RX7Club.com - Mazda RX7 Forum

RX7Club.com - Mazda RX7 Forum (https://www.rx7club.com/)
-   2nd Generation Specific (1986-1992) (https://www.rx7club.com/2nd-generation-specific-1986-1992-17/)
-   -   RX8 6 speed in FC (https://www.rx7club.com/2nd-generation-specific-1986-1992-17/rx8-6-speed-fc-403986/)

flamin-roids 03-12-05 07:28 PM

RX8 6 speed in FC
 
Ok Hers the plan. I can get a steal on a new RX8 transmission. A friend of mine tells me that with my current TII drivetrain setup (bolted to a '89 N/A) the transmission will bolt right up to the TII flywheel etc. Now of course I'll need a custom crossmember , RX8 slave cylinder, and shifter assembly. THe whole escapade will cost me roughly $1200 compared to the $700 price to rebuild my TII transmission (with custom modifications). Now my question is will the swap be worth it? I'll have closer gears and the 3.90 auto rear is going to be replaced with a TII rear with 4.30 ring and pinion. Any thoughts on this subject?

13bturbo2 03-12-05 07:37 PM

closer gear ratios do improve acceleration somewhat, sounds quite interesting though, just one question: is the rx8 tranny as strong or stronger than the TII tranny? i mean if later on you decide to swap to a TII engine or 13rew or whatever.

vrooom305 03-12-05 08:07 PM

What about the bell housing and the driveshaft will they be custom made or what? Also will the RX-8 shifter line up with the FC's shifter hole?

BlaCkPlaGUE 03-12-05 08:20 PM


Originally Posted by vrooom305
What about the bell housing and the driveshaft will they be custom made or what? Also will the RX-8 shifter line up with the FC's shifter hole?


Thats a really good question. The engine does sit lower than the regular rotarys, but its still a 13B with the same displacement, honestly I think the bell housing will be the same size as the other trannys. What might not work, is the bolt pattern, as im sure they are different, maybe you need an adapter plate?


Where are you buying the 8 tranny btw?

How much is it through the dealer?


Strength, like the other guy was saying, I don't know. But it supports the 5psi kit from greddy, so obviously the tranny is much better than the NA one.

Impreza2RX7 03-12-05 08:24 PM

Damn, if this works, I might look into this down the road

13bturbo2 03-12-05 08:25 PM

it sucks to be referred to as: "the other guy" lol

therotaryrocket 03-12-05 09:08 PM

i read that mazda kept the rotary bellhousing and bolt pattern but i forgot where i read that. i think a 6th gear would be awesome, also the rx8 trans is made for 10,000 rpms so it might be more well balanced or something like that, but isn't the rx8 driveshaft aluminum or carbon fiber or something crap? the rx8 sure is beatiful.

vipers 03-12-05 09:17 PM

well about the strenght thing..... they have to be strong concidering they come with more hp than a t2......... there is a guy running a 500 hp 3-rotor rx8 w/ the stock 6-speed... so im sure it can handle the power!! :)

im almost certain they retained the same bellhousing pattern.... but you'll need the rx8 starter (might be different), slave cylinder, a custom driveshaft, and all the shifter mumbo-jumbo....

the big question is......... will it line up with the shifter hole of a fc........ ill have to measure speeddemons rx8 and see if they are the same

flamin-roids 03-12-05 09:20 PM

Well the trans has already been measured. Its the exact same length. Also the shifter will only be off by about 1/2 inch. It will bolt directly up to the engine and the starter will even fit. AS long as TII drive train parts are being used it will work apparantly. AS far as strength goes I don't know. My friend rebuilt it and said that the input shaft and amongst other parts were just as big as the FD's. I'll have to fabricate a crossmember and get some custom speedo setup because apparantly the RX8 trans doesn't have a gear for the speedo cable.

Funkspectrum 03-12-05 09:31 PM

I myself was wondering about this idea. I'm interested in doing the 6-speed swap....

F1blueRx7 03-12-05 09:47 PM


Originally Posted by flamin-roids
Well the trans has already been measured. Its the exact same length. Also the shifter will only be off by about 1/2 inch. It will bolt directly up to the engine and the starter will even fit. AS long as TII drive train parts are being used it will work apparantly. AS far as strength goes I don't know. My friend rebuilt it and said that the input shaft and amongst other parts were just as big as the FD's. I'll have to fabricate a crossmember and get some custom speedo setup because apparantly the RX8 trans doesn't have a gear for the speedo cable.



Did you put a t2 drive shaft in it yet to test the tail section to make sure the splines fit?

VietFC 03-12-05 10:05 PM

the rx8 has known problems of tranny breaking at high horsepower. I've even heard stories of breaking just by running at the track with slicks. I don't think it'd be a very wise choice. Keep looking around.

BlaCkPlaGUE 03-12-05 10:21 PM

Hmm im just waiting for reted or Nz to start posting, and literally shatter all of our hopes ;)

flamin-roids 03-12-05 10:58 PM

Well my friend said the TII and even the FD driveline fit. He was going to put it into his vert but lost interest. I asked him about how strong they are and he said the way it was built it looks just as strong as a TII or FD trans. HE said regardless of the trans if you have a dipshit driver downshifting from 10k rpm from like 2nd to 5th then that shits going to happen. However I've only got a mildly modded S5 N/A engine so power handling isn't an issue. And besides. Name one FC or any 7 with a RX8 trans. I'm going to make the measurements myself with it side by side with a TII trans.

ddub 03-12-05 11:00 PM

Guys, I really wouldn't do this if you're going to be putting much power through your car, like turbo guys for example.

The RX-8 transmission is NOT strong at all! It is built to handle stock and a little past stock but can die soon after. There are RX-8 owners that have broken their trannies at 250rwhp. That is a rare occasion as most that break them have 270+ rwhp, but there have been cases of them dying at as low as 250.

Also, I'm not sure how well it would fit. From what I understand, or have heard, with RX-8 owners that have too much power for the stock tranny they are switching to FD transmissions, but don't quote me on this because this is just what I recall reading. I think what I read is that the FD tranny is a pretty good match and fit, but if that's the case I'm not sure how well it'd fit in the FC without modification as I didn't think the FD tranny was a drop in for the FC. Once again I can't remember exactly but this is just what I'm recalling.

There are other factors that make the RX-8 a totally different drive than just the ratios of the gears in the tranny. I don't really think this is a good idea, especially someone with a turbo for example. I'd just stick with a TII drivetrain and be happy with that.


Oh I just recalled a situation of the stock RX-8 tranny breaking. JudgeITO had a completely stock RX-8 except for a "special" streetport done to his engine. There was absolutely no change besides the streetport, and he broke his transmission. I think Mazda addresses this with the late 04's and 05's, though, because it seemed all the people destroying their trannies were 03 and early 04. Plus, since then JudgeITO has done tuning and added a bunch of nitrous, so I'm guessing the later model ones have it worked out, because he had his replaced (obviously).

NZConvertible 03-12-05 11:07 PM


Originally Posted by vipers
well about the strenght thing..... they have to be strong concidering they come with more hp than a t2...

Horsepower does not break gearboxes, torque does. Compare the RX-8's 164ft-lb to the S4 TII's 183ft-lb and the S5 TII's 196ft-lb. Suddenly an RX-8 gearbox behind a modified 13BT doesn't seem so smart...


...there is a guy running a 500 hp 3-rotor rx8 w/ the stock 6-speed...
Are you sure about that?


Originally Posted by BlaCkPlaGUE
Hmm im just waiting for reted or Nz to start posting, and literally shatter all of our hopes

Sorry about that... ;)

ddub 03-12-05 11:11 PM


Originally Posted by NZConvertible
Are you sure about that?


I know I'm not ;)

You guys should really do research about this on rx8club.com, not rx7club for how much they can handle :rolleyes:

flamin-roids 03-13-05 02:59 AM

Did I mention that this won't be bolted to a turbo motor? The decision has been made as far as that goes. If I'm going turbo then I'm going FD. However a lightly modded N/A with close gears and a 4.30 rear end will surprise a few people and be my daily driver. I'm just looking at the cost and hassle (guessing it will be the same as doing an auto>5speed swap) to see if its worth it. I'm not worried about the 160 hp this motor puts down breaking anything.

JDUBrx7 03-13-05 03:27 AM

the renesis rotary is claimed 240 hp stock. A s4 t2 is 180..... an s5 is 200 i belive.... Shouldnt be a problem, should it?

ddub 03-13-05 03:30 AM


Originally Posted by JDUBrx7
the renesis rotary is claimed 240 hp stock. A s4 t2 is 180..... an s5 is 200 i belive.... Shouldnt be a problem, should it?




Originally Posted by NZConvertible
Horsepower does not break gearboxes, torque does. Compare the RX-8's 164ft-lb to the S4 TII's 183ft-lb and the S5 TII's 196ft-lb. Suddenly an RX-8 gearbox behind a modified 13BT doesn't seem so smart...



.

BlaCkPlaGUE 03-13-05 04:25 AM

You know, I did alot of searching last week on NA trannys. There were a few people here that said the NA was used up to 500hp, even on non rx7 cars.

They all agreed on one thing, dropping the clutch will kill the tranny.
If you can do a launch without hammering the shit out of the tranny, apparently it can take it. Its been discussed before, you just have to be carefull and smart, as in, not do a burnout all the freakin time ;)

Im not making that shit up, I searched it and found those comments.

Funkspectrum 03-13-05 04:29 AM

lots of good info....

ddub 03-13-05 04:31 AM


Originally Posted by BlaCkPlaGUE
You know, I did alot of searching last week on NA trannys. There were a few people here that said the NA was used up to 500hp, even on non rx7 cars.

They all agreed on one thing, dropping the clutch will kill the tranny.
If you can do a launch without hammering the shit out of the tranny, apparently it can take it. Its been discussed before, you just have to be carefull and smart, as in, not do a burnout all the freakin time ;)

Im not making that shit up, I searched it and found those comments.

I know Kevin Landers had an N/A tranny on his turbo vert when he had it and the gears got eaten to shit. He had a thread to show the tear down of it and basically all the gears except 5th/revers got ground to nothing over time. And he didn't have 500hp that's for sure.

SonicRaT 03-13-05 04:47 AM

Basically, NZ's still right. By dumping the clutch you're applying a shitload of torque instantly (which will slaughter it) By being gentle and just accelerating, you're not applying torque so violently and you're applying less of it, this will of course be a lot easier to deal with, but eventually the parts are going to wear and/or break depending upon just how much torque you feed it.

Attila the Fun 03-13-05 07:33 AM


Originally Posted by NZConvertible
Horsepower does not break gearboxes, torque does. Compare the RX-8's 164ft-lb to the S4 TII's 183ft-lb and the S5 TII's 196ft-lb. Suddenly an RX-8 gearbox behind a modified 13BT doesn't seem so smart...

Based on what I have been told, that's the bottom line. As I understand it, the RX-8 gearbox is the same as the Miata 6-speed. For the Miata or the stock, low-torque Renesis engine, it's just fine.

Some people who are upgrading their RX-8s are going to relatively low-priced T-II gearbox's to handle the higher power.

I was considering going to a 6-speed for my stock convertible and adding a 4.3 rear end. This notion was based on the mistaken belief that the Mazda 6-speed, like the Chevy (Camaro) 6-speed had 4th as it's 1:1 ratio and two overdrive ratios above that. However, the Mazda gearbox has 5th as its 1:1 and a numerically higher 6th gear than the T-II gearbox, so I couldn't see any advantage.

RX-Heven 03-13-05 12:52 PM


Originally Posted by vipers
well about the strenght thing..... they have to be strong concidering they come with more hp than a t2......... there is a guy running a 500 hp 3-rotor rx8 w/ the stock 6-speed... so im sure it can handle the power!! :)

That car uses a 3rd gen tranny with GURU dogbox internals.

Think of it this way, they stuck an extra gear in a smaller package. That means the gears/internals are physically smaller. Smaller gears are not the best thing for high torque/hp cars.

I can't think of one reason to fit one of those tranny's in a 1-3 gen RX.
If you really want a 6th gear, there are much better alternatives.

MRX_Rotary 03-13-05 01:43 PM

What about using an FB tranny for closer gear ratios?

vipers 03-13-05 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by RX-Heven
That car uses a 3rd gen tranny with GURU dogbox internals.

Think of it this way, they stuck an extra gear in a smaller package. That means the gears/internals are physically smaller. Smaller gears are not the best thing for high torque/hp cars.

I can't think of one reason to fit one of those tranny's in a 1-3 gen RX.
If you really want a 6th gear, there are much better alternatives.

lol..... i read that info in "import racer" a while back.... so, i assumed they knew what they were talking about....... everyone is wrong from time to time.... sorry for the mis-info!!!

BlaCkPlaGUE 03-13-05 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by RX-Heven
That car uses a 3rd gen tranny with GURU dogbox internals.

Think of it this way, they stuck an extra gear in a smaller package. That means the gears/internals are physically smaller. Smaller gears are not the best thing for high torque/hp cars.

I can't think of one reason to fit one of those tranny's in a 1-3 gen RX.
If you really want a 6th gear, there are much better alternatives.

Like what? People here are asking about having a 6 speed transmission that works, the rx8 one will work. Its obviously not the best choice as discussed above, so let us know whats an alternative! Can't stand when people just cut off ideas.. let us know what your talking about please.

thx

Snrub 03-13-05 05:36 PM

RX-8 Gear Ratios: 3.76:1, 2.27:1, 1.65:1, 1.19:1, 1.00:1, 0.84:1
Final drive 4.44:1

Type-M Gear Ratios: 3.475:1, 2.002:1, 1.366:1, 1.000:1, .0711:1
Type-R Gear Ratios: 3.483:1, 2.015:1, 1.391:1, 1.000:1, 0.762:1

I'm no transmission expert, but I don't know that you'd acheive that much of an advantage. It looks to me like you might get better from a stop acceleration because of the taller first gear, but other than each gear seems to have a similar difference inbetween them. Often the biggest claimed advantage of a 6-speed is the improved fuel economy. I think your fuel economy would be noticably worse on the highway and perhaps the similar elsewhere.

RX-Heven 03-13-05 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by BlaCkPlaGUE
Like what? People here are asking about having a 6 speed transmission that works, the rx8 one will work. Its obviously not the best choice as discussed above, so let us know whats an alternative! Can't stand when people just cut off ideas.. let us know what your talking about please.

thx

Late model Supras and F-bodies can be made to work or just about any other 6-speed for that matter.
Kennedy Engineering can adopt just about any tranny to any engine, all you need is money.
Contact them for specifics.

iceblue 03-13-05 08:40 PM

Well I have a 04 RX-8 AT and I am having trany problems allready as well.
I personal would be interested in puting the 6sped in a 7 thow the RX-8trany 6sp is the same 6sp tranny that is in the miata. Acording to mazda the AT is a stronger tranny then the 6sp and quit a bit acualy. Thow the load carectoristics stock on the AT are horrble and defanitly need reprogrammed.

ddub 03-13-05 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by iceblue
Well I have a 04 RX-8 AT and I am having trany problems allready as well.
I personal would be interested in puting the 6sped in a 7 thow the RX-8trany 6sp is the same 6sp tranny that is in the miata. Acording to mazda the AT is a stronger tranny then the 6sp and quit a bit acualy. Thow the load carectoristics stock on the AT are horrble and defanitly need reprogrammed.

English?

Anyways, the Auto tranny rx8's also have a worse engine and lower redline, so of course they'll last longer.

rx7raca 03-13-05 10:06 PM

Heres a good idea. Instead of us trying to guess what the out come will be. Why not just try it? If flamin roids wants to give it a try. Then let him do it.

We can only gain information from experience.

For some reason I always see threads like this, pple saying well what if this, what if that. It means nothing.

Will someone please try this tranny crap, an post pics and info an let us know how it is.

IMO, the rx8 would be good for any Na rotary, just for the fact of the smooth tq curve.

Good luck.

Whizbang 03-13-05 11:20 PM

fook it all, get an allison and never have another trans problem again. as long as you dont idle in gear.

unek87 03-13-05 11:58 PM

mrx rotary said something bout a fb tranny well bout 2yrs ago i had to replace my clutch and come to find out that my 2nd,3rd gears were going out (past owner) the mechanic said that he had rolled his fb 6 months before and it was just setting there.we got to talking and i bought it for $75 and it had just been rebuilt not to long before he rolled it but anyway i dont know the ratios of the gears or anything but i do know that going through the gear box the fb is quicker in my eyes this was bolted up to a n/a if the rx-8 for some reason doesnt workout try that just my 2cents

flamin-roids 03-14-05 12:10 AM

Well the cool factor is definitly on the RX8 tranny's side. A 6 speed FC will be a rare one. BUt I do like the gear ratio on the TII trans and I'm not to thrilled about having to rig a speedo sensor. I'm sorta reconsidering it but the experience will definitly be useful. Is there no one who has attempted this?

gotrotors? 03-14-05 08:47 AM

Another problem will be that(i think) it is a pull type clutch instead of a push. If this is true, because it is in the 3rd gen rx7, youre gonna need to use the rx8 flywheel, clutch, etc.


sounds to be more trouble than its worth. Bottom line is mazda trannys SUCK ASS!!!!


Im on my third tII tranny. My first was s4, my second was s5, my third is s5.


S5 tranny tII is stronger. The only problem im having is synchros blowing, then taking out the tranny after awhile, losing 5 and reverse.


One more thing. Mazda could have very well changed the bell housing, seeing as how its not a regular 13b. dont forget, the renesis uses side exhaust ports. They could have possibly changed the casting completely, as well as changing how the bell housing bolts up.



Look into all of this before making a rash decision.

Snrub 03-14-05 12:10 PM

I thought that the whole reason behind the exclusive use of the lower powered renesis engine in the automatic was because Mazda didn't have a torque converter that could handle the torque or revs. The torque/power argument doens't make a lot of sense to me because other Mazda RWD cars like the FD and Cosmo have more torque.

The Type-R trannys seem to be rather stout. gotrotors, I think you've just had some lousy luck. My car at 152k miles and is on it's original tranny.

MRX_Rotary 03-14-05 03:52 PM


Originally Posted by unek87
mrx rotary said something bout a fb tranny well bout 2yrs ago i had to replace my clutch and come to find out that my 2nd,3rd gears were going out (past owner) the mechanic said that he had rolled his fb 6 months before and it was just setting there.we got to talking and i bought it for $75 and it had just been rebuilt not to long before he rolled it but anyway i dont know the ratios of the gears or anything but i do know that going through the gear box the fb is quicker in my eyes this was bolted up to a n/a if the rx-8 for some reason doesnt workout try that just my 2cents

Yeah, the ratios in the FB are shorter, depending on the year. I was thinking about doing this myself since I could probably get an '80 or '81 tranny for free or cheap.

'80 & '81 gear ratios (look at iluvmyrx7.com or something for other years):
1st: 3.674
2nd: 2.217
3rd: 1.432
4th: 1.000
5th: .825

FC N/A gear ratios:
1st: 3.475
2nd: 2.002
3rd: 1.366
4th: 1.000
5th: 0.697

rx7raca 03-14-05 04:53 PM

flamin roids-

You said you measured both trannys right? So that would mean you saw the rx8 tranny. If you can see it again check out the bolt pattern. Also for you speedo, just buy an electirc autometer speedo gauge. Who needs speed anyways?;)

This can be done, it just takes time an money. How much of each I dont know. Find out some more info about the tranny an get back to us.(bolt pattern, shifter location, gauge wiring, etc.)

Good luck

jhammons01 03-14-05 05:25 PM

Couple of things.

Bolt pattern, get a rear iron and go hold it up next to the RX8 tranny and SEE if the bolt holes line up.

Get an E-shaft and SEE if the splines line up

Get a GPS and mount it to your dash for a Speedo. problem solved except mileage ticker.

turbine 03-14-05 08:04 PM

g

Attila the Fun 03-15-05 06:27 AM


Originally Posted by gotrotors?
Bottom line is mazda trannys SUCK ASS!!!!


Im on my third tII tranny. My first was s4, my second was s5, my third is s5.


S5 tranny tII is stronger. The only problem im having is synchros blowing, then taking out the tranny after awhile, losing 5 and reverse.

I'll politely disagree. I'm running an S4 T-II gearbox behind a 20B, putting out 478 lb/ft of torque. After 50,000 miles, it's still running strong. Truth-in-advertising: I don't do drag racing, which helps with longevity.

Switching to Redline gearlube made the synchros a lot happier. YMMV

Horse 03-15-05 08:13 AM

Guys I have an RX-8 and as much as I love it, the transmission sucks. It is the same transmision out of the Miata. We are having alot of trouble keeping them together when we have applications with more power, ie the SpeedSource team in the Pan-Am series said that every 6 races they have to replace the tranny. The Tranny will not take the power of the 13B-REWs and 20Bs that have been dropped in, they all use the thrid gen tranny. Now that we are finally getting turbo applications even more people are having problems from jsut daily driving. On my RX-8 I have SR pullies, SR high-flow CAT, K&N intake, Borla Exhaust, and ZEX wet Nitrous, so far I have not had alot of problems out of it but soon I will be adding the Greddy Turbo and I am a little worried about pushing it too hard on the track, that's why I got my FC. IF you plan on building this motor I would not suggest putting an RX-8 tranny in it, now if it is just for show a six speed RX-8 Tranny dramaticly increases the cool factor.

TitosToy 03-15-05 08:54 AM

it sounds like the best thing to do is to stick with the tII's or the 3rd gen. but the mazdaspeed rx8 coming out sometime next yr will be forced inducted (supercharger i believe) and hopefully mazda will put in a beefier tranny. IF that happens, then go for it.

Fire85GSLSE 03-15-05 09:31 AM

Six speed is what my gslse need bad! The car running 4k on the highway is bad.

mudbone 03-30-05 10:30 AM

Any one know the transmission code for an Rx8 tranny.

Snrub 03-30-05 12:13 PM


Originally Posted by Fire85GSLSE
Six speed is what my gslse need bad! The car running 4k on the highway is bad.

Compare the top gear ratios between the RX-8, what I posted and what MRX_rotary posted with the FB. (although I'm not sure why our FC numbers conflict - I took mine from Mazda's FC book by Yamaguchi) If you want to lower your highway revs the top gear ratio in the FC transmissions would appear to be the better choice.

MRX_Rotary 03-30-05 01:31 PM


Originally Posted by Snrub
Compare the top gear ratios between the RX-8, what I posted and what MRX_rotary posted with the FB. (although I'm not sure why our FC numbers conflict - I took mine from Mazda's FC book by Yamaguchi) If you want to lower your highway revs the top gear ratio in the FC transmissions would appear to be the better choice.

I got mine from this thread:
https://www.rx7club.com/2nd-generation-specific-1986-1992-17/specifications-what-did-2nd-generation-rx-7-come-w-options-standard-features-249616/

Apparently, the N/A's 5th gear ratios started changing from .711 to .697 in the 1987.5 and 1988 models and all N/A S5s have a .697 5th gear. I learn something new everyday. :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:43 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands