How to value your FD
#1901
Full Member
iTrader: (2)
Very interesting Fritz, I agree with all your points although I personally feel VR on tan is marginally less desirable than MB.
I've never been in a 94+ and had no clue that the build quality was that much better, I just assumed it was the trim panels changing. I knew the doors sounded different as well.
I've never been in a 94+ and had no clue that the build quality was that much better, I just assumed it was the trim panels changing. I knew the doors sounded different as well.
#1902
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
Very interesting Fritz, I agree with all your points although I personally feel VR on tan is marginally less desirable than MB.
I've never been in a 94+ and had no clue that the build quality was that much better, I just assumed it was the trim panels changing. I knew the doors sounded different as well.
I've never been in a 94+ and had no clue that the build quality was that much better, I just assumed it was the trim panels changing. I knew the doors sounded different as well.
The 94 cars are far and I mean FAR superior to 93. I've dissected a lot of FDs
Last edited by Fritz Flynn; 02-15-19 at 10:05 AM. Reason: correction
#1904
Full Member
The 95 MB (PEP) on Bring a Trailer posted the compression test results.
R1 - 6.8, 6.7, 6.8 (235 RPM); R2 - 6.6, 6.5, 6.6 (239 RPM)
I was expecting a bit better. Any thoughts?
R1 - 6.8, 6.7, 6.8 (235 RPM); R2 - 6.6, 6.5, 6.6 (239 RPM)
I was expecting a bit better. Any thoughts?
Last edited by jsesq; 02-15-19 at 01:27 PM.
#1905
Rx7 Wagon
iTrader: (16)
Did they do it warm? RPMs are a little low. Pulses are even. Probably needs to be driven. I'm sure it has lots of life left, and is not "at risk"
The soft seals and springs are probably long in the tooth, after 25yrs. You wouldn't be wrong to refresh the engine. If you replaced it, that block will make a really nice rebuild core for someone.
The soft seals and springs are probably long in the tooth, after 25yrs. You wouldn't be wrong to refresh the engine. If you replaced it, that block will make a really nice rebuild core for someone.
#1906
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
Did they do it warm? RPMs are a little low. Pulses are even. Probably needs to be driven. I'm sure it has lots of life left, and is not "at risk"
The soft seals and springs are probably long in the tooth, after 25yrs. You wouldn't be wrong to refresh the engine. If you replaced it, that block will make a really nice rebuild core for someone.
The soft seals and springs are probably long in the tooth, after 25yrs. You wouldn't be wrong to refresh the engine. If you replaced it, that block will make a really nice rebuild core for someone.
RPMs may be a little low but I'd expect better then 96 psi on the low side. I think normal cranking speed is 250.
I'd expect 7s or higher or say 105 plus #s from this car. But I'll keep repeating it. Compression isn't the end all be all BAT on lookers seem to think it is. This car will still sell for 30k plus IMO.
#1907
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
Just checked the auction and the peanut gallery loves to talk about compression.
I can see worrying about compression if you are not able to view/test drive the car BUT if it starts hot, runs smooth when hot (has a smooth idle at 750 and below with no vibration or rocking) you have good compression in your rotary engine car. There's no way I'm buying any of these cars on BAT without a long conversation with the owner followed up with a PPI that may or may not include a compression test.
I'd care more about the above then whatever compression test results came back. Also you need to consider if the testers held the gas pedal down, pulled both plugs at once, have a bad tester/leaky tester, etc...etc...
Again the things to worry about regarding engine health: does it idle like a rock at 700 to 750 when beaten on for 20 minutes during the test drive. Next shut it off for 5 minutes and restart. Does it fire right up or take a little more cranking. A little more and compression may be a little low or a lot more and a compression test is in order. Won't start it probably needs a new engine and you renegotiate. If it's a low mileage car and I'm paying close to retail I want a 5k discount LOL.
Lastly bring a boost gauge and 15 feet of hose attach it to the UIM. Go for ride and see what's what. The majority of these 25 year old low mileage FDs likely have boost issues. The vacuum will also tell you a lot about the engine health. If above 15 then it's probably healthy if not you could have issues. That said if it's above 15 and idling at 1000 well that's a problem. These cars should idle at 750 max once warmed up and the engine should be quiet and smooth.
I can see worrying about compression if you are not able to view/test drive the car BUT if it starts hot, runs smooth when hot (has a smooth idle at 750 and below with no vibration or rocking) you have good compression in your rotary engine car. There's no way I'm buying any of these cars on BAT without a long conversation with the owner followed up with a PPI that may or may not include a compression test.
I'd care more about the above then whatever compression test results came back. Also you need to consider if the testers held the gas pedal down, pulled both plugs at once, have a bad tester/leaky tester, etc...etc...
Again the things to worry about regarding engine health: does it idle like a rock at 700 to 750 when beaten on for 20 minutes during the test drive. Next shut it off for 5 minutes and restart. Does it fire right up or take a little more cranking. A little more and compression may be a little low or a lot more and a compression test is in order. Won't start it probably needs a new engine and you renegotiate. If it's a low mileage car and I'm paying close to retail I want a 5k discount LOL.
Lastly bring a boost gauge and 15 feet of hose attach it to the UIM. Go for ride and see what's what. The majority of these 25 year old low mileage FDs likely have boost issues. The vacuum will also tell you a lot about the engine health. If above 15 then it's probably healthy if not you could have issues. That said if it's above 15 and idling at 1000 well that's a problem. These cars should idle at 750 max once warmed up and the engine should be quiet and smooth.
#1908
Rotary Freak
iTrader: (12)
I agree Fritz. If the car drives well, cold and hot starts well, and pulls good vacuum, then that's all that matters. The bickering over compression numbers just deters prospective new-comers to an FD. I'm sure there's a ton of piston motor cars that have "borderline spec" compression, but the buyers and sellers dont know or care because the car drives fine. But when a rotary pops up, compression is always the forefront of the conversation.
The following users liked this post:
Fritz Flynn (02-16-19)
#1909
rotorhead
iTrader: (3)
As far as how well these BaT cars boost: well my opinion is that you need to assume any car that is mostly original needs a vac job and solenoid replacement (as I've pointed out, parts are like $200 for all the OEM sequential switching solenoids). That was one of the first things after I got my car.
The following users liked this post:
Fritz Flynn (02-18-19)
#1912
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
Tough to say but that was one of the best deals yet on BAT.
#1913
Senior Member
yeah, the difference in those 2 Montego's is way more than $7K
#1914
2 FD's since '98
iTrader: (11)
No v8 swap pricing? Well sorted ones seem to all be $30, right?
I dont know about this 94 OEM that sold, I just watched it sell right behind another car I own. Looked like the bumper was warped as per usual. Final hammer $32k + $3200 auction house fees.
In my minds eye, the more buyers that see $25k+ FDs over and over in long sales, the better it is for everyone. (Also LOVE seeing totaled FD’s:-)
Last edited by rajeevx7; 02-19-19 at 11:35 PM.
#1915
rotorhead
iTrader: (3)
The seller is in California and made a big mistake selling in February, unless he really needed it gone now. When I lived in NC I didn't really understand how half the country goes into hibernation during winter regarding car things. If you live in Chicago, New York, Minneapolis, Chicago, or anywhere in flyover country there isn't a good logistical way to get the car home from California. The roads are impassible if you try do a long road trip (ice and snow through the mountains). There may be a pile of snow in your street... you can't even drive the car into your garage if somebody ships it from across the country and drops it off at the end of the block, because it doesn't have winter tires. There's salt everywhere.
The pool of potential buyers is much lower if you sell in February. Not only that, a lot of people are just now getting around to filing their taxes and likely aren't ready to make a big purchase (haven't gotten their return, or maybe even owe money). This sale isn't a good indicator of market demand. Half the market is dormant until at least April.
The pool of potential buyers is much lower if you sell in February. Not only that, a lot of people are just now getting around to filing their taxes and likely aren't ready to make a big purchase (haven't gotten their return, or maybe even owe money). This sale isn't a good indicator of market demand. Half the market is dormant until at least April.
#1916
rotorhead
iTrader: (3)
The guy selling this car made a mistake doing it in February. It is logistically very difficult to buy a sports car for half the country, due to snow and salt on the ground. You can't even get the car into your driveway if it has summer tires and there's ice on your street. There's a reason why peak sports car season starts in May. You may have ice in April in a lot of places. I didn't understand this until I moved to the Midwest.
For that reason I don't think you can draw a broad conclusion on the market. Some enthusiast in say the Chicago area isn't thinking about buying an FD when it's 10 degrees out and snowing twice a week.
For that reason I don't think you can draw a broad conclusion on the market. Some enthusiast in say the Chicago area isn't thinking about buying an FD when it's 10 degrees out and snowing twice a week.
#1917
Rotorhead for life
iTrader: (4)
If this one is available you should consider it. Likely equally as clean. Just needs a detail.
https://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-...ckType=listing
https://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-...ckType=listing
#1918
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
The guy selling this car made a mistake doing it in February. It is logistically very difficult to buy a sports car for half the country, due to snow and salt on the ground. You can't even get the car into your driveway if it has summer tires and there's ice on your street. There's a reason why peak sports car season starts in May. You may have ice in April in a lot of places. I didn't understand this until I moved to the Midwest.
For that reason I don't think you can draw a broad conclusion on the market. Some enthusiast in say the Chicago area isn't thinking about buying an FD when it's 10 degrees out and snowing twice a week.
For that reason I don't think you can draw a broad conclusion on the market. Some enthusiast in say the Chicago area isn't thinking about buying an FD when it's 10 degrees out and snowing twice a week.
#1919
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
^That one is likely sold or off the market. Tried to contact the seller via the ad 2x, no response, even though I made it clear I have cash to blow and am a quick road trip away.
This was a great deal if you live on the west coast and can drive the car home. I may be a bit more objective and less enthusiastic about FDs than you guys, but I couldn't see myself spending more than ~$30K for this particular example. The compression results didn't bother me - they were typical for a <50K mile FD, but when you add in the 5% BaT buyers fee, and shipping cost from the west coast (~$2.2K enclosed, $1.2K open trailer) this one would have cost me about $30K for an FD that has a sunroof (prefer R1/R2s or base) and isn't my favorite color combo. Given it's February, and cross country shipping on an open trailer would have salted & chipped the crap out of it, enclosed shipping is the only smart choice.
Market maybe cooling a bit, but I think it had more to do with poor timing (Feb) which results in a smaller potential market for this guy. Basically you're shipping thru snow/ice season, so you're looking at more expensive enclosed shipping unless you're a local buyer.
This was a great deal if you live on the west coast and can drive the car home. I may be a bit more objective and less enthusiastic about FDs than you guys, but I couldn't see myself spending more than ~$30K for this particular example. The compression results didn't bother me - they were typical for a <50K mile FD, but when you add in the 5% BaT buyers fee, and shipping cost from the west coast (~$2.2K enclosed, $1.2K open trailer) this one would have cost me about $30K for an FD that has a sunroof (prefer R1/R2s or base) and isn't my favorite color combo. Given it's February, and cross country shipping on an open trailer would have salted & chipped the crap out of it, enclosed shipping is the only smart choice.
Market maybe cooling a bit, but I think it had more to do with poor timing (Feb) which results in a smaller potential market for this guy. Basically you're shipping thru snow/ice season, so you're looking at more expensive enclosed shipping unless you're a local buyer.
If I didn't own an FD and wanted one I'd buy the best one I could find asap because I still believe this market is just starting to take off.
#1921
Full Member
This thread is never ending! I love it!
This thread. Crazy long. I love it!
Hey guys!
I fell outta here for awhile. Some worthless piece of **** was trying to bring me down when I was looking for my first FD.
Negativity isn't my game. . I'm glad to recently be back and seeing positive stuff here!
Soon I hope to be looking for my second FD!
MB BABY!
Hello again to everyone!
Hey guys!
I fell outta here for awhile. Some worthless piece of **** was trying to bring me down when I was looking for my first FD.
Negativity isn't my game. . I'm glad to recently be back and seeing positive stuff here!
Soon I hope to be looking for my second FD!
MB BABY!
Hello again to everyone!
The following users liked this post:
Fritz Flynn (02-21-19)
#1922
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
It went to 26 in a hurry which I'm sure cut through the BS bidders.
Most of the good deals I recall on BAT have been MB cars which I think also explains the low bidding. I'd love a 95 base mb.
#1923
All out Track Freak!
Thread Starter
iTrader: (263)
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Charlottesville VA 22901
Posts: 10,672
Received 416 Likes
on
252 Posts
I agree, totally crazy. I also believe we will see and FD sell for 75k in the next 2 years which will be equally insane.
YEP perfect comparison. FD sold for 49k and supra for 121 or approx 2.5 times. I think the FD will have gained substantial ground by 2025, OR NOT....lol..... clearly my view of the Supra doesn't align with the market. I have love for the supra, the 300 ZX and the FD but the FD is the clear winner in looks, performance and drive/vibe. Big looser though in reliability and overall build quality.
To me it's worth a lot more..... LOL
To me it's worth a lot more..... LOL
The following users liked this post:
Greg Sabol (02-22-19)
#1924
Fritz...thanks for your insight, interested reading! I've had a 93 base for 24 years, stolen/recovery, which gave it a rebuild title here in Florida. I bought the car because I knew it's history, with 32k miles, never hit, just missing some parts. It's up to 78k miles now. I've kept it basically stock, I did all the R1 mods with Mazda parts, kept the base seats, had them red stitched to match the red stitched console/shift boot/E brake. 3M Carbon wrapped all the interior plastics. Flawless expensive red re-paint. Up grades are the Koyo radiator, the Pettit AST, silicone hoses, stainless brake lines, 18" wheels, Eibach springs, RB dual tip exhaust/down pipe, FC Commander. I've restored a lot of cars, this one I kept because it's just about as perfect as it gets, meticulous maintenance, runs perfect. You mentioned the 94 model, what did Mazda change from the 93's, I know the interior plastics were changed, what else was improved, and what do you think my '93 would sell for? 6 months ago I bought a 2007 Honda S2000 for a DD. The S2000 is another incredible car, and easy to work on!
Last edited by Greg Sabol; 02-22-19 at 06:53 PM.
#1925
A friend 4 months ago in Arcadia Florida called me and said a dealer had a '93 R1 33k miles....asking 27k for it....I told my friend, offer 24k.....bargain ....but get it! He got it for 25k.....a clean Florida car, he got a good deal...I wish I could have bought it!