When transmissions fail...
#1
Raining 120mm fury
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: NC
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When transmissions fail...
The pics. are rather large and not the greatest clarity, but heres the background... I had my local shop install my ACT S/S clutch with the HD pressure plate. No biggie right? (They are Mazda Master Technicians btw) They even test drove it around before they gave me the thumbs up. Well... I got to drive the car less than 200 feet from their shop when the car would not go into ANY gear. Here is the "carnage."
http://i124.photobucket.com/albums/p...D/DSC00519.jpg
http://i124.photobucket.com/albums/p...D/DSC00520.jpg
The guys at the shop said that the bolts were stripped out of the bell housing. One of them was just lying in the housing! So they sent the whole transmission off to their machinist to helicoil?? (did I butcher that?) the studs back. Fun stuff... I figured that with my luck the transmission would have catastrophically failed, but I guess I "lucked out." Too bad... that Greddy 6 speed was looking pretty good.
http://i124.photobucket.com/albums/p...D/DSC00519.jpg
http://i124.photobucket.com/albums/p...D/DSC00520.jpg
The guys at the shop said that the bolts were stripped out of the bell housing. One of them was just lying in the housing! So they sent the whole transmission off to their machinist to helicoil?? (did I butcher that?) the studs back. Fun stuff... I figured that with my luck the transmission would have catastrophically failed, but I guess I "lucked out." Too bad... that Greddy 6 speed was looking pretty good.
Trending Topics
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Roaring Spring, PA USA
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Let me get this straight. You put a heavier duty clutch and pressure plate in. The bolts that hold the clutch fork pivot point pulled out of the aluminum threading because of increased force required to engage/disengage the clutch.
1. Are these in-fact, the bolts holding the fork pivot point to the bell housing? If not, what bolts are they and what are they holding down?
2. Did the technicians remove the fork hinge bolts for any reason?? Replacing the clutch should not require this removal at all. If they were not removed, they were factory torqued and met tolerances for stock pressure plate force.
3. If this is the bolts to the hinge point and it was my shop, I would say it is the car owner's fault for installing a clutch/PP combo that increased the force on the bolts beyond their load capabilities. Knowing that a heavier force Pressure Plate requires increased load forces, the assumption that the bolts are strong enough as is would be a mistake.
Just my .02 cents. Don't be so quick to judge or blame the mechanics. Some responsibility also lies with us to understand what exactly happened and in what order they happened.
Tim
1. Are these in-fact, the bolts holding the fork pivot point to the bell housing? If not, what bolts are they and what are they holding down?
2. Did the technicians remove the fork hinge bolts for any reason?? Replacing the clutch should not require this removal at all. If they were not removed, they were factory torqued and met tolerances for stock pressure plate force.
3. If this is the bolts to the hinge point and it was my shop, I would say it is the car owner's fault for installing a clutch/PP combo that increased the force on the bolts beyond their load capabilities. Knowing that a heavier force Pressure Plate requires increased load forces, the assumption that the bolts are strong enough as is would be a mistake.
Just my .02 cents. Don't be so quick to judge or blame the mechanics. Some responsibility also lies with us to understand what exactly happened and in what order they happened.
Tim
#10
Eye In The Sky
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: In A Disfunctional World
Posts: 7,892
Likes: 0
Received 114 Likes
on
66 Posts
Originally Posted by Tim McCreary
3. If this is the bolts to the hinge point and it was my shop, I would say it is the car owner's fault for installing a clutch/PP combo that increased the force on the bolts beyond their load capabilities. Knowing that a heavier force Pressure Plate requires increased load forces, the assumption that the bolts are strong enough as is would be a mistake.
Tim
FD owners have been using the ACT HD clutch for years and the only failures have been in the clutch fork it'self, not the fasteners. Mazda even redesigned the fork back in the 90s because it failed where a pin went through one of the arms.
We do not know the history of this transmission but your assumption is way off base about the HD clutch being the problem.
#11
Form follows function
iTrader: (8)
I have not ever--in 30 years--seen a failure like that. Someone hit those bolts with a [large] impact wrench. There is no way that the clutch load is going to cause those bolts to pull the threads out of the case--that had to result from overtorquing.
I agree that it can be repaired with heli-coils.
I agree that it can be repaired with heli-coils.
#12
Norcal RX7 Pimp
iTrader: (6)
Yeah its the clutchs fault.
I would guess that around 80% of the people on this board run a better than stock clutch. If the stronger pressure plate caused the throw out bearing pivot holding bolts to strip I would think we would be hereing this all the time. This is not normal. The clutch did not cause this. And in all reality ther was no reason for those bolt to be removed. The throw out bearing can be replaced with it still atached to the tranny.
It sounds like crapy work to me.
I would guess that around 80% of the people on this board run a better than stock clutch. If the stronger pressure plate caused the throw out bearing pivot holding bolts to strip I would think we would be hereing this all the time. This is not normal. The clutch did not cause this. And in all reality ther was no reason for those bolt to be removed. The throw out bearing can be replaced with it still atached to the tranny.
It sounds like crapy work to me.
#14
Slower Traffic Keep Right
iTrader: (5)
Originally Posted by Tim McCreary
2. Did the technicians remove the fork hinge bolts for any reason?? Replacing the clutch should not require this removal at all. If they were not removed, they were factory torqued and met tolerances for stock pressure plate force.
#15
ya man i no nuthin bout these cars cuz i just got one... but my step dad is a honda michanic... if sumthing goes wrong like this it would only be fair for them to repair it... in your case u might need all new internals depending if it was in the bell housing or the gear box itself...
pretty lame... dont be mad if they have a hard tiome workin with you and take 3 months
pretty lame... dont be mad if they have a hard tiome workin with you and take 3 months
#16
Couldn't stay away
iTrader: (5)
Originally Posted by Tim McCreary
3. If this is the bolts to the hinge point and it was my shop, I would say it is the car owner's fault for installing a clutch/PP combo that increased the force on the bolts beyond their load capabilities. Knowing that a heavier force Pressure Plate requires increased load forces, the assumption that the bolts are strong enough as is would be a mistake.
Granted, the FC clutch system is different from the FD. However I've installed several of ACT's Xtreme pressure plates including one in my own car and have never seen the pivot or the clutch fork wear/warp/bend.
#17
Raining 120mm fury
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: NC
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Alot of the questions and assumptions that you guys have posted have their merit. These mechanics have been doing various work on my other 2 rides and every car my Dad and sister have owned in the last 10 years. They run a very tight ship in terms of equipment and their own mechanical expertise. I'm not saying they didn't overtorque something or fudged it up somewhere along the install process, but it just doesn't jive with me either. I had never heard of anyone on here having a problem such as me with their transmission. I don't know enough about the components that makeup the transmission and their proper installation/removal to make a valid argument as to what went wrong and why. I figured it would be a little situation that those of you in the know so to speak could kick around for ***** and giggles as well as help give me a little more knowledge about the transmission/ clutch itself.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
MILOS7
3rd Generation Specific (1993-2002)
2
10-09-15 02:19 AM