Originally Posted by TheWoganSleeve
What is detonation then exactly, i thought it was igniting the mix too early so it trys to send it the other way, im kinda new
I'm curious about which model you're "Importing", and why nobody has replied to that yet.
Have you looked into this yet? If not, start searching for MANY topics about it. It's not easy.
Have you looked into this yet? If not, start searching for MANY topics about it. It's not easy.
Last edited by tdazmansFD; Jan 19, 2007 at 07:14 PM.
All the things you and others specified are good and ESSENTIAL except:
I've never heard of getting a vented hood, but it makes sense given the high underhood temperatures (much is from the pre-cat though).
The engine should be redlined from time to time to keep it clean.
Oil is oft debated. But bad quality synthetics are definately a no-no. Good synthetics should be listed in the FAQ.
The following site has a good project car. Besides many performance upgrades, they also get heavily into reliability upgrades. Every one I've ever seen in fact. They say you can can some major power gains (without losing reliability), with just some bolt-ons. Something to consider.
http://www.sportcompactcarweb.com/projectcars/
Besides things you and others mentioned (these are all ESSENTIAL):
Replace all vacuum lines with silicone ones.
Retune the ECU to run a bit rich. ECU must be retuned again after every power upgrade, like removing the pre-cat.
Turbo timer.
Other:
On the subject of driving hard, the rotary takes high rpms pretty well. Poor FD reliability stems mainly from the components I and others are telling you to replace.
On the subject of FD horror stories, they're all true. It's usually NOT the owner's fault, you MUST replace the things people are telling you to replace or you will have a very unreliable car. Find a rotary specialist; other mechanics scratch their heads with FDs. Do all that and the FD should be reliable. Us FC drivers don't have to deal with bad FD components. Those of us who don't buy lemons have cars that never give us any real trouble.
Regular maintenace is a must on any car. Good quality oil (at least API SX, where X is highest letter available) and good quality gasoline (Chevron, Texaco, 76 or Shell, plus some minor brands I won't list) are helpful to keep the engine clean.
I've never heard of getting a vented hood, but it makes sense given the high underhood temperatures (much is from the pre-cat though).
The engine should be redlined from time to time to keep it clean.
Oil is oft debated. But bad quality synthetics are definately a no-no. Good synthetics should be listed in the FAQ.
The following site has a good project car. Besides many performance upgrades, they also get heavily into reliability upgrades. Every one I've ever seen in fact. They say you can can some major power gains (without losing reliability), with just some bolt-ons. Something to consider.
http://www.sportcompactcarweb.com/projectcars/
Besides things you and others mentioned (these are all ESSENTIAL):
Replace all vacuum lines with silicone ones.
Retune the ECU to run a bit rich. ECU must be retuned again after every power upgrade, like removing the pre-cat.
Turbo timer.
Other:
On the subject of driving hard, the rotary takes high rpms pretty well. Poor FD reliability stems mainly from the components I and others are telling you to replace.
On the subject of FD horror stories, they're all true. It's usually NOT the owner's fault, you MUST replace the things people are telling you to replace or you will have a very unreliable car. Find a rotary specialist; other mechanics scratch their heads with FDs. Do all that and the FD should be reliable. Us FC drivers don't have to deal with bad FD components. Those of us who don't buy lemons have cars that never give us any real trouble.
Regular maintenace is a must on any car. Good quality oil (at least API SX, where X is highest letter available) and good quality gasoline (Chevron, Texaco, 76 or Shell, plus some minor brands I won't list) are helpful to keep the engine clean.
Last edited by ericgrau; Jan 19, 2007 at 08:19 PM.
A propperly prepared, tuned and maintained rotary is an extremely reliable and long lived powerplant. Even greater than the average reciprocating piston engine. Mazda won (outright) the 24 hrs of Le Mans with a rotary - perhaps the most grueling engine endurance race on the planet. Mazda is the only Japanese manufacturer to do so. The vaunted (and well deserved) quality of Toyota's powertrains has never done it. Mazda did it because of the inherent reliabilty of the rotary design and a factory team of engineers who knew what they were doing.
There is alot of misinformation on this board spread by members who cannot hold a candle to those Mazda engineers. But there are also members who have written alot of big checks over the years learning through individual trial and error what works and what doesn't. You're task is to try and separate the wheat from the chaff.
My advise: don't believe the "rotaries are unreliable" crap. But accept as an immutable law of nature that you cannot shortcut or shortchange propper preparation, tuning and maintenance of a rotary. If you're a shadetree mechanic and want to mod a rotary start your efforts with a very big checking account.
There is alot of misinformation on this board spread by members who cannot hold a candle to those Mazda engineers. But there are also members who have written alot of big checks over the years learning through individual trial and error what works and what doesn't. You're task is to try and separate the wheat from the chaff.
My advise: don't believe the "rotaries are unreliable" crap. But accept as an immutable law of nature that you cannot shortcut or shortchange propper preparation, tuning and maintenance of a rotary. If you're a shadetree mechanic and want to mod a rotary start your efforts with a very big checking account.
I have this same argument on mustang site...to them rotaries are cursed POS. Any engine could end up as POS if they got beat the heck out of it. Rotaries got a bad rap from the begining this was because they were mistreated. No one know jack about them...not to mention the complex sequential turbo system...at the time mechanics were scratching their heads...
To address your original question of maximizing longevity:
1) Start with a well-built motor. Mazda remans are good, but sometimes have an out-of-spec component in the mix. Aftermarket rebuilders range from crap to excellent, but are not cheap. If you want the engine to last longest, you ideally want all brand new housings for the best possible tolerances, surface finishes, and hardness. Use the best quality o-rings and seals and replace as many as possible.
2) Improve cooling system to keep engine temperatures as even as possible. Run it around 200-220F. I'm not convinced cooler is better, but 200f-220f is a whole lot better than the original stock system did. So installing a bigger radiator and changing the thermoswitch will help avoid the high temp events much better. Change the coolant every year to help keep deposits from junking up in the cooling passages.
3) Drive the engine gently for at least 5 minutes at the beginning of each drive, and drive it gently for the last couple at the end. Idling is IMHO just time to develop more heat soak when you shut it off. Turbo timers don't work - they just put the car through more heat-soaking idling.
4) Boost = higher temps. Higher temps = shorter engine life. Period. Choose the least amount of boost for your needs if engine life is a concern. Past experience shows that with proper maintenance, a stock ported motor will last 75-100k if it's well maintained and luck is on your side. Lower boost = longer life on average. The less time the engine spends driving under boost, the longer it will last. Boost slowly kills engines, and that's that.
5) I don't think you will find 'bad' synthetic oils. Use a quality oil, synthetic or mineral based, and change it frequently enough to avoid much fuel dilution. Many folks change at 2k. Make sure the oil injection system is working, and use premix if you're paranoid about it.
6) I don't think gasoline matters too much, except to always use sufficient octane. IMHO, it matters a whole lot more to make sure the injectors are clean and flowing to spec since dripping or sticking injectors run rich/lean and either one will substantially increase EGTs.
7) If you're using a tunable ECU, tune for reasonable EGTs, possibly have a low power and high power setting. With the low power setting you can have the tuner set it up for lower EGTs.
Dave
1) Start with a well-built motor. Mazda remans are good, but sometimes have an out-of-spec component in the mix. Aftermarket rebuilders range from crap to excellent, but are not cheap. If you want the engine to last longest, you ideally want all brand new housings for the best possible tolerances, surface finishes, and hardness. Use the best quality o-rings and seals and replace as many as possible.
2) Improve cooling system to keep engine temperatures as even as possible. Run it around 200-220F. I'm not convinced cooler is better, but 200f-220f is a whole lot better than the original stock system did. So installing a bigger radiator and changing the thermoswitch will help avoid the high temp events much better. Change the coolant every year to help keep deposits from junking up in the cooling passages.
3) Drive the engine gently for at least 5 minutes at the beginning of each drive, and drive it gently for the last couple at the end. Idling is IMHO just time to develop more heat soak when you shut it off. Turbo timers don't work - they just put the car through more heat-soaking idling.
4) Boost = higher temps. Higher temps = shorter engine life. Period. Choose the least amount of boost for your needs if engine life is a concern. Past experience shows that with proper maintenance, a stock ported motor will last 75-100k if it's well maintained and luck is on your side. Lower boost = longer life on average. The less time the engine spends driving under boost, the longer it will last. Boost slowly kills engines, and that's that.
5) I don't think you will find 'bad' synthetic oils. Use a quality oil, synthetic or mineral based, and change it frequently enough to avoid much fuel dilution. Many folks change at 2k. Make sure the oil injection system is working, and use premix if you're paranoid about it.
6) I don't think gasoline matters too much, except to always use sufficient octane. IMHO, it matters a whole lot more to make sure the injectors are clean and flowing to spec since dripping or sticking injectors run rich/lean and either one will substantially increase EGTs.
7) If you're using a tunable ECU, tune for reasonable EGTs, possibly have a low power and high power setting. With the low power setting you can have the tuner set it up for lower EGTs.
Dave
From what I gather four (very general) factors play a crucial role in engine longevity:
1.) proper cooling
2.) proper fuel management
3.) proper upkeep (replacing seals, vacuum lines, filters, oil, etc.)
4.) and proper driving habits
I'm glad someone mentioned the bit about turbo timers not being the ideal way to end a hard driving session. A few minutes of softer driving is always the best.
------------- FYI ----------------
The car is an efini rx-7 type R.
The specs: http://specs.amayama.com/specs-mazda...-august/14051/
1.) proper cooling
2.) proper fuel management
3.) proper upkeep (replacing seals, vacuum lines, filters, oil, etc.)
4.) and proper driving habits
I'm glad someone mentioned the bit about turbo timers not being the ideal way to end a hard driving session. A few minutes of softer driving is always the best.
------------- FYI ----------------
The car is an efini rx-7 type R.
The specs: http://specs.amayama.com/specs-mazda...-august/14051/
Originally Posted by megatron
From what I gather four (very general) factors play a crucial role in engine longevity:
1.) proper cooling
2.) proper fuel management
3.) proper upkeep (replacing seals, vacuum lines, filters, oil, etc.)
4.) and proper driving habits
1.) proper cooling
2.) proper fuel management
3.) proper upkeep (replacing seals, vacuum lines, filters, oil, etc.)
4.) and proper driving habits
The reason for the turbo timer is b/c, I presume, you don't boost at idle. I've seen a turbo in one of my lab classes and it glows orange hot (not just red hot), even at low throttle & low rpm. Now imagine leaving stagnant oil on the turbo bearing when you immediately shut your car off. Ouch. Doesn't the 1st turbo kick in at 1500rpm? How slow do you drive during cooldown? (35mph in 5th??) I dunno, but I've only heard of idling your car, not slow driving. The purpose is to cool the turbo so it won't fry the bearing and bearing oil when the oil stops moving.
Last edited by ericgrau; Jan 21, 2007 at 07:10 PM.
Originally Posted by ericgrau
The reason for the turbo timer is b/c, I presume, you don't boost at idle. I've seen a turbo in one of my lab classes and it glows orange hot (not just red hot), even at low throttle & low rpm. Now imagine leaving stagnant oil on the turbo bearing when you immediately shut your car off. Ouch. Doesn't the 1st turbo kick in at 1500rpm? How slow do you drive during cooldown? (35mph in 5th??) I dunno, but I've only heard of idling your car, not slow driving. The purpose is to cool the turbo so it won't fry the bearing and bearing oil when the oil stops moving.
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,678
Likes: 96
From: Bay Area, CA
Originally Posted by ericgrau
The reason for the turbo timer is b/c, I presume, you don't boost at idle. I've seen a turbo in one of my lab classes and it glows orange hot (not just red hot), even at low throttle & low rpm. Now imagine leaving stagnant oil on the turbo bearing when you immediately shut your car off. Ouch. Doesn't the 1st turbo kick in at 1500rpm? How slow do you drive during cooldown? (35mph in 5th??) I dunno, but I've only heard of idling your car, not slow driving. The purpose is to cool the turbo so it won't fry the bearing and bearing oil when the oil stops moving.
There has not been a single turbo failure on an FD attributed to coking.
You are applying 10+ year old knowledge (that only really applied to the older more primitive oil designs of that time) to a car with turbos that are not even oil cooled.
Heyy guys, I'm not siding with anyone when I ask this, but why is it that even though the stock turbos are water-cooled that so many twin turbo FD owners are still using turbo timers? Is it denial or lack of knowledge? I'm just curious because there are so many threads pointing out how useless the turbo timers are and people continue to use them.
Originally Posted by ericgrau
The reason for the turbo timer is b/c, I presume, you don't boost at idle.
I've seen a turbo in one of my lab classes and it glows orange hot (not just red hot), even at low throttle & low rpm.
Now imagine leaving stagnant oil on the turbo bearing when you immediately shut your car off. Ouch. Doesn't the 1st turbo kick in at 1500rpm?
How slow do you drive during cooldown? (35mph in 5th??) I dunno, but I've only heard of idling your car, not slow driving.
Slow driving works because there is incoming airflow to keep the coolant and oil cooler. If you had a boost gauge, you might already know that your right foot has complete control over whether the car is boosting or not.
Idling relies on the fans, which don't run constantly, to provide airflow. No airflow leads to higher temps.
The purpose is to cool the turbo so it won't fry the bearing and bearing oil when the oil stops moving.
Dave
Last edited by dgeesaman; Jan 21, 2007 at 07:47 PM.
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 30,783
Likes: 642
From: FL-->NJ/NYC again!
This is turning into a pretty good thread, lots of good information here.
Just for another data point, my current engine (which I ported and built) has over 10,000 hard miles of primarily 15 to 17 psi boost, primarily with my old BNR stage 3 setup and now with a healthy single. I barely drive the car, so when I do I am on it quite a bit. Compression checked out not to long ago to a nice even 105 psi across the board
One thing I've noticed since removing my a/c system---my coolant temps stay much more stable, and are much more likely to hang around 85 to 90 degrees. With my old SMIC installed, seldom did my fans come on when I was driving on the street, even boosting the car repeatedly on the highway. Without the condensor in the way of the rad, you're getting alot more airflow to it. Of course, now I have a blitz fmic installed, so we'll see what happens now
Just for another data point, my current engine (which I ported and built) has over 10,000 hard miles of primarily 15 to 17 psi boost, primarily with my old BNR stage 3 setup and now with a healthy single. I barely drive the car, so when I do I am on it quite a bit. Compression checked out not to long ago to a nice even 105 psi across the board

One thing I've noticed since removing my a/c system---my coolant temps stay much more stable, and are much more likely to hang around 85 to 90 degrees. With my old SMIC installed, seldom did my fans come on when I was driving on the street, even boosting the car repeatedly on the highway. Without the condensor in the way of the rad, you're getting alot more airflow to it. Of course, now I have a blitz fmic installed, so we'll see what happens now
Originally Posted by moconnor
You are applying 10+ year old knowledge (that only really applied to the older more primitive oil designs of that time) to a car with turbos that are not even oil cooled.
As for that sport compact car web article, it matches other sources I've read, and what's being said in this thread in fact. Except in regard to the turbo timer and ECU retuning. But ECU retuning should be necessary to keep the engine from running lean whenever you upgrade the exhaust/intake/etc., no?






