fmic bov question
do you have to run a bov when you run a fmic...i know it prevents surge but is it really nessesary? not very familure with this subject..legit pros(besides sound) / cons
|
Uhhhh.....Ya.
|
ha expecting a little more info other than uh yea..i mean im trying to see why other than just yea...icemark? aaroncake? i tryed searching
|
Originally Posted by t24todd
(Post 7728100)
ha expecting a little more info other than uh yea..i mean im trying to see why other than just yea...icemark? aaroncake? i tryed searching
|
you didn't search well enough:
www.howstuffworks.com yielded this>>>http://www.thedodgegarage.com/turbo_bov.html If that isn't good enough then wikipedia has this>>> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowoff_valve |
Stock turbo? You can get away with not running one, but you dramatically decrease the life of the turbo.
Aftermarket turbo? Are you big ballin? Can you buy aftermarket turbo's often? If so, go ahead and NOT run one. Other wise, I would if I were you..... |
no i am running the stock turbo/giant ported wastegate and purchasing fmic..i knew that compressor surge would be generated but @ 10psi didnt know if it is really that much to comprimise..
|
it's your car. Let us know how long the turbo lasts like this. This is the perfect opportunity to see what kind of damage the turbo can take.
miles on turbo? |
uh well its original as i believe and that would mean 102k lik on the chassis..thanks for the info i searched this forum and didnt find what i was looking for..thanks for the other threads though..awnsered most my questions..i will be purchasing one
|
the search feature is handy but you gotta be able to use it to it's full potential. I found these within 10 seconds:
https://www.rx7club.com/showthread.p...=BOV+necess%2A https://www.rx7club.com/showthread.p...=BOV+necess%2A https://www.rx7club.com/showthread.p...=BOV+necess%2A Dial8 and I have been discussing BOVs for a couple of days now and the threads posted above are informative and long so just start reading. BTW: ^^^^^^^^^^THAT'S HOW YOU SEARCH. I tried "BOV Necess*" and those were the three that popped out at me. I'm sure I can narrow it down some more but I'm kinda busy at work. |
Originally Posted by NCDA
(Post 7728179)
Stock turbo? You can get away with not running one, but you dramatically decrease the life of the turbo.
|
Originally Posted by NZConvertible
(Post 7728439)
Pure, unadulterated BS. The BOV does nothing to increase the stock turbo's lifespan. Nothing.
ever since I can remember I've heard/read that you really don't want the turbine spinning in the opposite way because it will cause damage. At first I questioned it since the turbine can freely spin one way or another right? It won't magically be unable to spin the opposite way. Well, the surge of air still has to stop the turbine and internal components from spinning one way and would then HAVE spin the opposite way. That is until you're boosting again and it stops the opposite spin to spin the right way. Over time this will cause wear and tear on the internals and THAT HAS to reduce the life of the turbo unit. If this guy goes without one we'll be able to say "the turbo lasted THIS long without it and THIS long with it". EDIT: found this too. Not as informative but it was directed at a 16year old so I don't think he wanted to waste too much time. The blow-off valve should not be confused with a waste-gate. The waste-gate is a device that by-passes the turbine wheel of the turbocharger, limiting the shaft-speed of the turbocharger. Therefore, limiting the boost (pressure) that the compressor generates and keeping the turbocharger from over-speeding. A blow-off valve is mounted in the intake plumbing between the turbocharger compressor and the throttle plate. The blow-off valve is a second safety measure against the turbocharger over-boosting and damaging the engine. The blow-off valve is more commonly used to keep the turbocharger spinning when the throttle plate is suddenly closed. When the turbocharger is generating maximum boost pressure at full throttle and then the throttle is suddenly closed, compressed air coming from the compressor slams against the throttle, generating extremely high pressures that travel backwards to the compressor stopping the compressor from spinning. When the throttle plate is again opened, the engine must spool the turbocharger shaft again. The effects of this high pressure can also be very damaging to the turbocharger. Brian Wright Washington University in St. Louis Formula SAE Racing |
This has been covered in great detail in other threads. The only people who'll tell you BOV's protect turbos from damage are the people marketing and selling BOV's, and those they've managed to convince.
My old 12AT never had a BOV in it's entire life, and yet despite the abuse it regularly got the high-km turbo died from the same reason most of them do; a failed oil seal. |
Originally Posted by Marcel Burkett
(Post 1584974)
I have owned five tubocharged cars , and the were all equiped with factory installed BOV's ( I make it a point to purchace "untouched " cars ).
As for race cars ....... remember its a race and engine RPM , and hence throttle opening is expected to be in the upper ranges allowing a very high flow of air through the engine / turbo for maybe the entire race .The minimum FORWARD flow through the turbo would then be satisfied thereby keeping the turbo safely away from the SURGE LIMIT.,so I guess the fitting of a BOV isn't warrented here , but on a road going vehicle , we all know what happens with traffic , putholes, pedestrians ,cops, pets etc forcing us to come off the gas and to have to mash the clutch and brake pedals.
Originally Posted by Marcel Burkett
(Post 1582857)
I have been in the energy industry down here for the last 12 years and every one of the large compressors in use on these plants has an ANTISURGE system which does exactly what the BOV does ,ie. once the discharge flow falls below the surge limit of the compressor a controller will automatically open a valve and recycle the discharge flow back to the suction there by maintaining a minimum flow through the machine ( the BOV will vent to atmosphere which is the turbos suction ) , I have also been close to these guys when these valves / controllers fail to operate , trust me it will scare the shit out of you , it shakes very large steel structures like they were made of sticks and they also make awful loud groulig , shrieking freightening sounds.
When these machines are taken apart for maintenance you can see a lot of internal damage due to surging requiring a change out of all the related parts. In my book physics is physics weather it is on a large or small scale , the same thing would occur , as Max explained , there would be a "violent" reversal in flow once the throttle is closed which would surely over load and eventually cause damage to the turbo , on the NISSAN RB20 engines that use the ceramic turbine wheels (we have those engines in abundance here ) the turbine wheels are often severed by this as the compressor wheel is being forced to spin opposite to the turbine when there is no BOV and nowhere for the compressed air to go , but backward , when the throttle is closed. As we say down here it is better to be safe than sorry ,a BOV is cheap compared to replacing or repairing a large single , and also that thing about the valve failing and causing the turbo to over rev. , wouldnt you hear the air escaping ? , and most good quality valves use a diaphragm made of similar material to the waste gates' diaphragm , so what ,one shouldnt usea WG for fear of failure ?.
Originally Posted by RICE RACING
(Post 1573777)
Lets think about this for a second.
Why will your turbo be destroyed sooner without a BOV ? a thrust bearing is designed to take a certain amount of designed load at maximum boost, all that happens when you run the WG is that the thrust pulses down>down>down>down> just as reflected on a data logger 15psi WG setting may start to open at 10psi so the turbo is making 15psi, you shut the throttle the WG opens, boost drops WG closes, boost goes up WG opens and so on till there is no more boost pressure to open the gate at it's lowest spring opening pressure. Surley this cannot cause so much damage to the thrust bearing ? I have never loged a boost spike when not running the BOV valve, and I have never measured a noticable delay in boost pressure build up after a change of gear with the BOV bypassed. So I am having trouble seeing the exact problem, I mean for years and years WG was all that was used on every race. And many production cars too. I think the first production sports car I saw with a BOV was a Ferrari F40 in 1987 Ironically they came out with RX6 IHI Turbos
Originally Posted by CarbonR1
(Post 6383557)
BOV's are primarily in the OEM to reduce the noise from compressor surge. They are even used on diesel motors that have no throttling lose. When running without one, it theoretically the hardest on the thrust bearing/BB cartridge because when the throttle is closed, it tends to want to put an axial load on the rotating assembly towards the turbine side. This is due to the pressure being on the turbine side acting underneath the wheel to put the whole assembly in an quick axial load.
I don't think it would be possible to feel something like this from the driver's seat, because it happens so quickly. Also, it is not practical to compare DD turbo systems to racing turbocharging. For the sake of performance, reliability is often compromised. The turbos used in high racing applications are rebuilt after each race, so who would care if it was hard on the bearing system? I'm not a fan of the BOV sound, but they are there for a reason, even if performance is a bit lower. -Kevin
Originally Posted by Barban
(Post 7550583)
A wastegate, no matter how effective, can not eliminate the necessity for a BOV. A wastegate can only relieve backpressure from the turbo, which actually exascerbates the problem inherent to a no-BOV system(front pressure).
When you let off the gas under boost the compressor will continue to spin and build boost between itself and the closed throttle body until the force of the compressed air in front of the turbo is greater than the combined force of the exhaust pressure and momentum of the spinning CHRA. When the pressure of boost is greater than the absent exhaust pressure(thanks to the wastegate trying to replace the BOV) and the force generated by the momentum of the rotating assembly(which is a lot at 150,000rpm's) the compresser wheel and everything on the adjoining shaft will bounce off of the compressed air(instantly and violently, I might add). Modern turbocharger and metalurgy technology has made it possible to bounce your turbo and detonate on apex seals multipe times before failure. But, I like to look at it like this: Running a turbo car witout a BOV is like smoking cigarettes at the gas pump; you will get away with it for a while.
Originally Posted by mono4lamar
(Post 7548164)
I've seen surging that has bent the compressor fins... Am I the only one?
I'm sure we can go back and forth for days this way, but I don't wanna do it, but can you SEE why some would have a hard time knowing what is correct info and what isn't??? BTW, this was all found via searching so don't say you can't find a damn thing while searching. Isn't thing the second time today TODD :wink:? |
at stock or close to stock levels, a BOV is not needed
I had a Plymouth Conquest and it never had a BOV the engine failed before the turbo did |
Originally Posted by phoenix7
(Post 7728614)
...can you SEE why some would have a hard time knowing what is correct info and what isn't???
Car manufacturers' fit recirculating BOV's to eliminate the noise that's caused without one. It even says that in the FSM. As well as my own experience with my 12AT (admittedly only one example, but a good one), to me the best indication of how unnecessary they are is the fact that top-level endurance racers don't use them. Now if I said "racecars" don't use them, you could argue that they just replace the turbo after every race,but obviously endurance racing is completely different. If such a simple and cheap device reduced the chance of turbo damage, they would be used. Like I said, BOV's strongest proponents are usually the ones with their hand out for your money... :) |
thanks for the arguing of both sides...like i said i was looking for positive feedback on this subject because i admitted that i really had no experience with this subject..
|
To answer your original question, a FMIC makes no difference to whether you run one or not. It doesn't change a thing. ;)
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:22 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands